Characteristics of Lamination in Deep Marine Shale and Its Influence on Mechanical Properties: A Case Study on the Wufeng-Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin

Jingqiang Tan, Baojian Shen, Huricha Wu, Yaohua Wang, Xinyao Ma, Xiao Ma, Wenhui LiuMinerals 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the fine-scale layering (lamination) in deep marine shale from the Wufeng-Longmaxi Formation in China impacts its mechanical strength and how it fractures. By analyzing different types of shale laminations, the researchers found that the density and thickness of these layers, along with mineral composition and microstructure, significantly influence rock strength and fracture patterns, offering crucial insights for optimizing hydraulic fracturing in shale gas reservoirs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Shale formations are a major source of natural gas, but their extraction relies heavily on hydraulic fracturing. The success of this process is intimately tied to the mechanical properties of the shale, particularly how it behaves under stress and how it fractures. A key characteristic of shales is their laminated structure, formed by alternating layers of different materials. While it's understood that these laminations influence mechanical behavior, a systematic understanding of how different lamination characteristics (like the scale, density, and type of layers) affect macroscopic mechanical properties and fracture patterns has been lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by providing a detailed analysis of these relationships in a specific, economically important shale formation.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach to characterize the shale and its mechanical behavior:

  • Field Emission Scanning Electron Microscopy (FE-SEM): Used to visualize the microscopic structures and pore types within the shale samples.
  • Thin Section Observation: Provided visual inspection of the shale's micro-scale features.
  • X-ray Diffraction (XRD): Determined the mineral composition of the shale samples.
  • Triaxial Compression Tests: Measured the rock's compressive strength, elastic modulus, and Poisson's ratio under simulated subsurface pressure conditions.
  • Brazilian Tests: Assessed the rock's tensile strength.

These techniques allowed for a comprehensive analysis of both the physical structure and the mechanical response of the shale under stress.

Datasets

The study utilized core samples collected from the Wufeng-Longmaxi Formation in the South Sichuan Basin, China. Approximately 58 core samples were collected from the L3 well. Specific samples were selected for detailed analysis based on their observed lamination characteristics. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study focused on analyzing existing geological formations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Lamination is not monolithic: The study identified four distinct types of laminasets (GSM1, GSM2, GSM3, and ASM) based on the grading and alternating nature of silt and mud layers, and their relative thicknesses. This classification is crucial because these different laminasets exhibit markedly different mechanical behaviors.
  • Strength follows a pattern: The GSM1 laminaset, characterized by thin silt and thick mud layers, showed the highest mechanical strength and the most complex fracture patterns. Conversely, the GSM3 and ASM laminasets, with thick silt and thin mud layers, were the weakest and exhibited simpler fractures.
  • Mineralogy matters, but so does arrangement: While higher siliceous mineral content (quartz, feldspar) generally correlates with increased strength, the arrangement of these minerals (microstructure) plays a critical role. Grain-supported structures, where brittle mineral grains are closely packed, reduce the energy needed for crack extension, leading to weaker rocks and simpler fractures. Matrix-supported structures, where grains are more dispersed, require more energy for crack propagation, resulting in stronger rocks and more complex fracture networks.
  • Lamina development is a double-edged sword: Increased density and thickness of silt laminae generally lead to lower mechanical strength. This is because these layers often represent weaker interfaces that can act as preferential paths for crack propagation.

Key Results

  • Mechanical Strength Ranking: GSM1 > GSM2 > GSM3 ≈ ASM (Strongest to Weakest).
  • Fracture Complexity Ranking: GSM1 (most intricate) > GSM2 > GSM3 ≈ ASM (simplest).
  • Correlation with Mineral Content: Positive correlation between siliceous mineral content and mechanical properties (tensile strength, compressive strength, elastic modulus). Negative correlation between clay mineral content and mechanical properties.
  • Correlation with Lamina Development: Negative correlation between the density and thickness of silt laminae and mechanical properties.
  • Microstructure Influence: Grain-supported structures generally resulted in weaker mechanical properties and simpler fracture patterns compared to matrix-supported structures.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Specificity: The study focused on a specific formation (Wufeng-Longmaxi) in a particular basin (Sichuan Basin). While valuable, the findings might not be universally applicable to all shale formations without further investigation.
  • Confining Pressure: The triaxial tests were conducted at a high confining pressure (80 MPa). The authors note that this high pressure might have minimized differences in Poisson's ratio, suggesting that further studies at varying confining pressures could provide a more nuanced understanding.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that a deeper understanding of the effects of lamina characteristics on shale's mechanical properties is crucial for optimizing hydraulic fracturing design. This implies that future research could focus on translating these findings into practical engineering applications and exploring other geological settings.

Summary updated

Abstract

The extensive development of lamination structures in shale significantly influences its mechanical properties. However, a systematic analysis of how laminae affect the macroscopic mechanical behavior of rocks remains absent. In this study, field emission scanning electron microscopy (FE-SEM), thin section observation, X-ray diffraction (XRD), triaxial compression and Brazilian tests were carried out on the deep marine shale of the Wufeng-Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin. The results reveal four distinct laminasets: grading thin silt–thick mud (GSM1), grading medium thick silt–mud (GSM2), grading thick silt–thin mud (GSM3) and alternating thick silt–thin mud (ASM). GSM3 and ASM laminasets exhibit the weakest mechanical properties and the simplest fracture patterns, while GSM2 demonstrates moderate mechanical properties and more complex fracture patterns. GSM1 shows the highest mechanical strength and the most intricate fracture patterns. Mechanical properties are positively correlated with siliceous mineral content and negatively correlated with clay mineral content and scale of laminae development (average density and thickness), revealing that lamination plays a key role in fracture behavior, with more intensively developed laminasets leading to the concentrated distribution of brittle silty minerals, facilitating microcrack propagation. Moreover, microstructure has an important effect on both mechanical properties and fracture pattern. In grain-supported structures, closely packed silty brittle mineral grains reduce the energy required for crack extension. In matrix-supported structures, widespread silty brittle mineral grains increase energy requirements for crack extension, leading to more irregular and complex fracture networks. This study enhances the understanding of the effects of lamination on the rock mechanical behavior of shales, optimizing hydraulic fracturing design in shale reservoirs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tan2024characteristics,
  author = {Jingqiang Tan and Baojian Shen and Huricha Wu and Yaohua Wang and Xinyao Ma and Xiao Ma and Wenhui Liu},
  title = {{Characteristics of Lamination in Deep Marine Shale and Its Influence on Mechanical Properties: A Case Study on the Wufeng-Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin}},
  booktitle = {Minerals},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/min14121249},
}
Figure