Abstract
Total RNA samples were extracted from the non-photosynthetic root parasitic plants Orobanche minor and O. ramosa and used to synthesize cDNAs. The cDNA fragments encoding ethylene biosynthesis enzymes, 1-amino-1-cyclopropanecarboxylic acid (ACC) synthase and ACC oxidase, were amplified and characterized. ACC synthases (OmACS and OrACS) and ACC oxidases (OmACO and OrACO) were found to have high homologies with those in other plants, in particular, with SHACS2 and SHACO1 of the root hemiparasite Striga hermonthica. The expression of these genes after germination stimulation by (+)-strigol, a natural germination stimulant, was slightly increased in O. ramosa but not in O. minor, indicating the possible involvement of ethylene biosynthesis in the germination of O. ramosa. In these root parasites, however, inhibitors of ethylene biosynthesis and action did not affect seed germination elicited by (+)-strigol except for the ethylene action inhibitor silver thiosulfate in O. ramosa.
Introduction
Root parasitic plants like Orobanche (broomrape) and Striga (witchweed) are major agricultural pests that remain dormant until they detect specific chemical signals, known as strigolactones, released by host plant roots.
In the genus Striga, it is well-established that ethylene production is a mandatory intermediate in the germination process: strigolactones trigger ethylene production, which in turn triggers germination. However, for Orobanche, the role of ethylene has been a subject of long-standing controversy. This study investigates whether Orobanche species possess the genetic machinery to synthesize ethylene and whether that machinery is utilized during the critical window of germination.
Methods and Materials
The researchers focused on two key enzymes in the ethylene biosynthesis pathway: ACC synthase (ACS) and ACC oxidase (ACO).
- Gene Cloning: Total RNA was extracted from O. minor and O. ramosa. RT-PCR and RACE (Rapid Amplification of cDNA Ends) techniques were used to isolate cDNA sequences for these enzymes.
- Sequence Analysis: Deduced amino acid sequences were compared against known sequences from Arabidopsis thaliana and the related parasite Striga hermonthica using the GenBank, DDBJ, and EMBL databases to identify conserved functional domains.
- Expression Profiling: Using Northern hybridization and real-time RT-PCR, the team measured how mRNA levels of these genes changed over time after treating seeds with germination stimulants like (+)-strigol and the synthetic analogue GR24.
- Germination Assays: The physiological impact of ethylene was tested by applying various inhibitors: AVG (blocking ethylene synthesis) and 1-MCP or silver thiosulfate (STS) (blocking ethylene perception).
Key Results
Conserved Genetic Machinery
Orobanche species do indeed possess the full genetic toolkit for ethylene production. The cloned ACS and ACO genes showed high homology (over 80% and 87% identity, respectively) to their counterparts in Striga, suggesting this pathway is evolutionarily conserved across different types of parasitic plants.
Species-Specific Responses
There is a notable difference between the two studied species. In O. ramosa, OrACS expression peaked 6 hours after strigol treatment, followed by OrACO at 18 hours. In contrast, O. minor genes remained largely unresponsive to the natural stimulant.
The Ethylene Paradox
Despite having the genes and, in the case of O. ramosa, activating them, inhibiting ethylene did not stop the seeds from germinating. Standard inhibitors like AVG and 1-MCP failed to reduce germination rates in either species. This suggests that while Orobanche can produce ethylene, it is not a mandatory requirement for germination, marking a fundamental divergence from the biology of Striga.
Discussion and Limitations
The study reveals that ethylene is not the primary driver for Orobanche germination. While O. ramosa showed sensitivity to the inhibitor silver thiosulfate (STS), the authors suggest this might be due to non-specific effects rather than pure ethylene inhibition, as other perception inhibitors like 1-MCP had no effect.
A limitation of the study was the inability to obtain the full-length sequence for OrACS, only a partial fragment. Furthermore, while mRNA levels were measured, the study did not quantify actual ethylene gas production or protein levels. Future research identifying the downstream signaling components that allow Orobanche to bypass the ethylene requirement could reveal new targets for controlling these devastating weeds.
Summary updated