Characterization of the Vaginal Microbiome in Women with Infertility and Its Potential Correlation with Hormone Stimulation during In Vitro Fertilization Surgery

Changying Zhao, Zefeng Wei, Junjie Yang, Jiaming Zhang, Chunna Yu, Aijun Yang, Min Zhang, Lin Zhang, Ye Wang, Xiaofeng Mu, Xueyuan Heng, Huijun Yang, Zhongtao Gai, Xuenan Wang, Lei ZhangmSystems 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that women with secondary infertility have a less diverse vaginal microbiome compared to healthy women, particularly during the follicular phase. Interestingly, this microbiome composition in infertile women remains largely unchanged by the hormone stimulation used in IVF, suggesting a potential disconnect between hormonal interventions and the vaginal microbial environment in these patients.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Infertility is a significant global health issue, with secondary infertility (inability to conceive after a previous successful pregnancy) affecting a substantial number of couples. While the vaginal microbiome is known to play a crucial role in reproductive health and can influence pregnancy outcomes, its specific role in secondary infertility and its interaction with the hormonal interventions used in in vitro fertilization (IVF) remain poorly understood. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by characterizing the vaginal microbiome of women undergoing IVF for secondary infertility and investigating how it responds to the hormonal stimulation protocols common in IVF.

Methods

The researchers employed 16S rRNA gene sequencing to analyze the composition of vaginal microbiomes. This is a standard technique for profiling microbial communities. They compared the microbiome diversity and richness (alpha diversity) and the overall community structure (beta diversity) between different groups of women. Specifically, they used:

  • Alpha diversity analysis: To quantify the number of different microbial species and their evenness within a sample (e.g., using Shannon index and Chao1).
  • Beta diversity analysis: To compare the overall microbial community structure between different groups (e.g., using unweighted UniFrac distances and Principal Coordinate Analysis - PCoA).
  • Linear Discriminant Analysis Effect Size (LEfSe): A powerful tool to identify specific microbial taxa (at phylum and genus levels) that are significantly enriched or depleted in one group compared to another. This helps pinpoint key microbial biomarkers.
  • Correlation analysis: To examine the relationships between the abundance of different bacterial taxa.

Datasets

The study utilized vaginal swab samples from:

  • 30 patients with secondary infertility undergoing IVF. Samples were collected during the follicular phase (before hormone stimulation) and after hormone stimulation (GnRH agonist and r-hCG).
  • 92 healthy women serving as controls. Samples from these women were collected during both the follicular (non-ovulation) and ovulatory phases.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study relied on collected patient and healthy control samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Infertility is linked to reduced vaginal microbiome diversity: The most striking finding is that women with secondary infertility exhibit significantly lower vaginal microbiome diversity and richness compared to healthy women, especially during the follicular phase. This suggests that a less diverse microbial environment might be a characteristic of infertility.
  • Healthy women's microbiomes fluctuate with the menstrual cycle: The vaginal microbiome of healthy women shows dynamic changes, with distinct compositions during the ovulation period compared to the follicular phase. This highlights the influence of natural hormonal fluctuations on the vaginal ecosystem.
  • Hormone stimulation in IVF doesn't significantly alter the infertile microbiome: Counterintuitively, the hormone treatments used in IVF (GnRH agonist and r-hCG) did not induce significant changes in the vaginal microbiome composition of the infertile women. This suggests that the infertile vaginal microbiome might be less responsive to these hormonal cues compared to healthy individuals.
  • Specific bacterial shifts in infertility: Infertile women showed an increased abundance of certain bacteria like Atopobium, Aerococcus, and Bifidobacterium, and a decreased abundance of Lactobacillus and Leuconostoc. These shifts could contribute to an unfavorable vaginal environment.

