Charged-current non-standard neutrino interactions at Daya Bay

Daya Bay collaboration, Fengpeng An, Wenqi Bai, A. B. Balantekin, M. Bishai, S. Blyth, G. F. Cao, Jun Cao, J. F. Chang, Yoosoo Chang, H. S. Chen, Shaomin Chen, Y. Chen, Jie Cheng, Yin Cheong Cheng, Zhaokan Cheng, J. J. Cherwinka, M. C. Chu, J. P. Cummings, O. Dalager, F. S. Deng, Xinjian Ding, Y. Y. Ding, M. Diwan, Tadeáš Dohnal, Dmitry Dolzhikov, J. Dove, Katherine Dugas, Hongyue Duyang, D. A. Dwyer, J. P. Gallo, M. Gonchar, G. H. Gong, Hao Gong, W. Gu, J. Y. Guo, Lei Guo, X. H. Guo, Yuhang Guo, Zhen Guo, R. Hackenburg, Yang Han, S. Hans, M. He, K. M. Heeger, Y. K. Heng, Y. K. Hor, Y. Hsiung, Beibei Hu, Z. Hu, T. Hu, H. X. Huang, Jihong Huang, X. T. Huang, Y. B. Huang, P. Huber, D. E. Jaffe, K. L. Jen, X. L. Ji, R. A. Johnson, D. Jones, Lin Kang, S. H. Kettell, S. Kohn, M. J. Kramer, T. J. Langford, J. Lee, R. T. Lei, R. Leitner, J. K. C. Leung, F. Li, H. L. Li, J. J. Li, R. H. Li, S. Li, W. D. Li, X. N. Li, Yufeng Li, Z. B. Li, H. Liang, Chien‐Yu Lin, G. L. Lin, S. Y. Lin, J. J. Ling, J. M. Link, L. Littenberg, B. R. Littlejohn, J. C. LiuJournal of High Energy Physics 2024

TL;DR

This paper uses data from the Daya Bay reactor neutrino experiment to set new limits on "non-standard neutrino interactions" (NSI) that go beyond the Standard Model. By analyzing how electron antineutrinos oscillate, the researchers found no evidence for these new interactions, placing constraints on their potential strength.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Neutrino oscillations, the phenomenon where neutrinos change "flavor" as they travel, are well-described by the Standard Model of particle physics with three neutrino flavors. However, neutrinos are known to have mass, which is not explained by the Standard Model. This suggests the existence of "new physics" beyond the Standard Model. One way this new physics could manifest is by altering how neutrinos interact, leading to "non-standard neutrino interactions" (NSI). These NSI could affect neutrino production, detection, or propagation. This paper specifically investigates "charged-current" NSI (CC-NSI), which involve interactions mediated by charged W bosons, and aims to constrain their strength using data from the Daya Bay experiment, which precisely measures electron antineutrino disappearance.

Methods

The authors employ two theoretical frameworks to describe CC-NSI:

  • Quantum Mechanics-based NSI (QM-NSI): This approach modifies the neutrino interaction eigenstates by introducing complex parameters ($\epsilon$) that represent deviations from standard interactions at the production and detection points. They consider scenarios where these parameters are the same ($\epsilon^s = \epsilon^d$) and where they can differ ($\epsilon^s \neq \epsilon^d$).
  • Weak Effective Field Theory NSI (WEFT-NSI): This framework treats NSI as higher-dimensional operators suppressed by a high energy scale, leading to a more general set of NSI parameters denoted as $[\epsilon^X]_{e\alpha}$.

Both approaches are used to calculate the effective survival probability of electron antineutrinos. The researchers then compare these theoretical predictions to the experimental data from Daya Bay, fitting for the NSI parameters while accounting for standard oscillation parameters and systematic uncertainties. They analyze the impact of different phases of these NSI parameters and explore various scenarios, including fixing phases to specific values or allowing them to vary freely.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is the full data set from the Daya Bay reactor neutrino experiment. This includes approximately 5.55 x 10^6 inverse beta decay (IBD) candidate events collected over 3158 days of operation. The neutrino flux is taken from the Huber-Mueller model, with an enlarged 5% uncertainty.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • No Evidence for CC-NSI: The most significant finding is the lack of evidence for charged-current non-standard neutrino interactions. This means that the Daya Bay data is consistent with the Standard Model of neutrino interactions within the explored parameter space.
  • Complementary Approaches: The use of both QM-NSI and WEFT-NSI frameworks provides a comprehensive way to probe CC-NSI, ensuring that the results are robust across different theoretical interpretations.
  • Phase Dependence is Crucial: The constraints on NSI parameters are highly dependent on their complex phases. Allowing these phases to vary freely generally weakens the constraints compared to fixing them to specific values (like 0, π/2, π, or 3π/2).
  • Flavor-Universal vs. Flavor-Non-Universal: The paper distinguishes between flavor-universal NSI (where the interaction strength is the same for all neutrino flavors) and flavor-non-universal NSI (where the strength differs). The constraints are generally stronger for flavor-universal NSI.
  • Reactor Flux Uncertainty: For certain NSI parameters (like $\epsilon_{ee}$), the constraints are sensitive to the uncertainty in the reactor neutrino flux. This highlights the importance of precise flux measurements for future NSI studies.

