CHARM High-Energy Ions for Microelectronics Reliability Assurance (CHIMERA)

Kacper Biłko, Rubén García Alía, Alessandra Constantino, Andrea Coronetti, Salvatore Danzeca, Marc Delrieux, Natalia Emriskova, Matthew Fraser, Sylvain Girard, Eliott Philippe Johnson, Marc Sebban, Federico Ravotti, Andreas WaetsIEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

The CHIMERA project at CERN is successfully repurposing the Proton Synchrotron (PS) infrastructure to deliver Very High Energy (VHE) heavy ion beams for radiation reliability testing. These highly penetrating beams allow researchers to test complex, fully packaged microelectronics—mimicking deep-space cosmic rays—without the need for invasive sample preparation like "delidding."

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As microelectronics become more complex (using 3D stacks, flip-chips, and system-in-package architectures), traditional radiation testing hits a physical wall. Standard heavy ion facilities typically provide ions in the 10–20 MeV/u range. These ions have very short ranges in matter, meaning they cannot penetrate the thick plastic or ceramic "lids" of modern chips. To test them, engineers must "delid" or thin the silicon substrate, which is risky, expensive, and sometimes impossible for advanced packaging.

Furthermore, these low-energy ions don't perfectly replicate the Galactic Cosmic Ray (GCR) spectrum found in space. There is a global scarcity of facilities capable of providing Very High Energy (VHE, >100 MeV/u) ions that can penetrate entire electronic boards or boxes while maintaining a meaningful Linear Energy Transfer (LET)—the measure of how much energy a particle deposits as it travels through a material.

Methods

The researchers utilized CERN’s Proton Synchrotron (PS) to accelerate lead ($^{208}$Pb) ions. Key technical components include:

  • RFKO Extraction: They used Radio Frequency Knock-Out (RFKO) to "slowly" extract the beam over 300–400 ms spills, allowing for controlled testing of Single Event Effects (SEE).
  • Beam Characterization: The team combined FLUKA Monte Carlo simulations with physical instrumentation. They used a 300 µm-thick silicon diode to measure energy deposition and flux, and a Multi-Wire Proportional Chamber (MWPC) to map the spatial beam profile.
  • Dosimetry Calibration: A critical part of the work involved cross-calibrating Secondary Emission Chambers (SECs) against the silicon diode. This ensures that facility users know exactly how many ions hit their components during a test run.

Datasets

The study validated the CHIMERA beam by performing benchmark Single Event Upset (SEU) measurements on three commercial Static Random Access Memories (SRAMs):

  1. Cypress 65 nm (16 Mbit)
  2. ISSI 40 nm (32 Mbit)
  3. Renesas 110 nm (8 Mbit)

The results were compared against established "gold standard" data from other European facilities, including GSI (Germany), GANIL (France), and RADEF (Finland).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Degradation" Advantage: Counter-intuitively, the beam's passage through ~30 meters of air and various vacuum windows is beneficial. It slows the ions down, which actually increases their LET at the device location. For example, a beam extracted at 650 MeV/u arrives at the test site at 140 MeV/u, boosting the LET from ~8 to ~27 MeV/(mg/cm²).
  • Testing "In Air": Because the ions are so energetic, they can be tested in a standard room environment rather than a vacuum chamber, significantly simplifying the experimental setup for engineers.
  • MCU Overlap: The paper highlights a unique challenge: because CHIMERA provides high-intensity spills rather than a continuous low-flux beam, Multiple-Cell Upsets (MCUs) can sometimes overlap in time, making it harder to distinguish if a cluster of errors was caused by one ion or two.

Key Results

  • Energy Versatility: The PS successfully delivered Pb ions at three primary energies: 1000, 750, and 650 MeV/u.
  • LET Coverage: The facility achieved LET values of 13, 18, and 27 MeV/(mg/cm²), covering a significant portion of the range required for space-grade reliability assurance.
  • Cross-Facility Consistency: The SEU cross-section measurements for the SRAMs matched data from GSI and other facilities within a factor of 2. For the Cypress 65 nm chip, the results were within ±20%, proving that CHIMERA provides high-quality, reliable data.
  • Beam Size: The beam follows a Gaussian profile with a Full Width at Half Maximum (FWHM) of approximately 10 cm, large enough to irradiate entire boards.

Limitations and Future Work

The current beam is Gaussian, meaning the intensity is much higher in the center than at the edges. Future upgrades aim to deliver a "flatter," more spatially uniform beam using weaker focusing and collimation.

The team also aims to reach higher LET values (up to 40 MeV/(mg/cm²)) to test even more sensitive components. This work is continuing under the EU-funded HEARTS project, which seeks to transition CHIMERA from a developmental activity into a high-readiness facility for the global aerospace and high-reliability electronics communities.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present the progress related to CERN’s capacity of delivering highly penetrating, high-LET heavy ions for radiation effect testing of electronic components within the CHIMERA (CHARM High-energy Ions for Micro Electronics Reliability Assurance) project. Profiting from the existing accelerator infrastructure, Monte Carlo simulations and a 300 μm-thick silicon diode, we highlight the beam characterization capabilities and a summary of the beam properties. Finally, we present the comparison of the SRAM SEE cross-section measurements with respect to other heavy ion facilities.
BibTeX
@article{biko2024charm,
  author = {Kacper Biłko and Rubén García Alía and Alessandra Constantino and Andrea Coronetti and Salvatore Danzeca and Marc Delrieux and Natalia Emriskova and Matthew Fraser and Sylvain Girard and Eliott Philippe Johnson and Marc Sebban and Federico Ravotti and Andreas Waets},
  title = {{CHARM High-Energy Ions for Microelectronics Reliability Assurance (CHIMERA)}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/tns.2024.3358376},
}
Figure