Chimeric CRISPR guides enhance Cas9 target specificity

Noah Jakimo, Pranam Chatterjee, Joseph M. JacobsonbioRxiv 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed "melt-guides," a novel type of CRISPR guide RNA that incorporates DNA bases into its spacer sequence. These melt-guides significantly enhance Cas9's specificity by reducing its ability to cleave DNA sequences with even a single mismatch, while maintaining high on-target activity. This breakthrough promises to improve the precision of genome editing applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

CRISPR-Cas9 technology has revolutionized genome engineering, allowing for precise DNA modifications. However, a major limitation is the potential for Cas9 to bind and cleave off-target sites in the genome that are similar, but not identical, to the intended target. This "off-target activity" can lead to unintended mutations and limit the safety and reliability of CRISPR-based therapies and research tools. While various strategies have been explored to improve Cas9 specificity, such as controlling exposure time or modifying binding affinity, a fundamental approach to fine-tuning the guide RNA's recognition properties has been lacking. This paper addresses the need for a guide RNA design that inherently reduces mismatch tolerance, thereby increasing Cas9's specificity without sacrificing on-target efficiency.

Methods

The core innovation presented is the development of "melt-guides." These are chimeric guide RNAs where the traditional RNA spacer sequence is partially or largely replaced with DNA bases. The rationale behind this is that DNA:DNA duplexes are generally less stable than RNA:DNA duplexes, and this reduced stability in the R-loop structure formed during target recognition is hypothesized to make Cas9 more sensitive to mismatches.

Key methods include:

  • In vitro cleavage assays: Purified Cas9 was used to digest target DNA sequences containing varying numbers of mismatches, comparing the cleavage efficiency of canonical gRNAs with melt-guides.
  • In silico modeling (Rosetta): Used to predict the energetic penalties of DNA substitutions in the guide RNA, helping to select optimal positions for DNA incorporation.
  • Cell-based assays (HEK293T): Melt-guides were co-transfected with Cas9 into human cells, and indel formation (a measure of DNA editing) was assessed using deep sequencing.
  • Exonuclease co-transfection: To enhance indel formation rates, the mammalian exonuclease Trex2 was co-expressed with Cas9 and melt-guides.
  • Deep sequencing: Used to quantify on-target and off-target indel rates with high precision.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention training or evaluation on large, pre-existing benchmark datasets in the traditional machine learning sense. Instead, the "datasets" are the synthesized DNA and RNA sequences used as guide RNAs and target DNA substrates. These include:

  • Synthesized chimeric melt-guides: Designed with varying degrees of DNA substitution in the spacer region.
  • Synthesized target DNA sequences: Including an on-target sequence (VEGF) and several off-target sequences with varying numbers of mismatches (e.g., VEGF OFF1-OFF6, as detailed in Table 1).
  • Genomic DNA from transfected HEK293T cells: Used for deep sequencing to measure indel formation.

The study introduces its own set of experimental conditions and target sequences to evaluate the performance of melt-guides compared to canonical gRNAs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • DNA in the spacer is key: Replacing RNA bases with DNA in the guide RNA spacer sequence is a powerful strategy to enhance Cas9 specificity.
  • Mismatches are less tolerated: Melt-guides significantly reduce Cas9's ability to cleave DNA targets with even a single base pair mismatch, a critical improvement over standard gRNAs.
  • R-loop destabilization is the mechanism: The reduced stability of the DNA:DNA or DNA:RNA hybrid in the R-loop structure formed during target binding is proposed to be the primary driver of increased mismatch sensitivity.
  • On-target activity is largely preserved: While specificity is enhanced, melt-guides still exhibit substantial on-target cleavage activity, making them practical for genome editing.
  • Exonuclease co-delivery can boost efficiency: Co-transfecting with an exonuclease like Trex2 can increase indel rates, potentially overcoming slower kinetics or repair mechanisms that might otherwise limit editing efficiency with melt-guides.

Key Results

  • In vitro: A melt-guide containing 17 DNA bases produced 74% of the on-target cleavage compared to a canonical gRNA. Crucially, this same melt-guide showed no detectable cleavage on off-target sequences with two mismatches, whereas canonical gRNA could cut these even faster than the on-target. For a challenging single-mismatch substrate, melt-guides reduced digested fraction by four-fold compared to wild-type or high-fidelity Cas9 variants.
  • In vivo: In human cell culture (HEK293T), melt-guides with DNA substitutions in the first 11 positions of the spacer, when co-transfected with Trex2, achieved on-target indel percentages translating to approximately 70% of the rate of canonical gRNA. Importantly, at a known off-target site where gRNA induced mutations, melt-guides showed indel percentages below the no-guide negative control.

Limitations and Future Work

  • GC/pyrimidine content: The paper notes that targets with high GC or pyrimidine content can limit sufficient destabilization, potentially affecting cleavage of multi-mismatched sequences even with melt-guides. This limitation can inform target selection or be addressed by combining melt-guides with other destabilization techniques.
  • Structural uncertainty: The exact helical structure (A-form vs. B-form) adopted by melt-guides in complex with Cas9 and target DNA is unclear and could be elucidated by crystal structure analysis.
  • Extensibility to other CRISPR systems: While the authors believe melt-guides should be extensible to other CRISPR systems (like Cpf1), this requires further investigation and extrapolation from chimeric oligo libraries or structural data.
  • All-DNA melt-guides: The authors suggest that further protein engineering of Cas9 might enable the realization of all-DNA melt-guides, which would be even more resistant to RNases.
  • Reverse-transcribable melt-guides: The development of reverse-transcribable melt-guides with only DNA bases could reduce dependence on Trex2 for efficient mutagenesis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Oligonucleotide-guided nucleases (OGNs) have enabled rapid advances in precision genome engineering. Though much effort has gone into characterizing and mitigating mismatch tolerance for the most widely adopted OGN, Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9 (SpCas9), potential off-target interactions may still limit applications where on-target specificity is critical. Here we present a new axis to control mismatch sensitivity along the recognition-conferring spacer sequence of SpCas9’s guide RNA (gRNA). We introduce mismatch-evading loweredthermostability guides (melt-guides) and exhibit how nucleotide-type substitutions in the spacer can reduce cleavage of sequences mismatched by as few as a single base pair. Cotransfecting melt-guides into human cell culture with an exonuclease involved in DNA repair, we observe indel formation on a standard genomic target at approximately 70% the rate of canonical gRNA and undetectable on off-target data.
BibTeX
@misc{jakimo2017chimeric,
  author = {Noah Jakimo and Pranam Chatterjee and Joseph M. Jacobson},
  title = {{Chimeric CRISPR guides enhance Cas9 target specificity}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1101/147686},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure