Charm Photoproduction Cross Section at 20 GeV

K. Abe, T. C. Bacon, J. Ballam, L. Berny, A. V. Bevan, H. H. Bingham, J. E. Brau, K. Braune, D. Brick, W. Bugg, J. Butler, W. Cameron, J. T. Carroll, C. V. Cautis, J. S. Chima, H.o. Cohn, D.c. Colley, G. T. Condo, S. Dado, R. N. Diamond, P.j. Dornan, R. Erickson, T. Fieguth, R. C. Field, L. Fortney, B. Franek, N. Fujiwara, R. Gearhart, T. Glanzman, Jacques Goldberg, G. P. Gopal, A. T. Goshaw, E. Hafen, V. Hagopian, G. Hall, Edwin R. Hancock, T. Handler, H. J. Hargis, E. L. Hart, P. Haridas, K. Hasegawa, T. Hayashino, D. Q. Huang, R. I. Hulsizer, S. Isaacson, M. Jobes, G. Kalmus, D. P. Kelsey, J. Kent, T. Kitagaki, J. Lannutti, A. Levy, Peter W. Lucas, M. MacDermott, W. A. Mann, T. Maruyama, R. Merenyi, R. H. Milburn, C. Milsténe, K. C. Moffeit, Joseph J. Murray, A. Napier, S. Noguchi, F. Ochiai, S.w. OʼNeale, A. P. T. Palounek, I. A. Pless, M. S. Z. Rabin, P. Rankin, W. J. Robertson, A. H. Rogers, E. Ronat, H. Rudnicka, Takahiro Sato, J. Schneps, S. J. Sewell, J. T. Shank, A. Shapiro, C. K. Sinclair, R. Sugahara, Y. Suzuki, K. Takahashi, K. Tamai, S. Tanaka, S. Tether, H. B. Wald, W. D. Walker, M. Widgoff, Christina Wilkins, S. Wolbers, C. A. Woods, Yi Wu, A. Yamaguchi, R. K. Yamamoto, S. Yamashita, G. Yekutieli, Y. Yoshimura, G.p. Yost, H. YutaPhysical 1983 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reports the measurement of the charm photoproduction cross section at 20 GeV using the SLAC Hybrid Facility. The collaboration observed 47 charm events, leading to a calculated total charm cross section of $63_{-28}^{+33}$ nb, providing valuable data for understanding charm particle production in photon-proton interactions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how charm quarks are produced in high-energy interactions is crucial for testing and refining theoretical models of particle physics, particularly Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). Charm particles, containing a charm quark, are relatively heavy and their production is sensitive to the underlying dynamics of quark-gluon interactions. While previous experiments had measured charm photoproduction cross sections, there was a need for more precise measurements at specific energies to discriminate between different theoretical predictions, such as the Photon Gluon Fusion (PGF) model and Vector Meson Dominance (VDM) models. This paper aims to contribute to this understanding by measuring the charm photoproduction cross section at a photon energy of 20 GeV.

Methods

The experiment utilized the SLAC Hybrid Facility, which combines a 1-meter hydrogen bubble chamber with electronic detectors. A 20 GeV photon beam, produced by Compton scattering of laser light off a 30 GeV electron beam, illuminated the hydrogen target. The photon beam had a peak energy of 20 GeV with a 2 GeV full width at half maximum.

To detect charm particle decays, a high-resolution fourth camera was employed. The experiment was triggered by charged particles pointing back to the fiducial volume of the bubble chamber or by significant energy deposition in lead-glass blocks. Particle identification was achieved through ionization measurements in the bubble chamber and Cerenkov counters.

A total of 270,000 hadronic interactions were analyzed. Events with short-lived particle decays within 1 cm of the production vertex were meticulously examined. Several cuts were applied to ensure the identification of genuine charm decays and to reject background events. These cuts included:

  • Rejecting decays with fewer than two charged products.
  • Rejecting two-prong decays consistent with photon conversions or strange particle decays (e.g., $K^0$, $\Lambda$). Specific invariant mass cuts were used to eliminate these backgrounds.
  • Rejecting three-prong decays consistent with $K^\pm \to \pi^+\pi^-\pi^\pm$ or $\rho\pi^0$ decays, as well as decays superimposed on production vertex tracks.

Further cuts were applied to ensure uniform and high detection efficiency:

  • A minimum decay length cut of 500 $\mu$m.
  • An impact distance cut ($d_{max}$) greater than 110 $\mu$m for at least one track.
  • An impact distance cut ($d_2$) greater than 40 $\mu$m for a second track.

