Characteristics of Four Upward-Pointing Cosmic-Ray-like Events Observed with ANITA

P. W. Gorham, J. W. Nam, A. Romero‐Wolf, S. Hoover, P. Allison, O. Banerjee, J. J. Beatty, K. Belov, Dominique Besson, W. R. Binns, V. Bugaev, Pinlu Cao, C. Chen, Pisin Chen, J. M. Clem, A. Connolly, B. Dailey, Cosmin Deaconu, L. Cremonesi, P. F. Dowkontt, M. A. DuVernois, R. C. Field, B. W. Fox, D. Goldstein, J. Gordon, C. Hast, Clément Hébert, B. Hill, K. Hughes, R. Hupe, M. H. Israel, A. Javaid, J. Kowalski, J. Lam, J. G. Learned, K. M. Liewer, T. C. Liu, J. T. Link, Elizabeth R. Lusczek, S. Matsuno, B. C. Mercurio, C. Miki, P. Miočinović, M. Mottram, Katharine Mulrey, C. J. Naudet, J. Ng, R. J. Nichol, K. J. Palladino, B. F. Rauch, K. Reil, Jason L. Roberts, M. Rosen, Björn Rotter, John W. Russell, Larry Ruckman, D. Saltzberg, D. Seckel, Harm Schoorlemmer, S. Stafford, J. Stockham, M. Stockham, B. Strutt, K. Tatem, G.s. Varner, A. G. Vieregg, D. Walz, Stephanie Wissel, Fan WuPhysical 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reports on four unusual radio-detected cosmic-ray (CR) events observed by the ANITA balloon experiment. Three of these events are stratospheric air showers developing horizontally, while a fourth, steeply upward-pointing event, hints at a possible tau-lepton decay originating from beneath the Antarctic ice. This latter event, if confirmed, could challenge our understanding of tau-neutrino cross-sections.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The study of ultra-high energy (UHE) cosmic rays (CRs) provides crucial insights into the most energetic phenomena in the universe. Traditionally, CRs are detected as they propagate downwards through the atmosphere, creating extensive air showers. However, there's a growing interest in detecting CRs or CR-like signals that originate from unusual directions, such as upward-pointing or Earth-skimming events. These could be signatures of exotic particle interactions or decays, like those of tau leptons produced by tau neutrinos interacting with the Earth. The ANITA experiment, designed to detect radio pulses from UHE neutrinos interacting in the Antarctic ice, is also sensitive to these upward-going CR-like signals. This paper addresses the challenge of identifying and characterizing these rare, anomalous events and exploring their potential origins, particularly the possibility of a tau-lepton decay.

Methods

The ANITA experiment utilizes a balloon-borne array of dual-polarized quad-ridged horn antennas to detect radio pulses. These pulses are generated by the coherent Cherenkov radiation emitted by charged particles in extensive air showers. The experiment precisely measures the polarization (horizontal and vertical) and timing of these radio signals.

For the events discussed, the analysis involved:

  • Signal Identification: Initial identification of CR events from sub-orbital altitudes based on their radio emission characteristics and expected background rates.
  • Polarization Analysis: Examining the polarization planes of the detected radio signals and comparing them to predictions based on the geomagnetic field and Lorentz force. This helps distinguish between direct CR signals and those reflected off the ice.
  • Waveform Analysis: Detailed examination of the time-domain radio pulse shapes to identify characteristic features and potential correlations.
  • Stokes Parameter Decomposition: Analyzing the polarization content of the signals in terms of Stokes parameters (I, Q, U, V) to quantify linear and circular polarization.
  • Geomagnetic Correlation: Comparing the measured Vpol/Hpol ratio of the radio signals to predictions based on the geomagnetic field to infer the shower's direction and origin.
  • Statistical Analysis: Estimating the probability of anthropogenic or instrumental backgrounds mimicking the observed anomalous events using established distributions and calculating likelihood ratios to favor CR over background hypotheses.
  • Energy Estimation: Estimating the energy of the air showers based on simulations and observed parameters.

Datasets

The data used in this paper comes from the ANITA-I and ANITA-II flights of the Antarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna (ANITA) experiment. These flights collected radio pulse data from UHE cosmic rays and neutrinos over Antarctica. No new datasets or benchmarks were introduced in this paper; it focuses on re-analyzing and characterizing previously detected events.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Horizontal Stratospheric Showers: The detection of three CR events developing nearly horizontally at altitudes of 20-30 km is a novel observation. These events are consistent with the expected acceptance of ANITA for the known CR flux at EeV energies.
  • Upward-Pointing Event as a Tau-Lepton Candidate: The fourth event, steeply upward-pointing and originating from beneath the ice, is a particularly intriguing finding. Its characteristics are consistent with a primary particle emerging from the Earth's surface, strongly suggesting a tau-lepton decay.
  • Challenge to Standard Model Neutrino Cross-Sections: If the upward-pointing event is indeed from a tau-lepton decay, it implies a significant suppression of the Standard Model tau-neutrino cross-section. This is because the Earth's density profile at the inferred interaction depth would typically attenuate tau neutrinos to such an extent that detecting their decays would be highly improbable.
  • Polarization as a Discriminator: The detailed analysis of radio pulse polarization (Hpol and Vpol) and Stokes parameters proved crucial in distinguishing between direct CR signals, reflected signals, and potential background.
  • Geomagnetic Field's Role: The strong correlation between the polarization of the radio signals and the Antarctic geomagnetic field provides a powerful tool for inferring the direction and origin of the air showers.

