Characterization of proteoform post-translational modifications by top-down and bottom-up mass spectrometry in conjunction with UniProt annotations

Wenrong Chen, Zhengming Ding, Yong Zang, Xiaowen LiubioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces PTM-TBA, a novel software pipeline that integrates top-down and bottom-up mass spectrometry (MS) with UniProt annotations to comprehensively identify and localize post-translational modifications (PTMs) on proteoforms. By combining these complementary approaches, PTM-TBA aims to overcome the limitations of individual methods, leading to more accurate and sensitive PTM characterization.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Proteoforms, the diverse molecular forms of a protein arising from genetic variations, alternative splicing, and post-translational modifications (PTMs), are crucial for cellular function and disease. PTMs, in particular, are critical regulators of signaling, degradation, and many other biological processes. Mass spectrometry (MS) is the go-to technique for studying these modifications. However, existing MS approaches have limitations: bottom-up MS, which analyzes digested peptides, can lose information about PTM combinations on intact proteins, while top-down MS, which analyzes intact proteins, often struggles with sensitivity and fragment ion coverage, making PTM localization challenging. This paper addresses the need for a more robust method to identify and characterize PTMs by leveraging the complementary strengths of both top-down and bottom-up MS, further enhanced by external knowledge from databases like UniProt.

Methods

The core of this work is the development of the PTM-TBA (PTM characterization by Top-down, Bottom-up MS and Annotations) software pipeline. PTM-TBA integrates data from two complementary MS techniques:

  • Bottom-up MS: Proteins are digested into peptides, which are then analyzed by MS/MS. This approach is good for identifying PTMs on peptides and provides high fragment ion coverage. The pipeline uses MSFragger for database searching of bottom-up MS data, employing an "open search" strategy to identify unexpected mass shifts.
  • Top-down MS: Intact proteins are analyzed by MS/MS. This method is powerful for identifying PTM combinations and characterizing intact proteoforms. The pipeline utilizes TopPIC for database searching of top-down MS data.

The pipeline then performs several key steps:

  1. Identification of Mass Shifts: Both bottom-up and top-down MS data are processed to identify mass shifts, which represent potential PTMs.
  2. Removal of Duplicated Mass Shifts: A crucial step involves clustering and greedily removing redundant mass shift identifications that arise from the same modification on the same protein across different analyses or within the same analysis.
  3. Classification of PTMs: Identified mass shifts are categorized into four classes: N-terminal acetylation, high-frequency PTMs with localized sites, high-frequency PTMs without localization, and low-frequency PTMs.
  4. Validation: PTMs identified by top-down MS are validated using:
  5. Bottom-up MS data: Matching mass shifts between proteoforms and peptides.
  6. UniProt annotations: Cross-referencing identified PTMs with known PTMs in the UniProt database.

Datasets

The study utilized a bottom-up and a top-down mass spectrometry dataset from SW480 colorectal cancer cells. These datasets were generated using established experimental protocols (described in detail in the Methods section). No new benchmark datasets were introduced; instead, the focus was on integrating existing data types with a knowledgebase.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy of Top-Down and Bottom-Up MS: The paper strongly demonstrates that combining top-down and bottom-up MS is more powerful than either method alone. Top-down MS provides a global view of proteoforms and PTM combinations, while bottom-up MS offers detailed peptide-level PTM localization and validation.
  • Importance of UniProt Annotations: Leveraging UniProt's extensive PTM information significantly enhances the validation of identified PTMs, providing an independent layer of confidence.
  • Computational Challenges in PTM Identification: The paper highlights the necessity of sophisticated computational approaches, like PTM-TBA, to handle the complexity of PTM identification and to effectively remove redundant identifications.
  • Impact of Variable PTM Settings: The study shows that carefully selecting which PTMs to consider as "variable" during database searching (e.g., methionine oxidation) can dramatically increase the number of identified PTMs.

Key Results

The PTM-TBA pipeline was applied to SW480 cell data, yielding significant findings:

  • Top-down MS: Identified 1,662 mass shifts in proteoforms. Of these, 545 (33%) were matched to 12 common PTMs, and 351 were confidently localized.
  • Validation: PTM-TBA successfully validated 346 of the 1,662 top-down MS mass shifts using either bottom-up MS data or UniProt annotations.
  • Uncommon Mass Shifts: 35 uncommon mass shifts were identified by both top-down and bottom-up MS, suggesting potential novel modifications or less common PTMs.
  • Bottom-up MS: Identified 14,073 mass shifts/PTM sites, with 754 N-terminal acetylation sites and 9,567 PTM-related mass shifts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Complex PTM Combinations: The authors acknowledge that identifying and localizing PTMs in proteoforms with multiple, complex PTM combinations remains a challenge.
  • Low-Abundance Proteoforms: Identifying PTMs on low-abundance proteoforms is difficult. The authors suggest that PTM-specific enrichment techniques (e.g., TiO2 columns, antibodies) could help address this in future work.
  • Further Development of PTM-TBA: While PTM-TBA is presented as a robust pipeline, ongoing development and refinement of its algorithms for handling complex PTM scenarios and improving sensitivity are implied.

Summary updated

Abstract

Many proteoforms can be produced from a gene due to genetic mutations, alternative splicing, post-translational modifications (PTMs), and other variations. PTMs in proteoforms play critical roles in cell signaling, protein degradation, and other biological processes. Mass spectrometry (MS) is the primary technique for investigating PTMs in proteoforms, and two alternative MS approaches, top-down and bottom-up, have complementary strengths. The combination of the two approaches has the potential to increase the sensitivity and accuracy in PTM identification and characterization. In addition, protein and PTM knowledgebases, such as UniProt, provide valuable information for PTM characterization and validation. Here, we present a software pipeline called PTM-TBA (PTM characterization by Top-down, Bottom-up MS and Annotations) for identifying and localizing PTMs in proteoforms by integrating top-down and bottom-up MS as well as UniProt annotations. We identified 1,662 mass shifts from a top-down MS data set of SW480 cells, 545 (33%) of which were matched to 12 common PTMs, and 351 of which were localized. PTM-TBA validated 346 of the 1,662 mass shifts using UniProt annotations or a bottom-up MS data set of SW480 cells.
BibTeX
@misc{chen2023characterization,
  author = {Wenrong Chen and Zhengming Ding and Yong Zang and Xiaowen Liu},
  title = {{Characterization of proteoform post-translational modifications by top-down and bottom-up mass spectrometry in conjunction with UniProt annotations}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.04.04.535618},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure