China and Africa: A new narrative on debt sustainability and infrastructure financing

Yan Wang, Yinyin XuJournal of Infrastructure Policy and Development 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper argues that current debt sustainability assessments are flawed because they focus solely on what governments owe (liabilities) while ignoring what they own (assets). By analyzing over 3,000 Chinese-financed projects in Africa, the authors demonstrate that the majority of these investments are strategically targeted at critical infrastructure bottlenecks, creating productive public assets that underpin long-term economic growth.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global financial community is increasingly concerned about a looming debt crisis in the Global South, particularly in Africa. However, the authors argue that the standard tool for measurement—the Debt Sustainability Analysis (DSA) used by the IMF and World Bank—suffers from a significant "anti-investment bias."

Traditional DSAs typically look at debt-to-GDP ratios. They treat all debt the same, whether the money was spent on government consumption (like salaries and pensions) or on productive infrastructure (like ports and power grids). This "liability-only" narrative ignores the asset side of the public sector balance sheet. If a country borrows to build a railway that lowers transport costs and boosts exports, that debt is fundamentally different from debt used to plug a budget deficit. The authors seek to shift the narrative toward "net worth"—assets minus liabilities—as a more accurate measure of a country's fiscal health.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged empirical approach to test whether Chinese-financed projects actually address the most urgent needs of host countries:

  1. Infrastructure Development Index: They created a standardized index across nine indicators (four "hard" sectors like energy and transport; four "soft" sectors like health and education) for 54 African countries from 2000 to 2017. This allowed them to quantify "bottlenecks"—sectors where a country is significantly behind its peers.
  2. Econometric Modeling:
    • Probit Model: Used for hard infrastructure projects, which are typically large, discrete, and located in fewer countries. This model estimated the probability that a project would be located in a "bottleneck" sector.
  3. Linear Regression: Used for soft infrastructure projects (like schools or clinics), which are more numerous and widely distributed.
  4. Bottleneck Identification: They developed a novel ranking method using percentiles within income groups (low-income vs. middle-income) to identify the top four "hard" and top three "soft" bottlenecks for every country.

Datasets

The study draws from several high-profile sources:

  • AidData’s Global Chinese Development Finance Dataset (v2.0): Used to track 3,126 completed projects in Africa financed or co-financed by China between 2000 and 2017.
  • World Bank International Debt Statistics (IDS) & World Development Indicators (WDI): For debt ratios and general economic data.
  • Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME) & World Governance Indicators (WGI): For soft infrastructure metrics.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Good Debt" Hypothesis: Debt used to build operational public assets (hydro plants, bridges, telecom networks) generates essential services, jobs, and tax revenue. These assets can be worth twice a country's GDP, yet they are often entirely unaccounted for in debt discussions.
  • Debunking the "Debt Trap": The data suggests that Chinese investment isn't "rogue" or "predatory" in its targeting. Instead, it shows high "relevance" and "efficacy," meaning projects are statistically likely to be placed in the sectors where the host country is most backward.
  • The "Sum of Assets" Approach: The authors propose that instead of traditional debt restructuring, countries could use "asset-based refinancing." For example, if a government has paid off 30% of a project loan, that 30% represents equity. They could package equity from multiple projects to attract "patient capital" from sovereign wealth funds or green funds.

Key Results

The empirical results strongly support the idea that Chinese-financed projects are well-targeted:

  • Hard Infrastructure: 76.1% of the 468 studied projects matched the identified bottlenecks of the host countries. The probability of "hitting" a top-tier bottleneck was highest for transport and energy.
  • Soft Infrastructure: 73.4% of the 1,246 studied projects matched identified bottlenecks, particularly in health and education.
  • Comparative Advantage: The study notes that Chinese development projects often improve socioeconomic outcomes at both national and subnational scales, with impacts comparable to—or sometimes superior to—those generated by the World Bank.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several critical caveats:

  • Efficiency vs. Relevance: While the projects are relevant (targeted at the right sectors), the study does not have enough granular data to evaluate their efficiency (cost-effectiveness) or long-term impact.
  • "White Elephants": Roughly 22% of hard infrastructure and 26% of soft infrastructure projects did not match identified bottlenecks, suggesting the existence of some "white elephant" projects that may not be demand-driven.
  • Negative Externalities: The paper notes that Chinese projects can be associated with negative externalities, including environmental degradation, corruption, and political instability, which require more rigorous future study.
  • Data Gaps: There is a dire need for African nations to conduct "asset mapping" to properly value their public wealth, as current data is often incomplete or unaudited.

Summary updated

Abstract

Strategic and collective efforts are needed from both the creditors and borrowing countries facing the looming debt crisis, with a full understanding of what are good debts and what are bad debts depending on how they are used. The current narrative on debt sustainability often ignores the issue of what a government owns (assets) versus what a government owes (liabilities). While conventional approaches largely focus on the liability side, the kinds of assets a country tries to build are vital to economic development and debt sustainability. This paper proposed a new narrative on debt sustainability and thoughts on infrastructure financing under the circumstance of debt restructuring. The empirical part of the study presented both the conventional and a novel method to investigate the role of completed infrastructure projects, co-financed and jointly built by China and African countries, focusing on whether and to what extent they have addressed infrastructure bottlenecks. Both methods validate the hypothesis that China-financed and completed projects match the host country’s most backward sectors and address their development bottlenecks. These completed projects form a part of a country’s public operational assets that generate essential social services, jobs, government revenues, exports and growth.
BibTeX
@article{wang2023china,
  author = {Yan Wang and Yinyin Xu},
  title = {{China and Africa: A new narrative on debt sustainability and infrastructure financing}},
  journal = {Journal of Infrastructure Policy and Development},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.24294/jipd.v7i1.2181},
}
Figure