TL;DR
This paper investigates how sustained compressive stress and the addition of fly ash and silica fume affect chloride ion transport in high-performance concrete (HPC). The researchers developed and validated a model that accurately predicts chloride diffusion in HPC under these combined conditions, crucial for improving the durability assessment of concrete structures in aggressive environments.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Concrete structures, especially those in marine environments, are susceptible to chloride-induced corrosion of reinforcing steel. High-performance concrete (HPC) offers improved resistance to chloride penetration due to the incorporation of supplementary cementitious materials like fly ash (FA) and silica fume (SF). However, many real-world concrete structures are subjected to sustained mechanical loads in addition to chloride exposure. Existing research often focuses on either the effect of admixtures or the effect of sustained loads, but rarely on their combined influence. This paper aims to fill that gap by experimentally quantifying and analytically modeling chloride transport in HPC with single and binary mineral admixtures under sustained compressive stress, which is essential for more accurate durability predictions of load-bearing concrete elements.
Methods
The study employed a two-pronged approach: experimental testing and analytical modeling.
Experimental: * Material Preparation: Concrete specimens (100 mm cubes) were cast using ordinary Portland cement, fly ash (Grade II), slag (S95), and a polycarboxylate superplasticizer. Different mix designs included ordinary concrete (C1), HPC with fly ash (HPC1), HPC with silica fume (HPC2), and HPC with both fly ash and silica fume (HPC12). * Sustained Compressive Loading: Specimens were subjected to sustained compressive stress levels of 0, 0.3 fc, and 0.5 fc (where fc is the compressive strength). * Chloride Exposure: A salt-spray test (5 wt% NaCl solution) was conducted for 180 days under controlled temperature (20°C) and humidity (95%). * Strain Measurement: Strain gauges were used to monitor surface strain evolution under different stress levels and admixture proportions. * Chloride Concentration Measurement: After exposure, concrete specimens were sampled at various depths (2 mm increments up to 20 mm, then 5 mm increments) using a grinding method. Water-soluble chloride concentration was determined using an ion-selective electrode method.
Analytical Modeling: * Diffusion Coefficient Model: An analytical equation for chloride ion diffusion in saturated concrete was established, incorporating the effects of admixtures (fly ash and silica fume percentages) and sustained compressive stress. * Model Development: The model was developed in two steps: first, determining the diffusion coefficient for ordinary concrete and the influence of admixtures, and second, incorporating the effect of compressive stress. * Validation: The developed model was validated against experimental data from this study and compared with existing experimental data from other researchers.
Datasets
The study utilized experimental data generated from the concrete specimens prepared and tested as described in the "Methods" section. This includes:
- Chloride concentration profiles at various depths for different concrete mixes and stress levels.
- Surface strain measurements under different loading conditions.
The paper also references and compares its model's predictions against experimental data from other published studies (e.g., Zhou et al. [11], Tang et al. [19], Fu et al. [44]) to validate its applicability.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Strain Behavior: Ordinary concrete exhibits the largest strain under load, while HPC with both fly ash and silica fume shows the smallest. This suggests that binary admixtures significantly enhance the concrete's ability to resist deformation under stress.
- Stress-Dependent Chloride Concentration: The relationship between compressive stress and chloride concentration is not linear. It initially decreases and then increases with rising stress levels. This non-monotonic behavior is attributed to complex interactions between pore structure compaction at low stresses and microcracking at higher stresses.
- Admixture Synergy: The combination of fly ash and silica fume is more effective in reducing chloride penetration than either admixture alone. This is likely due to silica fume refining pores and fly ash filling larger voids, creating a denser, more tortuous path for chloride ions.
- Model Validation: The developed diffusion coefficient model, which accounts for both admixtures and sustained stress, demonstrates good agreement with experimental data, indicating its potential for practical durability assessment.
Key Results
- Strain: Under a compressive stress of 0.5 fc, ordinary concrete showed significantly higher compressive strain (up to 61.5% more) compared to HPC with single or binary admixtures.
- Chloride Concentration:
- Ordinary concrete exhibited the fastest chloride diffusion rate.
- HPC with binary admixtures (fly ash and silica fume) showed the slowest diffusion rate.
- The chloride concentration in concrete generally decreased first and then increased with increasing compressive stress. Ordinary concrete showed the largest amplitude of change, while HPC with binary admixtures showed the smallest.
- Increasing silica fume content (while keeping fly ash constant) gradually decreased chloride concentration. At 17% silica fume, chloride concentration at 11 mm depth approached zero.
- Model Fit: The statistical analysis of the diffusion coefficient models (Equations 3 and 5) showed high R² values (0.965 and 0.973, respectively) and low RMSE, indicating good fits to the experimental data.
Limitations and Future Work
Limitations: * The salt-spray exposure was idealized, involving only one-sided exposure to a constant NaCl solution for 180 days. Drying-wetting cycles and carbonation coupling were not considered. * Specimens were limited to 100 mm cubes with a one-dimensional ingress boundary. Size effects and complex field boundary conditions were not addressed. * The study focused on sustained uniaxial compression; other loading regimes were not investigated. * Damage evolution was characterized using surface strain measurements; direct evidence of internal cracking and microstructural degradation was not obtained.
Future Work: * Develop an evolution model for the stress ratio considering different ages. * Investigate the influence of salt-spray deposition on surface chloride concentration. * Utilize advanced techniques like SEM, XRD, and MIP for microstructural interpretation and to examine relationships between residual strength, damage, and migration parameters. * Employ computer vision methods (e.g., DeepLab v3, EfficientNet) to quantify surface crack density and width for improved analysis.
Summary updated