TL;DR
This paper introduces PTM-TBA, a novel software pipeline that integrates top-down and bottom-up mass spectrometry (MS) with UniProt annotations to comprehensively identify and localize post-translational modifications (PTMs) on proteoforms. By combining these complementary approaches, PTM-TBA aims to overcome the limitations of individual methods, leading to more accurate and sensitive PTM characterization.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Proteoforms, the diverse molecular forms of a protein arising from genetic variations, alternative splicing, and post-translational modifications (PTMs), are crucial for cellular function and disease. PTMs, in particular, are critical regulators of signaling, degradation, and many other biological processes. Mass spectrometry (MS) is the go-to technique for studying these modifications. However, existing MS approaches have limitations: bottom-up MS, which analyzes digested peptides, can lose information about PTM combinations on intact proteins, while top-down MS, which analyzes intact proteins, often struggles with sensitivity and fragment ion coverage, making PTM localization challenging. This paper addresses the need for a more robust method to identify and characterize PTMs by leveraging the complementary strengths of both top-down and bottom-up MS, further enhanced by external knowledge from databases like UniProt.
Methods
The core of this work is the development of the PTM-TBA (PTM characterization by Top-down, Bottom-up MS and Annotations) software pipeline. PTM-TBA integrates data from two complementary MS techniques:
- Bottom-up MS: Proteins are digested into peptides, which are then analyzed by MS/MS. This approach is good for identifying PTMs on peptides and provides high fragment ion coverage. The pipeline uses MSFragger for database searching of bottom-up MS data, employing an "open search" strategy to identify unexpected mass shifts.
- Top-down MS: Intact proteins are analyzed by MS/MS. This method is powerful for identifying PTM combinations and characterizing intact proteoforms. The pipeline utilizes TopPIC for database searching of top-down MS data.
The pipeline then performs several key steps:
- Identification of Mass Shifts: Both bottom-up and top-down MS data are processed to identify mass shifts, which represent potential PTMs.
- Removal of Duplicated Mass Shifts: A crucial step involves clustering and greedily removing redundant mass shift identifications that arise from the same modification on the same protein across different analyses or within the same analysis.
- Classification of PTMs: Identified mass shifts are categorized into four classes: N-terminal acetylation, high-frequency PTMs with localized sites, high-frequency PTMs without localization, and low-frequency PTMs.
- Validation: PTMs identified by top-down MS are validated using:
- Bottom-up MS data: Matching mass shifts between proteoforms and peptides.
- UniProt annotations: Cross-referencing identified PTMs with known PTMs in the UniProt database.
Datasets
The study utilized a bottom-up and a top-down mass spectrometry dataset from SW480 colorectal cancer cells. These datasets were generated using established experimental protocols (described in detail in the Methods section). No new benchmark datasets were introduced; instead, the focus was on integrating existing data types with a knowledgebase.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Synergy of Top-Down and Bottom-Up MS: The paper strongly demonstrates that combining top-down and bottom-up MS is more powerful than either method alone. Top-down MS provides a global view of proteoforms and PTM combinations, while bottom-up MS offers detailed peptide-level PTM localization and validation.
- Importance of UniProt Annotations: Leveraging UniProt's extensive PTM information significantly enhances the validation of identified PTMs, providing an independent layer of confidence.
- Computational Challenges in PTM Identification: The paper highlights the necessity of sophisticated computational approaches, like PTM-TBA, to handle the complexity of PTM identification and to effectively remove redundant identifications.
- Impact of Variable PTM Settings: The study shows that carefully selecting which PTMs to consider as "variable" during database searching (e.g., methionine oxidation) can dramatically increase the number of identified PTMs.
Key Results
The PTM-TBA pipeline was applied to SW480 cell data, yielding significant findings:
- Top-down MS: Identified 1,662 mass shifts in proteoforms. Of these, 545 (33%) were matched to 12 common PTMs, and 351 were confidently localized.
- Validation: PTM-TBA successfully validated 346 of the 1,662 top-down MS mass shifts using either bottom-up MS data or UniProt annotations.
- Uncommon Mass Shifts: 35 uncommon mass shifts were identified by both top-down and bottom-up MS, suggesting potential novel modifications or less common PTMs.
- Bottom-up MS: Identified 14,073 mass shifts/PTM sites, with 754 N-terminal acetylation sites and 9,567 PTM-related mass shifts.
Limitations and Future Work
- Complex PTM Combinations: The authors acknowledge that identifying and localizing PTMs in proteoforms with multiple, complex PTM combinations remains a challenge.
- Low-Abundance Proteoforms: Identifying PTMs on low-abundance proteoforms is difficult. The authors suggest that PTM-specific enrichment techniques (e.g., TiO2 columns, antibodies) could help address this in future work.
- Further Development of PTM-TBA: While PTM-TBA is presented as a robust pipeline, ongoing development and refinement of its algorithms for handling complex PTM scenarios and improving sensitivity are implied.
Summary updated