Key Results

  • Diversity reduction in infertile women: Infertile women had a significantly lower Shannon index (a measure of diversity) in the follicular phase compared to healthy women in the same phase (P < 0.01).
  • Menstrual cycle influence in healthy women: Healthy women showed significant differences in vaginal microbiome composition between the ovulatory and non-ovulatory (follicular) phases, both in alpha and beta diversity.
  • Hormone insensitivity in infertile women: No significant differences were found in alpha or beta diversity between infertile women before and after hormone stimulation for IVF (P > 0.05).
  • Specific taxa changes: In infertile women, Atopobium, Aerococcus, and Bifidobacterium were more abundant, while Lactobacillus and Leuconostoc were less abundant compared to healthy controls.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample size: The authors acknowledge that the sample size for the infertile group (n=30) and healthy controls (n=92) might be relatively small, potentially underpowering some statistical tests. They suggest that larger, well-controlled studies are needed.
  • Focus on secondary infertility: The study specifically looked at secondary infertility. Future research could explore primary infertility and other causes of infertility.
  • Hormonal influence mechanism: While the study found the infertile microbiome to be insensitive to IVF hormones, the exact mechanisms behind this insensitivity and how it impacts fertility require further investigation.
  • IVF outcomes: The study characterized the microbiome but did not directly link these microbiome profiles to IVF success rates. Future work should aim to correlate microbiome composition with IVF outcomes.
  • Broader microbiome analysis: While 16S rRNA sequencing provides a good overview, shotgun metagenomic sequencing could offer a more detailed functional understanding of the microbiome.

Summary updated

Abstract

Perturbation of vaginal microbiome of reproductive-age women influences all the phases of a woman's reproductive life. Although studies have shown that dynamic changes in vaginal microbiome can affect pregnancy, its role in secondary infertility (i.e., inability to become pregnant or to carry a pregnancy successfully after previous success in delivering a child) and <i><u>i</u>n <u>v</u>itro</i> <u>f</u>ertilization (IVF) remains to be unraveled. To determine the vaginal microbiome in women undergoing <i><u>i</u>n <u>v</u>itro</i> <u>f</u>ertilization and <u>e</u>mbryo <u>t</u>ransfer (IVF-ET) and investigate its potential correlations with hormone stimulation, we recruited 30 patients with secondary infertility and receiving IVF and 92 matched healthy women and analyzed their vaginal microbiome composition using 16S rRNA gene sequencing. Our results show that women suffering from infertility (infertile women) exhibit a significant decrease in microbiome diversity and richness compared with healthy women during the nonovulation period (follicular phase) (<i>P < </i>0.01), whereas vaginal microbiome of healthy women reveals dramatic fluctuations during ovulation (<i>P < </i>0.05). Interestingly, infertility patients show no change of the vaginal microbiome under conditions of <u>g</u>o<u>n</u>adotropin-<u>r</u>eleasing <u>h</u>ormone (GnRH) agonist and <u>r</u>ecombinant <u>h</u>uman <u>c</u>horionic <u>g</u>onadotropin (r-hCG) induction (<i>P > </i>0.05). Moreover, our results indicate that infertile women show characteristic variations in vaginal microbiome, such as increased abundance <i>of Atopobium, Aerococcus</i>, and <i>Bifidobacterium</i> and decreased abundance of <i>Lactobacillus</i> and <i>Leuconostoc</i> <b>IMPORTANCE</b> The microbiome had been hypothesized to be involved in the physiology and pathophysiology of assisted reproduction before the first success in IVF, while the data supporting or refuting this hypothesis were less than conclusive. Thanks to sequencing data from the 16S rRNA subunit, we characterized the microbiome in the reproductive tract of infertile women, and we found that changes in the vaginal microbiome are related to female infertility. We also found that the characteristic microbiome bacteria are mainly members of several genera and that the vaginal microbiome of infertile women is not sensitive to hormonal changes during IVF. In conclusion, our report provides data that can be used for discovering the role of the vaginal microbiome in patients suffering from secondary infertility.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2020characterization,
  author = {Changying Zhao and Zefeng Wei and Junjie Yang and Jiaming Zhang and Chunna Yu and Aijun Yang and Min Zhang and Lin Zhang and Ye Wang and Xiaofeng Mu and Xueyuan Heng and Huijun Yang and Zhongtao Gai and Xuenan Wang and Lei Zhang},
  title = {{Characterization of the Vaginal Microbiome in Women with Infertility and Its Potential Correlation with Hormone Stimulation during <i>In Vitro</i> Fertilization Surgery}},
  booktitle = {mSystems},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1128/msystems.00450-20},
}
Figure