Key Results

  • Three Stratospheric CR Events: Three unusual CR events were identified that developed nearly horizontally in the stratosphere, at altitudes of 20-30 km. Their properties are consistent with expectations for the ANITA experiment's sensitivity to the UHE CR flux.
  • One Upward-Pointing CR-like Event: A fourth event, observed during the ANITA-I flight, points steeply upward and appears to originate from beneath the Antarctic ice.
  • Tau-Lepton Decay Hypothesis: This upward-pointing event's characteristics are consistent with a tau-lepton decay, a process initiated by a tau neutrino interacting with the Earth.
  • Statistical Favoring of CR Hypothesis: For the upward-pointing event, statistical analysis strongly favors a CR hypothesis over anthropogenic backgrounds, with an estimated probability of ~2.4 x 10^-4 for background mimicry.
  • Energy Estimates: Estimated energies for the observed showers range from approximately 0.6 to 9.9 EeV, with the upward-pointing event having an estimated energy of 0.60±0.40 EeV.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Tau-Neutrino Cross-Section Suppression: The primary limitation for interpreting the upward-pointing event as a tau-lepton decay is the need for a significant suppression of the Standard Model tau-neutrino cross-section. This would require a revision of current theoretical models.
  • Uncertainty in Tau-Lepton Decay Origin: While the event suggests a tau-lepton decay, the precise location of the decay along the track remains uncertain, impacting shower energy estimations.
  • Future ANITA Flights: The paper highlights the importance of future ANITA flights (ANITA-III and ANITA-IV), with reinstated CR triggers, to collect more data. This will help confirm or falsify the tau-neutrino interaction hypothesis and potentially provide more events for detailed analysis.
  • Refractive Atmospheric Delay: The observed correlated trailing noise in the upward-pointing event's waveform is consistent with refractive atmospheric delay, suggesting a possible scenario where a tau-lepton initiates a shower in the subsurface ice, with its decay producing a delayed radio emission. This scenario warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

We report on four radio-detected cosmic-ray (CR) or CR-like events observed with the Antarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna (ANITA), a NASA-sponsored long-duration balloon payload. Two of the four were previously identified as stratospheric CR air showers during the ANITA-I flight. A third stratospheric CR was detected during the ANITA-II flight. Here, we report on characteristics of these three unusual CR events, which develop nearly horizontally, 20-30 km above the surface of Earth. In addition, we report on a fourth steeply upward-pointing ANITA-I CR-like radio event which has characteristics consistent with a primary that emerged from the surface of the ice. This suggests a possible τ-lepton decay as the origin of this event, but such an interpretation would require significant suppression of the standard model τ-neutrino cross section.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gorham2016characteristics,
  author = {P. W. Gorham and J. W. Nam and A. Romero‐Wolf and S. Hoover and P. Allison and O. Banerjee and J. J. Beatty and K. Belov and Dominique Besson and W. R. Binns and V. Bugaev and Pinlu Cao and C. Chen and Pisin Chen and J. M. Clem and A. Connolly and B. Dailey and Cosmin Deaconu and L. Cremonesi and P. F. Dowkontt and M. A. DuVernois and R. C. Field and B. W. Fox and D. Goldstein and J. Gordon and C. Hast and Clément Hébert and B. Hill and K. Hughes and R. Hupe and M. H. Israel and A. Javaid and J. Kowalski and J. Lam and J. G. Learned and K. M. Liewer and T. C. Liu and J. T. Link and Elizabeth R. Lusczek and S. Matsuno and B. C. Mercurio and C. Miki and P. Miočinović and M. Mottram and Katharine Mulrey and C. J. Naudet and J. Ng and R. J. Nichol and K. J. Palladino and B. F. Rauch and K. Reil and Jason L. Roberts and M. Rosen and Björn Rotter and John W. Russell and Larry Ruckman and D. Saltzberg and D. Seckel and Harm Schoorlemmer and S. Stafford and J. Stockham and M. Stockham and B. Strutt and K. Tatem and G.S. Varner and A. G. Vieregg and D. Walz and Stephanie Wissel and Fan Wu},
  title = {{Characteristics of Four Upward-Pointing Cosmic-Ray-like Events Observed with ANITA}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.117.071101},
}
Figure