Chemosensory Cues to Conspecific Emotional Stress Activate Amygdala in Humans

Lilianne R. Mujica‐Parodi, Helmut H. Strey, Blaise B. Frederick, Robert L. Savoy, David Cox, Yevgeny Botanov, Denis Tolkunov, Denis Rubin, Jochen WeberPLoS 2009 · DOI

Abstract

Alarm substances are airborne chemical signals released by an individual to communicate emotional stress to others of the same species. This study investigated whether humans, like other mammals, possess a chemosensory system for detecting such stress. Through a series of four experiments, sweat samples from donors undergoing acute emotional stress (first-time skydiving) were compared against exercise controls (treadmill running). fMRI results demonstrated that "stress sweat" specifically activates the human amygdala, while behavioral tasks revealed that these chemosignals sharpen the perception of ambiguous social threats. These findings suggest that humans utilize a subconscious chemical signaling system to communicate emotional arousal.

Introduction

While human communication is primarily associated with visual and auditory channels, the role of chemosensory (olfactory) signaling in social emotional states has long been debated. Many mammals release "alarm substances" to signal danger to their peers, but identifying a similar system in humans requires distinguishing between the general smell of sweat and specific signals of emotional distress. Previous research often failed to control for physical exertion, leaving it unclear if the brain's response was to the emotion or the physical activity. This study sought to isolate the neurobiological and behavioral responses to emotional stress signals by comparing sweat produced during high-arousal fear (skydiving) with sweat produced during physical exercise.

Methods

The researchers employed a robust four-experiment design to isolate emotional signaling:

  1. Stimulus Collection: Axillary sweat was collected from 144 donors in two conditions: an emotional "stress" condition (first-time tandem skydiving) and a physical "control" condition (treadmill running for an equivalent duration).
  2. fMRI and Replication: Two separate fMRI experiments presented these sweat samples to 46 "detector" participants. To ensure consistency, an MRI-compatible olfactometer was used, and participants' breathing was synchronized with visual cues.
  3. Odor Discrimination: A double-blind forced-choice task was conducted to determine if participants could consciously distinguish between the two types of sweat based on intensity or pleasantness.
  4. Behavioral Threat Perception: Participants viewed "morphed" facial expressions (ranging from 10% to 90% angry) while breathing either stress or exercise sweat to determine if the chemosignals altered their perception of social ambiguity.

Results

Neurobiological Activation

The fMRI studies revealed significant activation in the left superficial (corticoid) amygdala in response to stress sweat compared to exercise sweat ($p < 0.02$ in the original study and $p < 0.008$ in the replication). This specific sub-region is homologous to areas involved in pheromonal processing in other mammals and is known to have substantial olfactory inputs in primates.

Behavioral Impact and Physiological Validation

Exposure to stress sweat resulted in a 43% mean increase in discrimination between neutral and angry faces. Rather than simply biasing participants to see more anger, the chemosignal appeared to "sharpen" perception, reducing noise and making participants more accurate at identifying subtle threats.

Physiological data confirmed the distinct nature of the samples: skydivers showed a massive spike in cortisol (from 0.229 to 0.584 μg/dL), whereas treadmill runners showed no significant increase. Gas chromatography-mass spectroscopy (GCMS) also confirmed the presence of androgen steroids associated with apocrine sweat, supporting the presence of potential social signaling molecules.

Discussion

These findings suggest that humans possess an evolutionarily conserved system for the subconscious communication of emotional stress. Because participants could not consciously distinguish between the odors of stress and exercise sweat, the amygdala activation and behavioral sharpening occur outside of conscious awareness. The lack of gender-specific interactions suggests this is a general "alarm" system rather than a reproductive or pheromonal one.

Future research is required to determine if this effect is specific to fear or applies to emotional arousal more broadly, and to isolate the specific chemical compounds responsible for triggering the amygdala response.

Summary updated

Abstract

Alarm substances are airborne chemical signals, released by an individual into the environment, which communicate emotional stress between conspecifics. Here we tested whether humans, like other mammals, are able to detect emotional stress in others by chemosensory cues. Sweat samples collected from individuals undergoing an acute emotional stressor, with exercise as a control, were pooled and presented to a separate group of participants (blind to condition) during four experiments. In an fMRI experiment and its replication, we showed that scanned participants showed amygdala activation in response to samples obtained from donors undergoing an emotional, but not physical, stressor. An odor-discrimination experiment suggested the effect was primarily due to emotional, and not odor, differences between the two stimuli. A fourth experiment investigated behavioral effects, demonstrating that stress samples sharpened emotion-perception of ambiguous facial stimuli. Together, our findings suggest human chemosensory signaling of emotional stress, with neurobiological and behavioral effects.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mujicaparodi2009chemosensory,
  author = {Lilianne R. Mujica‐Parodi and Helmut H. Strey and Blaise B. Frederick and Robert L. Savoy and David Cox and Yevgeny Botanov and Denis Tolkunov and Denis Rubin and Jochen Weber},
  title = {{Chemosensory Cues to Conspecific Emotional Stress Activate Amygdala in Humans}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0006415},
}

Loading related content...

Figure