Characterizing a psychiatric symptom dimension related to deficits in goal-directed control

Claire M. Gillan, Michał Kosiński, Robert Whelan, Elizabeth A. Phelps, Nathaniel D. DaweLife 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study proposes a "trans-diagnostic dimension" of "Compulsive Behavior and Intrusive Thought" that is strongly linked to deficits in goal-directed control, a cognitive function crucial for flexible behavior. This dimensional approach offers a more nuanced understanding of psychopathology than traditional diagnostic categories, suggesting a common neurobiological basis for seemingly disparate compulsive disorders.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Current psychiatric diagnoses, like those in the DSM, are based on symptom clusters rather than underlying neurocognitive mechanisms. This leads to significant overlap and comorbidity between disorders, making it difficult to pinpoint the specific cognitive or biological underpinnings of conditions like obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) and addiction. While deficits in "goal-directed control" (the ability to make deliberate choices based on expected outcomes) have been linked to compulsive behaviors, these deficits have also been observed in non-compulsive disorders, questioning their specificity. The authors aim to address this by investigating whether a dimensional approach, looking at symptoms and cognitive traits across the population rather than within diagnostic categories, can better delineate the neurocognitive basis of compulsivity.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged approach:

  1. Reinforcement Learning Task: Participants completed a "two-step reinforcement learning task" designed to quantify individual differences in "goal-directed" (model-based) versus "habitual" (model-free) learning. This task involves learning probabilistic transitions between states and rewards, allowing researchers to estimate a "model-based learning" parameter.
  2. Large-Scale Online Assessment: Two large samples of the general population were recruited via Amazon's Mechanical Turk. Participants completed the reinforcement learning task and a battery of self-report questionnaires assessing various psychiatric symptoms.
  3. Factor Analysis: To reduce the dimensionality of the symptom data and identify underlying symptom dimensions, a factor analysis was performed on the individual questionnaire items. This identified three latent factors: "Anxious-Depression," "Compulsive Behavior and Intrusive Thought," and "Social Withdrawal."
  4. Statistical Modeling: Mixed-effects logistic regression models were used to examine the associations between the model-based learning parameter and the identified symptom dimensions, while controlling for covariates like age, IQ, and gender.

Datasets

  • Experiment 1: 548 participants from Amazon's Mechanical Turk.
  • Experiment 2: 1413 participants from Amazon's Mechanical Turk.

No new benchmarks were introduced; the study utilized existing questionnaires and a well-established reinforcement learning task.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Compulsivity as a Dimension: The study strongly suggests that "compulsive behavior and intrusive thought" is a meaningful, continuous dimension of psychopathology, rather than being confined to specific diagnostic categories.
  • Goal-Directed Deficits as a Specific Marker: Deficits in goal-directed control are not a general marker of psychopathology but are specifically linked to this "Compulsive Behavior and Intrusive Thought" dimension. This provides a potential neurocognitive explanation for why certain disorders are characterized by compulsive behaviors.
  • Beyond Behavior: The Role of Intrusive Thoughts: The identified dimension goes beyond just compulsive actions to include intrusive thoughts and preoccupations, suggesting a shared cognitive mechanism for both.
  • Dimensional Psychiatry's Potential: The findings highlight the power of a dimensional, trans-diagnostic approach, aligning with initiatives like the NIMH's Research Domain Criteria (RDoC), for understanding the biological underpinnings of mental health conditions.

Key Results

  • Experiment 1: Self-reported OCD symptom severity was significantly associated with deficits in goal-directed control (a negative relationship). Depression and trait anxiety symptoms were not.
  • Experiment 2: This association was replicated for OCD and generalized to other disorders with compulsive features, including eating disorders, impulsivity, and alcohol addiction. Non-compulsive symptoms (depression, apathy, trait anxiety, social anxiety) showed no significant association.
  • Factor Analysis: Three distinct symptom dimensions emerged: "Anxious-Depression," "Compulsive Behavior and Intrusive Thought," and "Social Withdrawal."
  • Specificity: Only the "Compulsive Behavior and Intrusive Thought" factor was significantly associated with deficits in goal-directed control. This association was highly specific when directly compared to the other two factors.
  • Effect Size: The "Compulsive Behavior and Intrusive Thought" factor explained a substantial portion of the variance in goal-directed deficits, indicating a 17% reduction in model-based learning for a one standard deviation increase in this symptom dimension.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Self-Report Limitations: The study relies on self-report questionnaires, which can be subject to biases and have varying reliability.
  • General Population vs. Clinical Samples: While the study used large general population samples to leverage normal variation, future work should test these findings in clinically diagnosed patient populations.
  • Computational Model Nuances: While the logistic regression provided robust results, a more complex computational model revealed some subtle differences (e.g., schizotypy becoming a significant predictor in one instance), suggesting that further refinement of computational approaches is valuable.
  • Habit Formation Mechanisms: The study points to the role of goal-directed deficits in habit formation but acknowledges that the precise contribution of stimulus-response habit learning to the "Compulsive Behavior and Intrusive Thought" dimension requires further investigation.
  • Temporal Dynamics: The relationship between obsessive thoughts and compulsive behaviors is complex and likely bidirectional. Longitudinal studies are needed to disentangle their temporal dynamics.
  • Impulsivity Nuances: While impulsivity total scores were associated with goal-directed deficits, the factor analysis suggested that only a subset of impulsivity items loaded onto the "Compulsive Behavior and Intrusive Thought" factor, indicating that impulsivity is a broad construct with potentially distinct components.
  • Other Compulsive Behaviors: The study did not account for all compulsive behaviors (e.g., pathological gambling, trichotillomania), which could introduce noise.

Future work should focus on validating these findings in clinical populations, exploring the neurobiological underpinnings of the "Compulsive Behavior and Intrusive Thought" dimension, and investigating the temporal relationship between cognitive deficits and symptom development.

Summary updated

Abstract

Prominent theories suggest that compulsive behaviors, characteristic of obsessive-compulsive disorder and addiction, are driven by shared deficits in goal-directed control, which confers vulnerability for developing rigid habits. However, recent studies have shown that deficient goal-directed control accompanies several disorders, including those without an obvious compulsive element. Reasoning that this lack of clinical specificity might reflect broader issues with psychiatric diagnostic categories, we investigated whether a dimensional approach would better delineate the clinical manifestations of goal-directed deficits. Using large-scale online assessment of psychiatric symptoms and neurocognitive performance in two independent general-population samples, we found that deficits in goal-directed control were most strongly associated with a symptom dimension comprising compulsive behavior and intrusive thought. This association was highly specific when compared to other non-compulsive aspects of psychopathology. These data showcase a powerful new methodology and highlight the potential of a dimensional, biologically-grounded approach to psychiatry research.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gillan2016characterizing,
  author = {Claire M. Gillan and Michał Kosiński and Robert Whelan and Elizabeth A. Phelps and Nathaniel D. Daw},
  title = {{Characterizing a psychiatric symptom dimension related to deficits in goal-directed control}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.11305},
}
Figure