Abstract
In the study of dense quark matter, identifying the stability of various solutions to the gap equation is a significant challenge. This paper establishes a rigorous analytical relationship between chiral susceptibility and the thermodynamic potential within the Nambu–Jona-Lasinio (NJL) model. By demonstrating that singularities in chiral susceptibility coincide with bifurcation points of the gap equation, the authors provide a powerful diagnostic tool for mapping chiral phase transitions.
Introduction
Dynamical Chiral Symmetry Breaking (DCSB) is a fundamental phenomenon in Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) responsible for the majority of hadronic mass. At high densities or temperatures, this symmetry is restored through a chiral phase transition. Effective models like the Nambu–Jona-Lasinio (NJL) model are frequently used to explore this transition. However, these models often produce multiple mathematical solutions for the constituent quark mass ($M$), known as the gap equation. Determining which solution represents a physically stable state typically requires calculating the thermodynamic potential ($\Omega$), which can be computationally intensive in more complex frameworks.
Methodology
The authors utilize the NJL model with point-like four-fermion interactions. Using the Hartree approximation and the random phase approximation (RPA), they derive the gap equation to solve for $M$ as a function of the chemical potential ($\mu$) and current quark mass ($m$).
The central contribution of this work is the analytical derivation of the relationship between chiral susceptibility ($\chi = \partial M / \partial m$) and the second derivative of the thermodynamic potential: $$\chi = \frac{1}{G \frac{\partial^2 \Omega}{\partial M^2}}$$ This identity implies that $\chi$ diverges whenever the thermodynamic potential reaches an inflection point ($\partial^2 \Omega / \partial M^2 = 0$), marking the boundaries of stability for different solution branches.
Results and Discussion
The Chiral Limit ($m=0$)
In the chiral limit, the system exhibits distinct branches of solutions for the quark mass. Figure 1 illustrates the constituent quark mass $M$ as a function of the chemical potential $\mu$.
At low $\mu$, the Nambu solution (massive) is stable. As $\mu$ increases, the Wigner solution (massless) undergoes a "trifurcation" at $\mu = 335.59$ MeV, where it transitions from unstable to metastable. Eventually, the Nambu solutions coalesce and vanish at $\mu = 397.23$ MeV.
The behavior of the chiral susceptibility $\chi$ perfectly mirrors these structural changes in the gap equation solutions. As shown in Figure 2, $\chi$ exhibits singularities exactly at the bifurcation points.
The top panel of Figure 2 shows $\chi$ for the Nambu branch, which diverges as it approaches the point of disappearance at $\mu = 397.23$ MeV. The bottom panel shows the susceptibility for the Wigner branch, which diverges at the trifurcation point $\mu = 335.59$ MeV.
Beyond the Chiral Limit
When a non-zero current quark mass ($m = 5.6$ MeV) is introduced, the "trifurcation" is replaced by more complex bifurcation patterns. However, the fundamental link between $\chi$ singularities and the emergence or annihilation of states remains intact. The analysis confirms that the chiral phase transition in the NJL model is of the first order, characterized by a discontinuous jump between metastable states.
Conclusion
This research provides a clear mathematical bridge between the response of quark masses to environmental changes and the underlying thermodynamic stability of the system. By using chiral susceptibility as a proxy for the curvature of the thermodynamic potential, researchers can identify phase transition points and solution stability without the need for direct potential calculations. This approach holds significant promise for application in more sophisticated frameworks like the Dyson-Schwinger Equations (DSE), where explicit thermodynamic potentials are often unavailable.
Summary updated