Charge state regulation of nuclear excitation by electron capture in $^{229}$Th ions

Yang-Yang Xu, Qiong Xiao, Jun-Hao Cheng, Wenyu Zhang, Tong-Pu YuarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Nuclear excitation by electron capture (NEEC) in $^{229}$Th holds significant potential for precise nuclear state manipulation. In this study, we thoroughly investigate NEEC in $^{229}\text{Th}^{q+}$ ions by integrating quantum numbers ($n, l, j$) effects and analyzing key parameters (e.g., resonance energy $E_r$, cross section $\sigma$, resonance strength $S$, and NEEC transition width $\Gamma_{\text{NEEC}}$) across charge states from $q=1^+$ to $90^+$. We focus on the charge-state regulation of the isomeric state (IS, 8.36 eV) and second-excited state (SE, 29.19 keV). Our calculations uncover critical charge-state-dependent behaviors: (1) For the IS, valid NEEC channels exhibit threshold migration, where the dominant principal quantum number $n$ increases linearly with $q$ following $n \approx 1.28q + 4.23$, while resonance strength $S$ stabilizes via compensatory nucleus-electron coupling. (2) For the SE, the total $S$ increases monotonically with $q$ due to negligible channel screening. This research clarifies the intrinsic mechanisms of charge-state-driven nuclear-electronic interactions and provides a critical reference for future experimental efforts to manipulate $^{229}$Th nuclear states.

Introduction

Thorium-229 ($^{229}$Th) is often described as the "holy grail" of nuclear physics due to its exceptionally low-lying isomeric state (IS) with an excitation energy of approximately 8.36 eV. This energy, comparable to ultraviolet light, makes $^{229}$Th the primary candidate for a nuclear optical clock, which could surpass the precision of current atomic clocks by orders of magnitude. However, efficiently populating this state remains a challenge. Nuclear Excitation by Electron Capture (NEEC) offers a promising pathway, where a free electron is captured into an atomic orbital, transferring its energy to the nucleus. This study explores how the ionic charge state ($q$) of $^{229}$Th acts as a regulatory "control knob" for this process.

Theoretical Framework and Energy Level Dynamics

The researchers utilized a Dirac-Hartree-Fock-Slater (DHFS) potential to solve the Dirac equation for electron wavefunctions, accounting for relativistic effects and electron-electron interactions. A central finding is how the increasing charge state shifts the atomic binding energies ($E_{\text{bound}}$), which directly dictates the available energy "budget" for nuclear excitation.

Evolution of electron binding energies $E_{bound}$ for $^{229}\text{Th}^{q+}$ ions ($q=1^+$ to $8^+$). As the charge state increases, the binding energy of lower orbitals exceeds the 8.36 eV threshold of the isomeric state, necessitating capture into higher-lying shells.

As shown in the figure above, for low charge states, the binding energies of the $6p$ and $6d$ shells are already significant. As $q$ increases, these levels sink deeper into the potential well. For the 8.36 eV IS transition, if an orbital's binding energy exceeds this value, it can no longer serve as a capture channel for a free electron with positive kinetic energy, leading to the phenomenon of threshold migration.

Results and Discussion

Threshold Migration and Stability in the Isomeric State

For the low-energy IS, the "available" slots for electron capture move to progressively higher principal quantum numbers ($n$) as the ion's charge increases. The study identifies a clear linear relationship: the dominant shell $n$ follows the scaling law $n \approx 1.28q + 4.23$.

Heatmap of resonance strength $S$ for the Isomeric State (IS) as a function of charge state $q$ and principal quantum number $n$. The linear trend highlights the threshold migration effect across the full range of ionic charges.

Remarkably, capturing an electron into these distant, high-$n$ shells does not lead to a collapse in efficiency. In highly charged ions, the nucleus exerts a stronger pull, causing Coulomb contraction of the electron orbits. This contraction increases the overlap between the electron and nuclear wavefunctions, effectively compensating for the increased distance of the shells. Consequently, the total resonance strength $S$ for the IS remains stable between $10^{-1}$ and $10^0$ barn eV across all charge states.

The Second-Excited State and Indirect Pumping

The behavior of the Second-Excited State (SE, 29.19 keV) is markedly different. Because its excitation energy is much higher than the electron binding energies of most shells, it does not suffer from the same channel restrictions as the IS. Instead, the resonance strength for the SE increases monotonically with the charge state, surging by four orders of magnitude from $q=1^+$ to $q=90^+$.

This leads to a critical strategic insight: for highly charged ions ($q \ge 87+$), the resonance strength of the SE actually surpasses that of the IS. This suggests that the most efficient way to populate the clock state in such environments is indirectly: using NEEC to excite the nucleus to the SE state, which then decays into the IS with high probability (~90%).

Conclusion

This study provides a comprehensive roadmap for manipulating $^{229}$Th nuclear states via the ionic charge state. By identifying the linear scaling of threshold migration and the efficiency of the indirect pumping route for highly charged ions, the research offers practical guidance for experimentalists using facilities like Electron Beam Ion Traps (EBIT). These findings bring the realization of a $^{229}$Th-based nuclear clock one step closer to reality.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nuclear excitation by electron capture (NEEC) in $^{229}$Th holds significant potential for precise nuclear state manipulation. In this study, we thoroughly investigate NEEC in $^{229}\text{Th}^{q+}$ ions by integrating quantum numbers ($n, l, j$) effects and analyzing key parameters (e.g., resonance energy $E_r$, cross section $σ$, resonance strength $S$, and NEEC transition width $Γ_{\text{NEEC}}$) influences across charge state from $q=1^+$ to $90^+$. Especially, we focus on the charge-state regulation of the isomeric state (IS, 8.36 eV) and second-excited state (SE, 29.19 keV). Our calculations uncover critical charge-state-dependent behaviors of NEEC in $^{229}\text{Th}$ ions: (1) For the IS, valid NEEC channels exhibit threshold migration, where the dominant principal quantum number $n$ increases linearly with $q$ following the relation $n \approx 1.28q + 4.23$; meanwhile, single-$n$-channel $S$ stabilizes between $10^{-2}$ to $10^0$ barn eV via compensatory nucleus-electron coupling, ensuring the total resonance $S$ constant. (2) For the SE, its excitation energy far exceeds nearly all electron binding energies, leading to negligible channel screening and causing the total $S$ to increase monotonically with $q$. This research clarifies the intrinsic mechanisms of charge-state-driven nuclear-electronic interactions in $^{229}\text{Th}^{q+}$ NEEC and provides a critical reference for future experimental efforts to manipulate $^{229}\text{Th}$ nuclear states, particularly via indirect regulation of the SE.
BibTeX
@misc{xu2025charge,
  author = {Yang-Yang Xu and Qiong Xiao and Jun-Hao Cheng and Wenyu Zhang and Tong-Pu Yu},
  title = {{Charge state regulation of nuclear excitation by electron capture in $^\{229\}$Th ions}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2510.08212},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.08212},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure