Characterization and Quantitative Assessment of Shale Fracture Characteristics and Fracability Based on a Three-Dimensional Digital Core

Le Qu, Penghui Zhang, Jianping Liu, Weigang Zhang, Lei Yu, Xiaolei Zheng, Zhenzhen Nian, Kexiang Ning, Jinze XuProcesses 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for quantitatively assessing the "fracability" of shale reservoirs by analyzing 3D digital core data. By developing a "three-dimensional fracture complexity" metric, the study provides a more accurate and reliable way to predict how effectively hydraulic fracturing will create a connected fracture network, crucial for optimizing gas and oil recovery.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Shale reservoirs are a significant source of unconventional oil and gas, but their complex geological structures and low permeability make extraction challenging. Hydraulic fracturing is essential for creating flow paths, but accurately predicting its effectiveness (fracability) is difficult. Traditional methods often rely on qualitative assessments or indirect measures like mineral brittleness, which can be imprecise and fail to capture the intricate 3D nature of fracture networks. There's a clear need for a quantitative approach that directly assesses the potential for forming an effective, interconnected fracture system within the reservoir rock.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • 3D Digital Core Generation: They used X-ray CT scanning to create high-resolution 3D digital models of shale core samples, both before and after simulated fracturing.
  • Triaxial Compression Experiments: These experiments mimicked in-situ reservoir conditions to induce fracturing in the core samples.
  • Fracture Extraction and Analysis: A suite of advanced image processing techniques was used to extract and analyze fracture characteristics from the 3D digital cores. This included:
  • Maximum Ball Algorithm: For initial fracture image extraction.
  • Least Squares Fitting: To determine the best-fit plane for fracture surfaces.
  • Image Tracking Algorithms: To analyze changes and features over time/conditions.
  • 3D Image Topology Algorithms: To understand the spatial relationships and connectivity of fractures.
  • Development of "Three-Dimensional Fracture Complexity": This is a novel metric introduced to quantify the degree of successful fracture network formation. It integrates factors like fracture count, aperture, orientation, and connectivity.
  • Quantitative Fracability Model: A model was developed by combining "fracture network formation potential" (related to complexity) and "fragmentation potential" (related to rock strength/fracture pressure). This model uses a combination weighting method, incorporating both objective (entropy) and subjective (Analytic Hierarchy Process) weights to derive a comprehensive fracability index.

Datasets

The study utilized domestic shale reservoir cores from various geological formations (e.g., Ordos Basin Chang 7, Sichuan Basin Longmaxi). These cores were subjected to triaxial compression experiments, and the resulting CT scan data served as the primary dataset for analysis. No specific benchmark datasets were introduced, but the study aimed to provide a new quantitative benchmark for fracability assessment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • 3D is Crucial: The study strongly emphasizes that a 3D perspective is essential for accurately characterizing fracture networks, as 2D methods can miss internal fracture details and connectivity.
  • Fracture Complexity as a Proxy: The concept of "three-dimensional fracture complexity" is a powerful new idea that directly links the geometric and topological characteristics of post-fracturing fractures to the effectiveness of hydraulic stimulation.
  • Bridging the Gap: The developed quantitative fracability model successfully bridges the gap between physical rock properties (fracture potential) and the resulting fracture network geometry (network potential).
  • Validation with Microseismic Data: The proposed fracability index showed a strong correlation with microseismic monitoring results, a key indicator of actual fracturing behavior in the field, lending significant credibility to the method.
  • Limitations of Brittleness: The research highlights that traditional brittleness indices, while useful, are insufficient on their own to accurately predict fracability, especially when internal fractures are present.

Key Results

  • The study successfully established a method for extracting 3D fracture information and parameters from CT scans of fractured rock cores.
  • A quantitative characterization model for fracability was developed, integrating fracture potential and network potential.
  • The "three-dimensional fracture complexity" metric was shown to be a reliable indicator of effective fracture network formation.
  • Validation against microseismic monitoring data demonstrated that the proposed fracability index significantly improves the accuracy of fracability characterization compared to traditional methods.
  • The study classified the fracability of 16 shale samples into four categories (Optimal, Good, Normal, Range) based on their calculated fracturing index, providing a practical ranking system.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: While the study used domestic shale cores, the generalizability of the model to different shale types and geological settings could be further explored.
  • Experimental Conditions: The triaxial compression experiments were conducted under specific pressure and temperature conditions; future work could investigate the impact of a wider range of reservoir conditions.
  • Auxiliary Parameters: The authors suggest that incorporating additional parameters like kerogen content and fracture toughness could further enhance the precision of the fracability model for distinct blocks.
  • Real-World Application: While the study mentions its utility for guiding fracturing design in actual mining, further field-scale validation and integration into existing reservoir simulation workflows would be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

At present, assessment techniques for the fracability of shale reservoirs, which rely on the formation of an effective fracture network, are scarce. Hence, in order to assess the fracability, it is critical to establish a quantitative correlation between the pattern of fracture distribution after fracture and fracability. The present investigation utilizes three-dimensional digital core technology and triaxial compression experiments to simulate the fracturing process in typical domestic shale reservoir cores. In addition to utilizing the maximum ball algorithm to extract fracture images, a number of other techniques are employed to compute the spatial quantitative parameters of the fractures, including least squares fitting, image tracking algorithms, and three-dimensional image topology algorithms. The introduction of the notion of three-dimensional fracture complexity serves to delineate the degree of successful fracture network formation subsequent to fracturing. A quantitative fracability characterization model is developed by integrating the constraints of fracture network formation potential and fragmentation potential. The results of this study show that the quantitative characterization of the characteristic parameters of cracks can be achieved by establishing a method for extracting crack information as well as parameters after core compression and completing the construction of a three-dimensional complexity characterization model. Meanwhile, the three-dimensional post-compression fracture image validation shows that the core fracturability index can better reflect the actual fracturing situation, which is in line with the microseismic monitoring results, and significantly improves the accuracy of fracturability characterization, which is an important guideline for the fracturing design of shale gas reservoirs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qu2024characterization,
  author = {Le Qu and Penghui Zhang and Jianping Liu and Weigang Zhang and Lei Yu and Xiaolei Zheng and Zhenzhen Nian and Kexiang Ning and Jinze Xu},
  title = {{Characterization and Quantitative Assessment of Shale Fracture Characteristics and Fracability Based on a Three-Dimensional Digital Core}},
  booktitle = {Processes},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/pr12040755},
}
Figure