Characteristics and Causes of Particularly Major Road Traffic Accidents Involving Commercial Vehicles in China

Mingwei Yan, Wentao Chen, Jianhao Wang, Mengmeng Zhang, Liang ZhaoInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study delves into the characteristics and root causes of particularly major road traffic accidents involving commercial vehicles in China, analyzing 11 severe incidents. It highlights that while driver error and vehicle failure are immediate causes, deeper organizational deficiencies in safety management systems and culture are the underlying drivers, emphasizing the need for systemic improvements.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Road traffic accidents, especially those involving commercial vehicles, pose a significant threat globally, leading to injuries, fatalities, and substantial economic losses. In China, major accidents involving commercial vehicles have been a recurring issue. While previous research has touched upon various contributing factors like environmental conditions, vehicle mechanics, and driver behavior, there's a need for a more comprehensive understanding of the complex interplay of causes, particularly for severe "particularly major" accidents. This paper aims to bridge this gap by dissecting the characteristics and identifying the multi-layered causal factors of these high-impact events.

Methods

The study employs a mixed-methods approach, combining statistical analysis of accident data with a qualitative analysis of accident reports. The core analytical framework is the "24Model," an improved causation model developed by the research team, building upon the domino accident theory and the Swiss Cheese Model. This model categorizes accident causes into individual and organizational levels, further breaking them down into unsafe acts, unsafe conditions, flaws in habitual behaviors, deficiencies in safety management systems, and weaknesses in safety culture. The researchers extracted data from 11 particularly major accident investigation reports, analyzing characteristics like time, location, and vehicle type. They then used the 24Model to systematically identify and classify causal factors across different levels.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 11 "particularly major" road traffic accidents involving commercial vehicles that occurred in China between 2010 and 2019. This data was sourced from investigation reports provided by the Ministry of Emergency Management of the People's Republic of China. The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather analyzes existing accident investigation data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Freeways are Hotspots: A striking finding is that 10 out of the 11 analyzed accidents occurred on freeways, underscoring the inherent risks associated with high-speed environments for commercial vehicles.
  • Peak Accident Times: The study identifies specific time windows for increased risk: early morning (2:00-4:00) and mid-afternoon (14:00-16:00), coinciding with periods of driver fatigue.
  • Summer Season Vulnerability: The months of May to August, particularly during the summer, show a higher incidence of these accidents, likely due to increased traffic volume and driver fatigue exacerbated by high temperatures.
  • Beyond Driver Error: While speeding and fatigued driving are identified as direct causes, the research strongly emphasizes that these are often symptoms of deeper organizational issues.
  • Systemic Failures: The analysis reveals significant deficiencies in organizational safety management systems, touching upon elements like safety accountability, training, and hazard identification. The paper notes that even when procedures exist, they are often not followed, and their implementation is not effectively assessed.
  • Culture is Key: The most profound insight is that weaknesses in organizational safety culture are the ultimate source of these accidents. This is characterized by a lack of understanding and commitment to safety's importance, safety management systems, and the integration of safety into daily operations.

Key Results

  • Vehicle Types: Large buses and dangerous goods vehicles were involved in 10 of the 11 accidents, highlighting their critical role and the need for stringent supervision.
  • Accident Locations: Freeways were the predominant location for these severe accidents.
  • Immediate Causes: Speeding (6 occurrences), fatigued driving (4 occurrences), and improper emergency operations were the most frequent direct causes.
  • Organizational Deficiencies: The study identified deficiencies across 12 key elements of safety management systems and highlighted weaknesses in safety culture, particularly concerning the recognition of safety's importance, commitment, and the effectiveness of safety practices.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study's focus on "particularly major" accidents means the sample size is relatively small, which can limit the statistical significance of some findings, especially regarding accident characteristics. They suggest that future research should expand to include a larger sample of general commercial vehicle accidents to allow for more robust comparative analysis. Additionally, while the study effectively identifies accident characteristics and causes, it did not delve deeply into specific accident prevention measures for governments, enterprises, and individuals. This area is identified as a crucial direction for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Major accidents occurred frequently in the road transportation industry, and the resulting harm to drivers, property loss, and traffic interruption are very serious. This study investigated 11 particularly major accidents involving commercial vehicles in China, and performed analysis on accident characteristics regarding the time, location, types of vehicles, and accident causation at different levels based on the 24Model. Large buses and dangerous goods vehicles were involved in 10 accidents and they all occurred on a freeway. The months from May to August, especially during the time periods of 2:00-4:00 and 14:00-16:00 every day, were the most prone to accidents. The driver's speeding and fatigued driving, and vehicle failure were the direct causes of most of the accidents. The defects in organizational safety management involved 12 system elements, such as safety accountability, education and training, etc. Procedures are of no use if they were not followed, and there was often no effective process to assess the implementation of procedures in many organizations. The weaknesses in organizational safety culture were the source of accidents, which was mainly manifested in members' inadequate cognition of key elements in the aspects of safety importance, safety commitment, safety management system, etc. Understanding the characteristics and root causes of accidents can help to prevent the recurrence of similar mistakes and strengthen preventative measures in road transportation enterprises.
BibTeX
@article{yan2021characteristics,
  author = {Mingwei Yan and Wentao Chen and Jianhao Wang and Mengmeng Zhang and Liang Zhao},
  title = {{Characteristics and Causes of Particularly Major Road Traffic Accidents Involving Commercial Vehicles in China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph18083878},
}
Figure