Charge Transport in Alkali-Metal Superoxides: A Systematic First-Principles Study

Nicolai Rask Mathiesen, Yang Sheng, J. M. García‐Lastra, Tejs Vegge, Donald J. SiegelChemistry 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the charge transport mechanisms in alkali-metal superoxides (LiO2, NaO2, KO2), which are discharge products in metal-air batteries. The study finds that while all superoxides are wide bandgap insulators, LiO2 exhibits significantly higher electronic conductivity than NaO2 and KO2, potentially explaining the superior performance of Li-air batteries.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Metal-air batteries, particularly lithium-air (Li-air) batteries, hold immense promise for next-generation energy storage due to their high theoretical energy densities. However, their practical application is hindered by high overpotentials during charging, which are often linked to the poor conductivity of the solid discharge products. While alkali peroxides (like Li2O2 and Na2O2) have been extensively studied, there's a lack of consensus on the charge transport properties of alkali superoxides (LiO2, NaO2, KO2), which are also observed as discharge products and are associated with lower overpotentials. This paper aims to systematically investigate the intrinsic charge transport mechanisms in these superoxides using computational methods to understand why some metal-air systems perform better than others.

Methods

The researchers employed first-principles density functional theory (DFT) calculations, specifically using the Vienna ab initio Simulation Package (VASP). They utilized both the generalized gradient approximation with a Hubbard U correction (GGA+U) and the Heyd-Scuseria-Ernzerhof (HSE) hybrid functional. The HSE functional, with a specific fraction of exact exchange (a=0.48), was chosen for its ability to accurately describe localized charge distributions and polaron hopping, which are crucial for understanding charge transport in these materials.

A key methodological contribution was the development of a constrained optimization approach to determine the most representative room-temperature structure for KO2, accounting for the dynamic Jahn-Teller effect and the rotation of superoxide dimers. This involved exploring various orientations of the superoxide ions while maintaining the overall tetragonal symmetry. Similar structural analyses were performed for LiO2 and NaO2.

To assess charge transport, the study calculated band gaps, defect formation energies, equilibrium defect concentrations, migration barriers for these defects, and ultimately, the intrinsic ionic and electronic conductivities. For more accurate band gap calculations, non-self-consistent GW calculations (HSE+GoWo) were also performed.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on first-principles calculations and theoretical modeling rather than experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Superoxides are Wide Bandgap Insulators: Contrary to some earlier predictions, all alkali superoxides (LiO2, NaO2, KO2) are predicted to be wide bandgap insulators (band gaps > 4 eV). This means that charge transport primarily occurs through defect hopping, not band conduction.
  • Ionic Conductivity Dominance: Superoxides exhibit significantly higher ionic conductivities (8-11 orders of magnitude larger) compared to their corresponding alkali peroxides. This is attributed to the high mobility of superoxide vacancies (VO2+), which are the dominant charge carriers.
  • LiO2's Electronic Advantage: While NaO2 and KO2 show low electronic conductivities (similar to peroxides), LiO2 stands out with a much higher electronic conductivity (9 x 10^-12 S/cm at 300 K). This enhanced conductivity in LiO2 is also due to polaron hopping.
  • Jahn-Teller Effect in KO2: The study proposes a non-symmetrized room-temperature structure for KO2 to account for the dynamic Jahn-Teller effect, which influences its electronic properties.
  • Defect Landscape: The dominant charged defects in LiO2 are superoxide vacancies (VO2+) and electron polarons (ep-). In KO2, potassium vacancies (VK) and superoxide vacancies (VO2+) are dominant.

Key Results

  • Band Gaps: LiO2: 4.16 eV, KO2: 4.95 eV, NaO2: 5.30 eV (estimated).
  • Ionic Conductivity (Room Temperature):
    • LiO2: 4 x 10^-9 S/cm
    • NaO2: 4 x 10^-9 S/cm
    • KO2: 5 x 10^-12 S/cm
  • Electronic Conductivity (Room Temperature):
    • LiO2: 9 x 10^-12 S/cm
    • NaO2: 10^-19 to 10^-20 S/cm
    • KO2: 10^-19 to 10^-20 S/cm
  • Ionic vs. Peroxide Conductivity: Superoxides are 8-11 orders of magnitude more ionically conductive than alkali peroxides.
  • Electronic Conductivity Comparison: LiO2's electronic conductivity is 7-8 orders of magnitude higher than that of NaO2 and KO2.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the calculated equilibrium defect concentrations might not be realized in operating batteries due to non-equilibrium effects (e.g., rapid discharge product growth and slow kinetics). This could lead to higher actual defect concentrations and thus higher conductivities.

Future work could focus on:

  • Quantifying the identity and non-equilibrium concentrations of charge-carrying defects in peroxides and superoxides formed under realistic electrodeposition conditions.
  • Investigating the role of microstructural features (surfaces, grain boundaries, amorphous regions) and non-equilibrium carrier concentrations in enhancing charge transport, particularly in KO2 and NaO2.
  • Further exploring the impact of CO2 poisoning and other electrolyte components on charge transport mechanisms.

Summary updated

Abstract

Charge-transport mechanisms within the discharge products of alkali-metal/O2 batteries can strongly influence the performance of these systems. To date, discharge products comprising alkali peroxides (Li2O2 and Na2O2) and superoxides (LiO2, NaO2, and KO2) have been observed. In general, cells that discharge to a superoxide exhibit lower overpotentials than those that form the corresponding peroxide. These lower overpotentials have been hypothesized to originate from more efficient charge transport within the superoxides. While the transport mechanisms in the peroxides have been well studied, consensus regarding the intrinsic conductivity across the alkali-metal superoxides is lacking. Here, we present a systematic first-principles study of charge-transport mechanisms across the alkali-metal (Li, Na, K) superoxides. Our study draws on our prior investigations of the alkali peroxides and of sodium superoxide, while adding new analyses for lithium and potassium superoxides (LiO2 and KO2). In the case of KO2, a nonsymmetrized room-temperature structure is proposed to account for a dynamic Jahn–Teller effect. Band gaps, equilibrium (charged) defect concentrations, mobilities, and intrinsic conductivities are estimated for both LiO2 and KO2. Overall, the alkali superoxides are predicted to be wide band gap insulators, with gaps exceeding 4 eV. These large band gaps imply that negligible transport occurs via band conduction. Compared to the alkali peroxides, ionic conductivities in the superoxides are predicted to be 8–11 orders of magnitude larger, ranging from 4 × 10–9 to 5 × 10–12 S/cm at room temperature. Regarding electronic conductivities, transport in NaO2 and KO2 is predicted to occur via polaron hopping, with low conductivities on the order of 10–19 to 10–20 S/cm. These values are similar to what has been previously reported for the peroxides. Importantly, the present calculations indicate that LiO2 has a much larger electronic conductivity (also arising from polaron hopping) than its Na and K analogues, 9 × 10–12 S/cm at 300 K. These data suggest that the low overpotentials observed for Na- and KO2-based batteries cannot be explained by high intrinsic electronic conductivities. In contrast, the much larger conductivities predicted for LiO2 imply that the superior performance observed in LiO2-based cells may reflect the ability of LiO2 to support higher charge-transport rates.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mathiesen2019charge,
  author = {Nicolai Rask Mathiesen and Yang Sheng and J. M. García‐Lastra and Tejs Vegge and Donald J. Siegel},
  title = {{Charge Transport in Alkali-Metal Superoxides: A Systematic First-Principles Study}},
  booktitle = {Chemistry},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.chemmater.9b03592},
}
Figure