Characterisation of slip and twin activity using digital image correlation and crystal plasticity finite element simulation: Application to orthorhombic α-uranium

Nicolò Grilli, Philip Earp, A.c.f. Cocks, T.j. Marrow, Edmund TarletonJournal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel method to accurately calibrate crystal plasticity models for complex materials like uranium. By combining digital image correlation (DIC) with crystal plasticity finite element (CPFE) simulations and an optimization algorithm, the researchers can precisely determine the critical stresses and hardening behaviors of various slip and twinning systems, even in coarse-grained materials. This approach offers a more efficient and reliable way to understand material deformation compared to traditional methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Developing accurate material models for crystal plasticity is crucial for predicting how materials deform under stress. However, calibrating these models is challenging, especially for materials with numerous potential slip and twinning systems, like orthorhombic α-uranium. Traditional methods often rely on testing single crystals or analyzing averaged responses from polycrystalline samples, which can be impractical or miss critical microstructural details. This paper tackles the problem of efficiently and accurately determining the parameters for crystal plasticity models, specifically focusing on the complex slip and twinning behaviors in coarse-grained α-uranium, which has limited ductility and a complex deformation response.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the synergistic combination of three key techniques:

  • Digital Image Correlation (DIC): This non-contact optical method is used to measure full-field surface strains and displacements on a tensile testing specimen. By applying a speckle pattern to the specimen surface, DIC can capture detailed deformation maps at a high resolution.
  • Crystal Plasticity Finite Element (CPFE) Simulations: This computational approach models the mechanical behavior of materials at the crystal level. It considers the anisotropic elastic properties, plastic deformation due to slip, and twinning within individual grains. The simulated geometry is directly informed by experimental electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD) data, providing realistic grain shapes and orientations.
  • Optimization Algorithm (Nelder-Mead): An optimization algorithm is employed to systematically adjust the parameters of the CPFE model. This algorithm iteratively runs simulations and compares the predicted strain evolution within individual grains to the experimentally measured strains from DIC. The goal is to find the set of model parameters that best reproduces the experimental data, effectively calibrating the model.

The novelty lies in using this integrated approach to not only calibrate the critical resolved shear stress (CRSS) for slip and twinning but also to investigate and quantify the hardening mechanisms and interactions between these deformation modes.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is derived from tensile testing experiments on two coarse-grained α-uranium dog-bone specimens.

  • Experimental Data:
    • Digital Image Correlation (DIC) measurements: Full-field strain and displacement data were collected during tensile loading.
  • Electron Backscatter Diffraction (EBSD) maps: These provided the grain size, shape, and crystallographic orientation information for constructing the CPFE model geometry.
  • Stress-strain curves: Measured for the overall specimen and individual grains.
  • Benchmark Data (for comparison): The paper references existing data for fine-grained α-uranium and other materials to contextualize their findings on hardening rates and interaction coefficients.

The study introduces a novel benchmark by directly comparing detailed, grain-specific experimental strain fields with CPFE simulations, enabling a more rigorous validation of the calibrated model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • DIC + CPFE + Optimization is a Powerful Calibration Tool: The study demonstrates that combining these techniques provides a robust framework for calibrating complex crystal plasticity models, even for challenging materials like α-uranium. This approach allows for the determination of parameters that are difficult to obtain through traditional methods.
  • Slip-Twin Interactions are Crucial for Uranium: The research highlights that understanding the interplay between slip and twinning is essential for accurately modeling the deformation of α-uranium. The hardening of twin systems is significantly influenced by the activity of other slip and twin systems.
  • Coarse-Grained Uranium Exhibits Different Hardening: The hardening rate of the most active slip system ("wall" slip) in coarse-grained α-uranium is found to be lower than in fine-grained counterparts. This suggests that microstructural scale plays a significant role in deformation mechanisms.
  • Twin-Coplanar Model Best Captures Behavior: Among the tested hardening models for twin systems, the "twin-coplanar" model, which accounts for interactions between coplanar twins and slip, provided the best fit to the experimental data.
  • Quantifying Interaction Coefficients is Now Possible: The optimization procedure successfully identified interaction coefficients between slip and twin systems, as well as between coplanar twins. These parameters were previously not well-characterized for α-uranium.

Key Results

  • The developed method successfully calibrated the critical resolved shear stress (CRSS) and hardening parameters for 8 slip systems and 2 twin variants in coarse-grained α-uranium.
  • The twin-coplanar hardening model (equation 12) was identified as the most accurate for describing the behavior of the {130}(310) twin system.
  • The "wall" slip system (α=1) was found to be the most active due to its lower CRSS.
  • The dislocation density in the "wall" slip system increased by approximately 100 times at 1% total strain.
  • The twin volume fraction reached about 12% at 2% total strain, primarily driven by the {130}[310] twin system.
  • The simulated stress-strain curves and strain fields closely matched the experimental DIC measurements, validating the calibrated model.
  • The hardening rate of the "wall" slip system in coarse-grained α-uranium was found to be lower than in fine-grained material.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Grain Orientation Uncertainty: The study acknowledges that the approximation of uniform crystal orientations within each grain in the initial optimization procedure introduced some uncertainty. While an uncertainty quantification was performed, further refinement could improve accuracy.
  • Distinguishing Interaction Mechanisms: The current approach, particularly with the twin-coplanar model, can't definitively distinguish between the interaction of twins with slip systems versus the interaction between coplanar twins. Future work could aim to disentangle these specific contributions.
  • Generalizability: While the method is presented as generalizable, its application to other materials with different crystal structures and deformation mechanisms would require further validation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that this optimization technique can be readily adapted to identify the CRSS and hardening parameters of other coarse-grained materials, paving the way for more accurate material modeling across various applications. The method's ability to avoid the need for single-crystal samples and its efficiency in determining numerous parameters from a single test are significant advantages for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Calibrating and verifying crystal plasticity material models is a significant challenge, particularly for materials with a number of potential slip and twin systems. Here we use digital image correlation on coarse-grained α-uranium during tensile testing in conjunction with crystal plasticity finite element simulations. This approach allows us to determine the critical resolved shear stress, interaction mechanisms and hardening rate of the different slip and twin systems. The constitutive model is based on dislocation densities and twin volume fractions as state variables, and the simulated geometry is constructed from electron backscatter diffraction images that provide shape, size and orientation of the grains, allowing a direct comparison between virtual and real experiments. An optimisation algorithm is used to discriminate between different models for the slip-twin interactions and to find the parameters that reproduce the evolution of the average strain in each grain as the load is increased. A tensile bar, containing four grains aligned with the load direction, is used to calibrate the model with eight unknown parameters. The approach is then independently validated by simulating the strain distribution in a second tensile bar. Different mechanisms for the hardening of the twin systems are evaluated, based on the interaction between coplanar and non-coplanar twins. The latent hardening of the most active twin system turns out to be determined by coplanar twins and slip. The hardening rate of the most active slip system is lower than in fine-grained α-uranium. The method outlined here can be applied to identify the critical resolved shear stress and slip-twin interaction mechanisms of other coarse-grained materials.
BibTeX
@article{grilli2019characterisation,
  author = {Nicolò Grilli and Philip Earp and A.C.F. Cocks and T.J. Marrow and Edmund Tarleton},
  title = {{Characterisation of slip and twin activity using digital image correlation and crystal plasticity finite element simulation: Application to orthorhombic α-uranium}},
  journal = {Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jmps.2019.103800},
}
Figure