Key Results

The study provides constraints on various CC-NSI parameters from the Daya Bay experiment:

  • QM-NSI:
    • For flavor-conserving electron NSI ($\epsilon_{ee}$), constraints reach the order of $\mathcal{O}(0.01)$ when phases are fixed. When phases are allowed to vary freely, the bounds are relaxed to $\mathcal{O}(1)$.
  • For flavor-violating electron NSI ($\epsilon_{e\mu}$, $\epsilon_{e\tau}$), constraints reach the order of $\mathcal{O}(0.1)$ even when phases are allowed to vary freely.
  • WEFT-NSI:
    • For parameters like $[\epsilon^X]_{e\alpha}$ (where X can be L, R, S, T), constraints are generally of the order of $\mathcal{O}(0.1)$ for both fixed and free phases.
  • No Bounds on Phases: In most cases, the phases of the NSI parameters are not constrained by the Daya Bay data and remain largely free.

Limitations and Future Work

  • No Evidence Found: The primary limitation is the lack of observed NSI, meaning the current data only provides upper bounds on their strength.
  • Flux Uncertainty: For some NSI parameters, the constraints are limited by the uncertainty in the reactor neutrino flux. Future experiments with more precise flux measurements could improve these limits.
  • Phase Degeneracies: The complex nature of NSI parameters means that certain combinations of phases can lead to similar effects, making it challenging to disentangle them.
  • Future Improvements: The authors suggest that future experiments with improved precision, particularly in measuring neutrino flux and potentially at different baselines, could further tighten the constraints on CC-NSI. The study also opens avenues for exploring other types of NSI (e.g., neutral-current NSI) and their implications for neutrino physics.

Summary updated

Abstract

The full data set of the Daya Bay reactor neutrino experiment is used to probe the effect of the charged current non-standard interactions (CC-NSI) on neutrino oscillation experiments. Two different approaches are applied and constraints on the corresponding CC-NSI parameters are obtained with the neutrino flux taken from the Huber-Mueller model with a $5\%$ uncertainty. For the quantum mechanics-based approach (QM-NSI), the constraints on the CC-NSI parameters $ε_{eα}$ and $ε_{eα}^{s}$ are extracted with and without the assumption that the effects of the new physics are the same in the production and detection processes, respectively. The approach based on the weak effective field theory (WEFT-NSI) deals with four types of CC-NSI represented by the parameters $[\varepsilon_{X}]_{eα}$. For both approaches, the results for the CC-NSI parameters are shown for cases with various fixed values of the CC-NSI and the Dirac CP-violating phases, and when they are allowed to vary freely. We find that constraints on the QM-NSI parameters $ε_{eα}$ and $ε_{eα}^{s}$ from the Daya Bay experiment alone can reach the order $\mathcal{O}(0.01)$ for the former and $\mathcal{O}(0.1)$ for the latter, while for WEFT-NSI parameters $[\varepsilon_{X}]_{eα}$, we obtain $\mathcal{O}(0.1)$ for both cases.
BibTeX
@article{collaboration2024charged,
  author = {Daya Bay collaboration and Fengpeng An and Wenqi Bai and A. B. Balantekin and M. Bishai and S. Blyth and G. F. Cao and Jun Cao and J. F. Chang and Yoosoo Chang and H. S. Chen and H. Y. Chen and Shaomin Chen and Y. Chen and Y. X. Chen and Z. Y. Chen and Jie Cheng and Yin Cheong Cheng and Zhaokan Cheng and J. J. Cherwinka and M. C. Chu and J. P. Cummings and O. Dalager and F. S. Deng and Xinjian Ding and Y. Y. Ding and M. Diwan and Tadeáš Dohnal and Dmitry Dolzhikov and J. Dove and Katherine Dugas and Hongyue Duyang and D. A. Dwyer and J. P. Gallo and M. Gonchar and G. H. Gong and Hao Gong and W. Gu and J. Y. Guo and Lei Guo and X. H. Guo and Yuhang Guo and Zhen Guo and R. Hackenburg and Yang Han and S. Hans and M. He and K. M. Heeger and Y. K. Heng and Y. K. Hor and Y. Hsiung and Beibei Hu and Z. Hu and T. Hu and Zhongfa Hu and H. X. Huang and Jihong Huang and X. T. Huang and Y. B. Huang and P. Huber and D. E. Jaffe and K. L. Jen and X. L. Ji and Xihan Ji and R. A. Johnson and D. Jones and Lin Kang and S. H. Kettell and S. Kohn and M. J. Kramer and T. J. Langford and J. Lee and J. H. C. Lee and R. T. Lei and R. Leitner and J. K. C. Leung and F. Li and H. L. Li and J. J. Li and Q. J. Li and R. H. Li and S. Li and Shirley Weishi Li and S. Li and W. D. Li and X. N. Li and X. Q. Li and Yufeng Li and Z. B. Li and H. Liang and Chien‐Yu Lin and G. L. Lin and S. Y. Lin and J. J. Ling and J. M. Link and L. Littenberg and B. R. Littlejohn and J. C. Liu and J. L. Liu and J. X. Liu},
  title = {{Charged-current non-standard neutrino interactions at Daya Bay}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2024},
}
Figure