Children’s Intake of Food from Non-Fast-Food Outlets and Child-Specific Menus: A Survey of Parents

Li Kheng Chai, Sze Lin Yoong, Tamara Bucher, Clare E. Collins, Vanessa A. ShrewsburyChildren 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study surveyed parents of young children in Australia about their experiences with non-fast-food outlets, finding that while children do eat at these establishments, parents overwhelmingly desire healthier options on children's menus. The findings highlight a clear demand for improved child-friendly menu offerings in a wider range of dining settings beyond traditional fast food.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Childhood obesity is a significant public health concern, and eating out-of-home has been linked to higher energy intake and less healthy food choices in children. While much research has focused on fast-food outlets, there's a notable gap in understanding children's dietary habits and menu preferences at non-fast-food establishments like bistros and cafes. This paper aims to fill that gap by exploring parents' perceptions of children's food consumption at these venues, their observations of child menus, and their desires for healthier options, which can inform future public health initiatives and regulations.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional survey with 95 parents of children aged up to six years. The survey comprised 15 questions, with eight focusing on the primary research aims. These questions explored the frequency of children eating at non-fast-food outlets, the availability and use of "children's menus" or "kids' menus" at these venues, parents' opinions on portion sizes and the healthiness of current menu items, and their preferences for future menu offerings. Seven sociodemographic questions were also included to assess potential influences on responses. Statistical analysis involved descriptive statistics, chi-squared tests for categorical data, and t-tests for continuous data to identify any associations between sociodemographic characteristics and survey responses.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized a custom-designed survey administered to parents.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Non-fast-food is a significant dining venue: A substantial portion of children (54%) consume food from non-fast-food outlets at least monthly, indicating these venues are a regular part of family dining.
  • Parental demand for healthier options is universal: Across the board, parents expressed a strong desire for a higher proportion of healthy items on children's menus at non-fast-food restaurants. This sentiment was consistent regardless of the parents' own sociodemographic characteristics.
  • Current "healthy" perception is low: On average, parents perceived only 45% of items on children's menus to be healthy, but they desired this to be 69%. This significant gap highlights a clear unmet need.
  • Sociodemographics don't sway opinions: Interestingly, parents' views on menu availability, ordering habits, and preferences for healthier options were not significantly influenced by factors like child's age, parent's sex, education level, household income, or family structure. This suggests a broad consensus on the need for healthier child-friendly options.

Key Results

  • Frequency of eating out: 54% of children consumed food from non-fast-food outlets at least monthly.
  • Child menu usage: Of parents whose children ate at non-fast-food restaurants, 71 reported their child ordered from a child menu: 7% every time, 29% often, 42% sometimes, and 16% rarely. A small percentage (7%) never ordered from these menus.
  • Perception vs. Preference for healthy items: Parents perceived an average of 45% of child menu items to be healthy, but ideally wanted 69% to be healthy. This difference of 24% was statistically significant.
  • Portion sizes: Parents had mixed views on portion sizes, with 38% finding them "just right," 34% finding them "too large," and 21% finding them "too small."
  • Desire for change: A large majority of parents (86%) wanted to see changes made to children's menus at non-fast-food outlets.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations. The study's sample size of 95 parents is relatively small, and the participants were predominantly tertiary educated, from higher-income households, and lived with a partner. This limits the generalizability of the findings to the broader Australian population. Future research should aim to recruit a more representative sample to confirm these results. Additionally, the study relied on parental perceptions, and objective audits of actual menu offerings would provide a more concrete understanding of the availability of healthy options. The authors also suggest that further investigation into the impact of children's observations of restaurant meals on their food preferences and norms is warranted. They emphasize the need for comprehensive studies on child menus in the non-fast-food sector to inform policy and interventions aimed at improving dietary quality.

Summary updated

Abstract

Eating out-of-home is associated with higher energy intakes in children. The continued high prevalence of childhood obesity requires a greater understanding of child menu options and eating out frequency to inform appropriate regulatory initiatives. The majority of studies to date have focused on menus from fast-food outlets with few focused on non-fast-food outlets. This study aimed to describe parents' reports of their child(ren)'s (aged up to 6 years) frequency of consuming foods at non-fast-food outlets, observations of child menus at these outlets, and their purchasing behaviours and future preferences regarding these menus; and if their responses were influenced by sociodemographic characteristics. Ninety-five parents completed a 15-item cross-sectional survey. Overall, children from 54% of families consumed food from non-fast-food outlets at least monthly. Of the 87 parents who reported that their child eats at a non-fast-food restaurant, 71 had children who ordered from child menus every time (7%, <i>n</i> = 5), often (29%, <i>n</i> = 22), sometimes (42%, <i>n</i> = 32) or rarely (16%, <i>n</i> = 12), with a further 7% (<i>n</i> = 5) never ordering from these menus. All parents indicated that they would like to see a higher proportion of healthy child menu items than is currently offered. Parents' responses were not influenced by sociodemographic characteristics. Parents' views support implementation of initiatives to increase availability of healthy options on child menus at non-fast-food outlets.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chai2019childrens,
  author = {Li Kheng Chai and Sze Lin Yoong and Tamara Bucher and Clare E. Collins and Vanessa A. Shrewsbury},
  title = {{Children’s Intake of Food from Non-Fast-Food Outlets and Child-Specific Menus: A Survey of Parents}},
  booktitle = {Children},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/children6110123},
}
Figure