Chemical control of structure and guest uptake by a conformationally mobile porous material

Alexandros P. Katsoulidis, Dmytro Antypov, George F. S. Whitehead, Elliot J. Carrington, Dave J. Adams, Neil G. Berry, George R. Darling, Matthew S. Dyer, Matthew J. RosseinskyNature 2019 · DOI

Introduction

Synthetic porous materials, such as zeolites and traditional metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), have long been valued for their rigid, predictable structures. These materials typically occupy a single global energy minimum, resulting in fixed pore geometries and chemical environments. While some "breathing" MOFs have been developed, their flexibility is often limited to simple mechanical expansions or contractions.

In contrast, biological systems utilize proteins to achieve remarkable functional complexity through conformational selection and induced fit. Proteins navigate complex energy landscapes by rotating single covalent bonds along their polypeptide backbones, allowing them to switch between multiple metastable states in response to external stimuli. Bridging the gap between rigid synthetic frameworks and flexible biological macromolecules, researchers have developed a peptide-based MOF that mimics this protein-like "shape-shifting" ability.

Design and Synthesis of ZnGGH

The research team synthesized a three-dimensional chiral MOF using the tripeptide linker glycine-glycine-L-histidine (GGH) coordinated with zinc ions, termed ZnGGH. The choice of a tripeptide is significant; it introduces multiple degrees of freedom through rotatable dihedral angles (phi and psi) along the peptide backbone, similar to those found in proteins.

Figure 1: Comparison of host complexity and the molecular structure of the ZnGGH framework. (a) Energy landscapes of rigid frameworks (ZSM-5), flexible frameworks (ZnGGH), and flexible macromolecules (Hb A). (b) Chemical structure of the GGH linker and its coordination environment, highlighting the rotatable bonds.

Mapping the Conformational Energy Landscape

To characterize the material's structural diversity, the team employed a suite of advanced techniques:

  • Crystallographic Analysis: Using single-crystal and powder X-ray diffraction (SCXRD/PXRD), they identified nine distinct crystal structures (ZnGGH-1 through ZnGGH-9) formed under varying solvent conditions.
  • Dihedral angle Principal Component Analysis (dPCA): Borrowing from protein-folding simulations, dPCA was used to map the conformational space of the peptide linkers. This reduced the complex bond rotations into a two-dimensional map of structural clusters.
  • Computational Modeling: Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations revealed an energy landscape with three primary minima: Straight, Twisted, and Folded.
Figure 2: A three-dimensional representation of the complex energy landscape for a flexible macromolecule, illustrating the multiple local minima (valleys) that the material can navigate.

Nudged Elastic Band (NEB) simulations estimated the energy barriers between these states to be between 12.4 and 19.5 kJ/mol—values remarkably similar to those of fast-folding proteins.

Chemically Triggered Functionality

The material's ability to navigate its energy landscape allows for precise control over guest uptake. The researchers demonstrated that ZnGGH can act as a chemical switch:

  1. Solvent-Induced Gating: When solvated with DMSO, the peptide linkers adopt a "Twisted" conformation. This state effectively closes the pore windows (approx. 4.5 Å), excluding larger guest molecules like dioxane.
  2. Chemical Triggering: The addition of a small amount of DMF acts as a trigger, inducing bond rotations that shift the framework into a "Straight" conformation. This opens the pore windows to 5.4 Å, enabling the uptake of dioxane.
  3. Induced Fit: One specific structure, ZnGGH-4, exemplifies the "induced fit" mechanism. This conformation is inherently unstable but becomes stabilized when it wraps around water or methanol molecules, forming specific hydrogen-bonding networks.

Results and Implications

The study successfully demonstrated that a single chemical framework could exist in nine experimentally observed states. By engineering the "pore window" through peptide bond rotation, the team achieved triggered adsorption, where guest uptake is turned on or off by specific chemical signals.

While the kinetics of these transformations can be slow—sometimes requiring days to reach equilibrium—this work represents a significant step toward "life-like" synthetic materials. The use of longer peptide chains (oligopeptides) could potentially lead to even more complex energy landscapes, paving the way for programmable materials capable of performing sequential chemical tasks or sophisticated molecular recognition.

Conclusion

By incorporating protein-like conformational mobility into a metal-organic framework, the researchers have created a material that transcends the limitations of traditional rigid porous solids. The ZnGGH system provides a blueprint for designing synthetic materials that mimic the dynamic functional control found in biology, opening new possibilities for selective separation, sensing, and catalysis.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{katsoulidis2019chemical,
  author = {Alexandros P. Katsoulidis and Dmytro Antypov and George F. S. Whitehead and Elliot J. Carrington and Dave J. Adams and Neil G. Berry and George R. Darling and Matthew S. Dyer and Matthew J. Rosseinsky},
  title = {{Chemical control of structure and guest uptake by a conformationally mobile porous material}},
  booktitle = {Nature},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41586-018-0820-9},
}
Figure