Characteristics of Ethical Leadership: Themes Identification Through Convergent Parallel Mixed Method Design From the Pakistan Context

Hina Shahab, Hafsah Zahur, Naveed Akhtar, Sobia RashidFrontiers in Psychology 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Current approaches to identifying ethical leadership characteristics predominantly reflect Western perspectives rooted in virtue-driven moral philosophy (relativism), often overlooking Asian perspectives based on idealism. This study utilizes a convergent parallel mixed-method design to extract person-driven ethical leadership themes within the Pakistani context. Through a three-phase process, 13 themes were identified, including four novel context-driven themes: altruism, encouragement, collective good, and spiritual transcendence.

Introduction

The concept of "ethical leadership" is frequently treated as a universal construct in management literature. However, most existing frameworks are built upon Western philosophical foundations that may not fully translate to Eastern organizational cultures. This research explores the unique moral landscape of Pakistan to identify leadership traits that global models often miss, challenging the "one size fits all" approach to ethical management.

The Problem: Relativism vs. Idealism

Most research on ethical leadership is rooted in Western "relativism"—a pragmatic, cognitive approach to morality. In contrast, many Eastern societies operate under "absolutism" or "idealism," where moral values are deeply intertwined with religion, social traditions, and spirituality. Because standard leadership scales are designed in the West, they often fail to capture the nuances of ethical behavior in Asian contexts, creating a "blind spot" for multinational organizations and local managers alike.

Methodology

The researchers employed a Convergent Parallel Mixed Method Design, treating qualitative and quantitative data as equal, independent strands that are merged to find points of convergence.

Methodological framework outlining the three phases of theme identification.

The study proceeded in three distinct phases:

  1. Phase 1 (Deductive): A systematic literature review to identify established ethical leadership traits.
  2. Phase 2 (Inductive): Qualitative inquiry using open-ended questionnaires with 14 experts (7 corporate, 7 academic) to allow new, context-specific traits to emerge.
  3. Phase 3 (Integration): Triangulation of data to identify overlapping and emerging themes.

Key Results: The 13 Themes of Ethical Leadership

The study successfully identified 13 themes that define ethical leadership in the Pakistani context. While nine of these themes—such as honesty, fairness, and accountability—overlap with Western literature, four themes emerged as unique cultural drivers.

Final 13 themes of ethical leadership identified through convergent parallel analysis.

The Four Emerging Themes

  • Altruism: A selfless concern for the well-being of others.
  • Encouragement: Actively supporting and building the skills of subordinates.
  • Collective Good: Prioritizing the group's welfare over individual metrics, reflecting collectivist cultural values.
  • Spiritual Transcendence: A leader’s sense of connection to a higher purpose or faith, which serves as a fundamental component of their ethical identity.

Discussion

A significant finding is the role of the "fatherly" leader in collectivist cultures. Ethical leaders in Pakistan are often perceived as nurturing figures who prioritize the "collective good" and provide "encouragement." Furthermore, while "honesty" is a universal trait, its justification in the Pakistani context is often tied to spiritual mandates rather than just organizational health. This suggests that for Pakistani employees, a leader’s faith and sense of purpose are inseparable from their perceived ethics.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The study confirms that Eastern ethical positioning is heavily influenced by idealism and spirituality, whereas Western positioning leans toward relativism. While the small sample size (14 experts) is a limitation, these findings provide a robust foundation for developing an "Eastern Ethical Leadership Scale." Such a tool would allow for more culturally resonant measurements of leadership effectiveness in Asian workplaces, moving beyond the limitations of Western-centric metrics.

Summary updated

Abstract

The current approaches in identifying the characteristics of ethical leadership proceed mainly from a Western perspective based on virtue-driven moral philosophy (i.e., relativism) and frequently ignoring the Asian perspective of morality based on idealism. This study aimed to conduct parallel analysis in convergent design by using qualitative and quantitative methods to extract person-driven ethical leadership themes by considering the Asian context. Using the hypothetico-deductive method, 13 themes were extracted altogether, out of which 4 are new context-driven themes (i.e., altruism, encouragement, collective good, and spiritual transcendence as the emerging themes of ethical leadership in the Asian context).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shahab2021characteristics,
  author = {Hina Shahab and Hafsah Zahur and Naveed Akhtar and Sobia Rashid},
  title = {{Characteristics of Ethical Leadership: Themes Identification Through Convergent Parallel Mixed Method Design From the Pakistan Context}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2021.787796},
}
Figure