Characteristics of the regulation of the surprise emotion

Chuanlin Zhu, Ping Li, Zhao Zhang, Dianzhi Liu, Wenbo LuoScientific 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated how individuals regulate the emotion of surprise using cognitive reappraisal and expressive suppression, finding that both strategies effectively reduce surprise intensity. Crucially, electrophysiological data revealed that this regulation primarily occurs in later stages of facial processing, with both strategies showing equivalent effects.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding emotion regulation is crucial, as individuals often need to manage their emotional responses to navigate social situations and maintain well-being. While research has extensively explored the regulation of emotions with clear valence (like anger or sadness), emotions without a distinct valence, such as surprise, have received less attention. Surprise is particularly interesting because its effective processing often relies on integrating contextual information. This paper addresses the gap in understanding how surprise is regulated, specifically examining the temporal dynamics of this process and comparing two common regulation strategies: cognitive reappraisal (changing one's interpretation of an event) and expressive suppression (inhibiting outward emotional displays). The study also investigates whether the context in which surprise arises influences these regulation processes.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of behavioral measures and electroencephalography (EEG) to investigate emotion regulation of surprise. Participants were college students who were presented with images of surprised facial expressions, preceded by either "basic" (neutral) or "complex" (contextual, implying a positive or negative event) visual cues. They were instructed to regulate their surprise using one of three strategies: cognitive reappraisal, expressive suppression, or free viewing (as a control).

Behavioral measures: Participants rated their surprise intensity after each trial. A manipulation check ensured participants were proficient in using the instructed strategies.

EEG recording: Event-related potentials (ERPs) were recorded from 64 scalp sites. The study focused on two key ERP components:

  • N170: An early component (around 170 ms post-stimulus) thought to reflect automatic facial processing.
  • Late Positive Complex (LPC): A later component (400-1000 ms post-stimulus) associated with emotional evaluation and regulation.

The ERP data were analyzed to examine how context and regulation strategy affected these components.

Datasets

The study utilized images from the Chinese Facial Affective Picture System, specifically selecting neutral faces for the "basic" condition and creating "complex" conditions by morphing happy and sad facial features to imply an uncertain emotional event. These images were presented alongside Chinese words indicating the regulation strategy to be used. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Surprise is Regulated: Participants successfully reduced their reported intensity of surprise using both cognitive reappraisal and expressive suppression compared to free viewing.
  • Context Matters for Early Processing: The N170 component, reflecting early facial processing, was larger in the "complex" context compared to the "basic" context. This suggests that richer contextual information demands more attentional resources during initial face perception.
  • Regulation Happens Later: Crucially, the N170 component was not affected by the type of emotion regulation strategy used. This indicates that emotion regulation does not occur at this very early, automatic stage of processing.
  • LPC Reflects Regulation: The later LPC component was modulated by emotion regulation. Both cognitive reappraisal and expressive suppression led to smaller LPC amplitudes compared to free viewing, suggesting that regulation influences the later evaluative stages of processing surprised faces.
  • Equivalent Strategies: Notably, the LPC amplitudes elicited by cognitive reappraisal and expressive suppression were not significantly different from each other. This implies that, for regulating surprise in this context, both strategies were equally effective.
  • Cultural Nuances: The authors speculate that the lack of a clear advantage for cognitive reappraisal (as seen in some Western studies) might be influenced by cultural factors, suggesting that individuals with Eastern cultural values may be more inclined towards suppression due to concerns about interpersonal relationships.

Key Results

  • Behavioral: Surprise intensity was significantly reduced by both cognitive reappraisal and expressive suppression compared to free viewing. There was no significant difference in surprise reduction between cognitive reappraisal and expressive suppression.
  • N170 ERP: Amplitudes were significantly larger in the "complex" context (M±SD, 4.992 ±0.708 µV) than in the "basic" context (5.208 ± 0.711 µV). No significant effects of emotion regulation strategy were found on N170 amplitudes.
  • LPC ERP: Amplitudes were significantly smaller when using expressive suppression (3.529 ± 0.345 μV) and cognitive reappraisal (3.515±0.310 µV) compared to free viewing (3.973±0.396µV) in the 400-600 ms time window. No significant differences were found between expressive suppression and cognitive reappraisal. Similar patterns were observed in later LPC time windows (600-800 ms and 800-1000 ms), with no significant differences between the two regulation strategies.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Stimulus Artificiality: The "complex" facial images were created using morphing software, which might not perfectly replicate the nuances of real-world complex emotional expressions. The combination of happy mouths and sad eyes could also lead to unique emotional experiences.
  • Sample Specificity: The study was conducted with college students, limiting generalizability to other populations.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Eye-Tracking: Incorporating eye-tracking to better understand how attention is allocated to different facial features within complex stimuli.
  • Clinical Populations: Replicating the study with clinical populations (e.g., individuals with schizophrenia, social anxiety disorder, bipolar disorder) to explore how emotion regulation of surprise might differ.
  • Cross-Cultural Comparisons: Further investigating the role of cultural values in shaping the effectiveness and preference for different emotion regulation strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study aimed to assess the characteristics of the regulation of the emotion of surprise. Event-related potentials (ERPs) of college students when using cognitive reappraisal and expressive suppression to regulate their surprise level were recorded. Different contexts were presented to participants, followed by the image of surprised facial expression; subsequently, using a 9-point scale, participants were asked to rate the intensity of their emotional experience. The behavioral results suggest that individuals' surprise level could be reduced by using both expressive suppression and cognitive reappraisal, in basic and complex conditions. The ERP results showed that (1) the N170 amplitudes were larger in complex than basic contexts, and those elicited by using expressive suppression and cognitive reappraisal showed no significant differences, suggesting that emotion regulation did not occur at this stage; (2) the LPC amplitudes elicited by using cognitive reappraisal and expressive suppression were smaller than those elicited by free viewing in both context conditions, suggesting that the late stage of individuals' processing of surprised faces was influenced by emotion regulation. This study found that conscious emotional regulation occurred in the late stages when individuals processed surprise, and the regulation effects of cognitive reappraisal and expressive suppression were equivalent.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2019characteristics,
  author = {Chuanlin Zhu and Ping Li and Zhao Zhang and Dianzhi Liu and Wenbo Luo},
  title = {{Characteristics of the regulation of the surprise emotion}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-019-42951-y},
}
Figure