Abstract
Local or global ordering of chiral molecules at a surface is a key step in both chiral separation and heterogeneous enantioselective catalysis. Using density functional theory and scanning probe microscopy results, we find that the accepted structural model for the well known bitartrate on Cu(110) chiral system cannot account for the chiral segregation observed. Instead, we show that this strongly bound, chiral adsorbate changes its adsorption footprint in response to the local environment. The flexible adsorption geometry allows bitartrate to form stable homochiral trimer chains in which the central molecule restructures from a rectangular to an oblique footprint, breaking its internal hydrogen bonds in order to form strong intermolecular hydrogen bonds to neighbouring adsorbates. Racemic structures containing mixed enantiomers do not form strong hydrogen bonds, providing the thermodynamic driving force for the chiral separation that is observed experimentally. This result shows the importance of considering the dynamical response of molecular adsorption footprints at the surface in directing chiral assembly and segregation. The ability of strongly-chemisorbed enantiomers to change footprint depending on the local adsorption environment indicates that supramolecular assemblies at surfaces may exhibit more complex dynamical behaviour than hitherto suspected, which, ultimately, could be tailored to lead to environment and stimuli-responsive chiral surfaces.
Introduction
Chiral segregation—the spontaneous separation of a racemic mixture into distinct enantiopure domains—is a cornerstone of 2D surface science. Understanding the mechanisms behind this "Pasteur resolution" at the molecular level is critical for developing enantioselective catalysts and chiral separation technologies. For over a decade, the adsorption of bitartrate on Cu(110) has served as the prototypical model for such studies. However, the prevailing structural model for this system faced significant challenges: it failed to explain the thermodynamic preference for homochiral domains and could not account for the anomalous brightness of certain molecules in Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM) images.
Methodology
To resolve these discrepancies, researchers employed a dual approach combining high-resolution experimental imaging with state-of-the-art computational modeling.
- Experimental Imaging: Ultra-high vacuum STM was conducted at cryogenic temperatures (77 K and 100 K) to visualize the molecular arrangements of bitartrate on the Cu(110) surface with sub-molecular resolution.
- Computational Modeling: Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations were performed using the VASP code. A key advancement in this study was the use of the
optB86b-vdWfunctional, which accurately incorporates dispersion (van der Waals) forces. This allowed for a more realistic assessment of the intermolecular interactions that drive assembly. - Simulated STM: The Tersoff–Hamann approximation was used to generate simulated STM images from DFT-optimized structures, enabling direct validation against experimental data.
The Dynamic Footprint and Chiral Assembly
The central discovery of this work is that bitartrate molecules are not rigid upon adsorption. Instead, they exhibit a "dynamical footprint" that responds to the local environment. While an isolated bitartrate molecule prefers a "rectangular" footprint ($R_{ec}$) due to stabilizing internal hydrogen bonds, the presence of neighboring molecules can trigger a structural transition.
In homochiral trimer chains, the central molecule adopts an "oblique" footprint ($O_a$). This transition requires the molecule to break its internal hydrogen bonds, but this "sacrifice" is more than compensated for by the formation of exceptionally strong intermolecular hydrogen bonds with adjacent molecules.
Key Results
The proposed $R_{ec}O_aR_{ec}$ trimer model successfully reconciles theory with experiment:
- Thermodynamic Stability: The new model is 0.123 eV per molecule more stable than the previous model where all molecules retained the $R_{ec}$ footprint.
- Driving Force for Segregation: This footprint switching and subsequent strong intermolecular bonding only occur efficiently in homochiral arrangements. In racemic (mixed) structures, the geometric mismatch prevents these strong bonds from forming, creating a significant energy penalty that drives the observed chiral segregation.
- STM Contrast: The shift to the $O_a$ footprint alters the electronic density of the central molecule, causing it to appear brighter in STM images—a phenomenon that was previously unexplained.
- Surface Strain Management: The model also accounts for the "bare copper channels" observed between molecular chains. The adsorption causes a slight expansion (~2.6%) of the copper lattice; these channels act as strain-relief zones.
Implications and Future Outlook
This study highlights that even strongly chemisorbed molecules can possess significant conformational flexibility. The ability of an adsorbate to change its footprint in response to its neighbors suggests that surface assemblies are more dynamic than previously thought.
Beyond bitartrate, this "footprint response" mechanism may be a general feature of chiral assembly on surfaces. Furthermore, the sensitivity of these footprints to the local environment—including the presence of other polar species like water—opens the door to designing stimuli-responsive chiral surfaces. In the context of heterogeneous catalysis, understanding these local structural variations is essential for predicting and controlling the enantioselectivity of chemical reactions on modified surfaces.
Summary updated