Chiral symmetry breaking and monopole dynamics in noncompact<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:msub><mml:mi>QED</mml:mi><mml:mn>3</mml:mn></mml:msub></mml:math>coupled to a four-Fermi interaction

Wesley Armour, John B. Kogut, Costas StrouthosPhysical 2010 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We present results from the first lattice simulations of three-dimensional noncompact quantum electrodynamics (${\mathrm{QED}}_{3}$) with ${N}_{f}$ four-component fermion flavors coupled to a weak ${Z}_{2}$ chirally invariant four-fermi interaction. Results with ${N}_{f}\ensuremath{\ge}4$ show that the scaling near the strong coupling chiral transition or sharp crossover is determined by the $3d$ Gross-Neveu ultraviolet-stable renormalization group fixed point. Small deviations of the ${N}_{f}=4$ critical exponents from the respective Gross-Neveu ones, hint at evidence for nonzero fermion mass generated by the gauge fields dynamics that might have been enhanced by the four-fermi coupling. It is also shown that the scaling region is suppressed at weak four-fermi couplings and large ${N}_{f}$ values. Measurements of (i) a monopole susceptibility which is the polarizability of the monopole configurations, and (ii) the density of isolated monopoles, imply that for ${N}_{f}\ensuremath{\ge}1$ and weak gauge couplings the monopoles do not affect the theory's confining properties, because they are shielded.

Introduction

Three-dimensional non-compact Quantum Electrodynamics ($\text{QED}_3$) serves as a critical "toy model" in theoretical physics, offering insights into high-temperature superconductivity and the dynamics of 4D Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). A fundamental question in $ ext{QED}_3$ is the nature of chiral symmetry breaking: specifically, whether there exists a critical number of fermion flavors ($N_f$) below which particles spontaneously acquire mass.

Historically, analytical approaches like the Schwinger-Dyson equations and numerical lattice simulations have yielded conflicting results regarding this critical value. The primary difficulty lies in a "separation of scales"—the generated mass is often significantly smaller than the theory's natural energy scale, making it difficult to resolve on finite lattices. This study addresses this by introducing a weak four-Fermi interaction to the system, providing a computational "nudge" that allows for efficient probing of dynamics directly in the chiral limit.

Methodology

The researchers utilized Lattice Field Theory simulations based on the Hybrid Molecular Dynamics (HMD) R algorithm. The study employed a non-compact formulation, treating the gauge potential as a real number rather than a periodic variable, which is essential for accurately capturing the continuum limit.

Fermions were modeled using the staggered fermion method on lattice sizes ranging from $16^3$ to $42^3$. To facilitate the inclusion of the four-Fermi interaction, a "semi-bosonized" Lagrangian was used, introducing an auxiliary field $\sigma$ as an order parameter for chiral symmetry breaking. The parameter space explored included fermion flavors $N_f \in \{1, 2, 4, 8, 12\}$ and varying four-Fermi couplings $\beta_s$.

Scaling and Critical Exponents

For $N_f \ge 4$, the simulations reveal that the scaling behavior near the phase transition is dominated by the 3D Gross-Neveu ultraviolet-stable fixed point. This indicates that the four-Fermi interaction drives the transition even at weak couplings. However, subtle deviations in the critical exponents (specifically $\delta$) suggest that gauge field dynamics still contribute to mass generation, potentially enhanced by the four-Fermi term.

Chiral condensate $\langle \bar{\chi}\chi \rangle$ as a function of gauge coupling $\beta$ for various four-Fermi couplings $b_s$ and lattice sizes.

As shown in the data, the "scaling window"—the region where these mathematical relationships are valid—shrinks as the four-Fermi coupling weakens or $N_f$ increases, following a $1/\sqrt{\beta_s}$ relationship. The magnetic critical exponent $\beta_m$ was measured between 0.93 and 0.99 for $N_f = 4$, closely aligning with the theoretical Gross-Neveu value of approximately 0.93.

Fitting parameters and critical exponents for different four-Fermi couplings $\beta_s$.

Monopole Dynamics and Shielding

A significant finding of this work concerns the role of magnetic monopoles (instantons in 3D). By measuring monopole susceptibility—the polarizability of monopole configurations—the authors found that it does not diverge with volume. This lack of divergence implies that monopoles and anti-monopoles are tightly bound into neutral pairs, a phenomenon known as "shielding."

Because these monopoles are shielded rather than forming a free plasma, they do not contribute to the linear confinement of charges. This distinguishes non-compact $\text{QED}_3$ from other models where monopoles dictate long-distance confining properties. The density of isolated monopoles was observed to decay exponentially faster than the total monopole density as gauge coupling weakens, further supporting the shielding hypothesis.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that for $N_f \ge 4$, the chiral transition in $\text{QED}_3$ with a four-Fermi interaction is governed by Gross-Neveu scaling, while monopoles remain shielded and do not drive confinement. Future research will focus on the $N_f < 4$ regime, where gauge dynamics are expected to play a more prominent role, and will involve direct measurements of fermion dynamical mass through Landau gauge-fixed simulations.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present results from the first lattice simulations of three-dimensional noncompact quantum electrodynamics (${\mathrm{QED}}_{3}$) with ${N}_{f}$ four-component fermion flavors coupled to a weak ${Z}_{2}$ chirally invariant four-fermi interaction. Results with ${N}_{f}\ensuremath{\ge}4$ show that the scaling near the strong coupling chiral transition or sharp crossover is determined by the $3d$ Gross-Neveu ultraviolet-stable renormalization group fixed point. Small deviations of the ${N}_{f}=4$ critical exponents from the respective Gross-Neveu ones, hint at evidence for nonzero fermion mass generated by the gauge fields dynamics that might have been enhanced by the four-fermi coupling. It is also shown that the scaling region is suppressed at weak four-fermi couplings and large ${N}_{f}$ values. Measurements of (i) a monopole susceptibility which is the polarizability of the monopole configurations, and (ii) the density of isolated monopoles, imply that for ${N}_{f}\ensuremath{\ge}1$ and weak gauge couplings the monopoles do not affect the theory's confining properties, because they are shielded.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{armour2010chiral,
  author = {Wesley Armour and John B. Kogut and Costas Strouthos},
  title = {{Chiral symmetry breaking and monopole dynamics in noncompact<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:msub><mml:mi>QED</mml:mi><mml:mn>3</mml:mn></mml:msub></mml:math>coupled to a four-Fermi interaction}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.82.014503},
}
Figure