The sensitivity of the experiment was determined by measuring the total photon flux, scanning efficiency, and triggering efficiency. Charm event triggering efficiency was found to be $92 \pm 4\%$. Scanning efficiency was determined to be $95_{-10}^{+10}\%$.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study consists of 270,000 hadronic interactions recorded in the SLAC Hybrid Facility's 1-meter hydrogen bubble chamber, exposed to a 20 GeV photon beam. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Charm production is a sensitive probe of QCD: The measurement of the charm photoproduction cross section provides a direct test of theoretical models describing the strong force, particularly at energies where charm quarks are produced.
  • Distinguishing theoretical models: The measured cross section at 20 GeV can help differentiate between various theoretical predictions, such as the Photon Gluon Fusion (PGF) model and Vector Meson Dominance (VDM) models, which predict different energy dependencies for charm production.
  • Challenges in charm decay identification: The paper highlights the difficulties in uniquely identifying all charm decay products, often requiring assumptions about missing neutral particles or considering multiple hypotheses (e.g., $D^\pm$, $F^\pm$, $\tau$).
  • Importance of precise measurements: The relatively large uncertainty in the measured cross section ($63_{-28}^{+33}$ nb) underscores the experimental challenges in charm photoproduction but also points to the need for even more precise measurements to strongly constrain theoretical models.

Key Results

After applying all selection criteria, 37 events remained, corresponding to 40 observed decays. This led to a measured charm photoproduction cross section at 20 GeV of $\sigma(\gamma p \to \text{CHARM}) = (63_{-28}^{+33})$ nb. This value is consistent with some theoretical predictions, particularly those favoring the Photon Gluon Fusion models, as shown in Figure 4. The paper also presents results for specific pair production models, with values ranging from 47.9 nb to 93.2 nb, and uses a median value based on an equal mixture of extreme models to arrive at the final cross section.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Systematic Uncertainties: The authors acknowledge significant systematic uncertainties, estimated at +40% and -30%, arising from production mechanisms, decay uncertainties, and the difficulty in experimentally determining relative production rates of different charm particle pairs.
  • Ambiguity in Particle Identification: As noted, many observed charged decays are not uniquely identified as specific charm particles (e.g., $D^\pm$, $F^\pm$), leading to uncertainties in the analysis.
  • Model Dependence: The calculation of the cross section relies on assumptions about production mechanisms and decay branching ratios, which are not fully determined experimentally.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that further theoretical work is needed to better understand the production dynamics and decay properties of charm particles. More precise experimental measurements at various energies are also crucial for discriminating between theoretical models. The authors also mention a second approach to calculating the cross section, which assigns weights based on momentum and decay multiplicity, yielding consistent results.

Summary updated

Abstract

Forty-seven charm events have been observed in an exposure of the SLAC Hybrid Facility bubble chamber to a 20-GeV backward-scattered laser beam. Thirty-seven events survive all the necessary cuts imposed. Based on this number the total charm cross section is calculated to be ${63}_{\ensuremath{-}28}^{+33}$ nb.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{abe1983charm,
  author = {K. Abe and T. C. Bacon and J. Ballam and L. Berny and A. V. Bevan and H. H. Bingham and J. E. Brau and K. Braune and D. Brick and W. Bugg and J. Butler and W. Cameron and J. T. Carroll and C. V. Cautis and J. S. Chima and H.O. Cohn and D.C. Colley and G. T. Condo and S. Dado and R. N. Diamond and P.J. Dornan and R. Erickson and T. Fieguth and R. C. Field and L. Fortney and B. Franek and N. Fujiwara and R. Gearhart and T. Glanzman and Jacques Goldberg and G. P. Gopal and A. T. Goshaw and E. Hafen and V. Hagopian and G. Hall and Edwin R. Hancock and T. Handler and H. J. Hargis and E. L. Hart and P. Haridas and K. Hasegawa and T. Hayashino and D. Q. Huang and R. I. Hulsizer and S. Isaacson and M. Jobes and G. Kalmus and D. P. Kelsey and J. Kent and T. Kitagaki and J. Lannutti and A. Levy and Peter W. Lucas and M. MacDermott and W. A. Mann and T. Maruyama and R. Merenyi and R. H. Milburn and C. Milsténe and K. C. Moffeit and Joseph J. Murray and A. Napier and S. Noguchi and F. Ochiai and S.W. OʼNeale and A. P. T. Palounek and I. A. Pless and M. S. Z. Rabin and P. Rankin and W. J. Robertson and A. H. Rogers and E. Ronat and H. Rudnicka and Takahiro Sato and J. Schneps and S. J. Sewell and J. T. Shank and A. Shapiro and C. K. Sinclair and R. Sugahara and Y. Suzuki and K. Takahashi and K. Tamai and S. Tanaka and S. Tether and H. B. Wald and W. D. Walker and M. Widgoff and Christina Wilkins and S. Wolbers and C. A. Woods and Yi Wu and A. Yamaguchi and R. K. Yamamoto and S. Yamashita and G. Yekutieli and Y. Yoshimura and G.P. Yost and H. Yuta},
  title = {{Charm Photoproduction Cross Section at 20 GeV}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {1983},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.51.156},
}
Figure