Changing the responses of cortical neurons from sub- to suprathreshold using single spikes in vivo

Verena Pawlak, David S. Greenberg, Henning Sprekeler, Wulfram Gerstner, Jason N. D. KerreLife 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that spike-timing-dependent plasticity (STDP) in the visual cortex of rats can fundamentally alter how neurons respond to visual stimuli. By pairing a single postsynaptic action potential with presynaptic input at precise timings, researchers could either transform a neuron's subthreshold response into a full action potential or suppress its existing spiking activity, suggesting STDP is a key mechanism for dynamic cortical circuit rewiring.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The brain's ability to adapt and learn relies on synaptic plasticity, where the strength of connections between neurons changes over time. Spike-timing-dependent plasticity (STDP) is a leading candidate mechanism, proposing that the precise timing of pre- and postsynaptic action potentials (spikes) dictates whether a synapse is strengthened or weakened. While STDP has been extensively studied in vitro, its functional relevance in vivo, particularly in transforming a neuron's output spiking behavior (from subthreshold to suprathreshold, or vice versa), has remained unclear. Specifically, how STDP might dynamically change a neuron's tuning to specific features in the environment and whether these changes are significant enough to alter information processing in real-time were open questions.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of in vivo electrophysiology and computational modeling.

  • Whole-cell recordings: They performed whole-cell patch-clamp recordings in the visual cortex of anesthetized rats to measure the membrane potential of individual neurons.
  • Visual Stimulation: A bar stimulus was presented at different locations on a screen to activate specific receptive fields.
  • STDP Induction Protocol: The core of the experiment involved pairing a single, artificially evoked postsynaptic action potential (via brief current injection) with the visually evoked presynaptic input. This pairing was repeated approximately 40 times. Crucially, the timing of the postsynaptic spike relative to the peak of the visually evoked subthreshold response was manipulated:
  • Positive Timing: Postsynaptic spike occurred after the initial peak of the visual response.
  • Negative Timing: Postsynaptic spike occurred before the initial peak of the visual response.
  • Computational Modeling: A biophysical model of a postsynaptic neuron was developed to simulate the effects of STDP. This model incorporated realistic EPSP shapes and allowed for the introduction of temporal jitter in presynaptic inputs to investigate its impact on the observed plasticity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on in vivo recordings from animal subjects.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • STDP as a "Functional Status Changer": The most striking finding is that STDP, even with a limited number of pairings (around 40), can convert a neuron that previously only showed a subthreshold response to a visual stimulus into one that fires action potentials (suprathreshold response). This suggests STDP can fundamentally change a neuron's role in information processing.
  • Bidirectional Control via Timing: The direction of plasticity is precisely controlled by spike timing. Postsynaptic spikes following presynaptic input (positive timing) potentiate the response, potentially turning subthreshold responses into spiking ones. Conversely, postsynaptic spikes preceding presynaptic input (negative timing) depress the response, reducing spiking activity.
  • Spatiotemporal Reorganization: The plasticity wasn't confined to the directly stimulated location. Changes in spiking responses extended to neighboring stimulus locations, indicating a spatial reorganization of the neuron's receptive field. This reorganization was also reflected in the "stimulus response center," which shifted towards the paired location after positive timing STDP.
  • The Role of Temporal Jitter: Computational simulations revealed that the broader temporal windows of plasticity observed in vivo (compared to in vitro) could be explained by the inherent temporal jitter in presynaptic inputs from different cortical layers. This highlights the importance of considering the complex, noisy nature of real neural circuits.
  • Small Voltage Changes, Big Spiking Impact: The study demonstrates that relatively small changes in membrane potential (around 2 mV) induced by STDP can be sufficient to significantly alter a neuron's spiking probability. This underscores the sensitivity of neuronal output to subtle synaptic modifications.

Key Results

  • Conversion to Spiking: In 8 out of 15 neurons that initially responded subthreshold to a paired stimulus, positive timing STDP induction led to stimulus-evoked spiking after the protocol. Overall, positive timing increased spiking by an average of 0.11 ± 0.06 APs per stimulus.
  • Suppression of Spiking: Negative timing STDP induction led to a decrease in spiking in 12 out of 15 tested neurons, with an average reduction of 0.18 ± 0.10 APs per stimulus.
  • Spatial Spread: Stimulus positions immediately adjacent to the paired location showed a significant increase in AP firing (0.10 ± 0.05 APs per stimulus) after positive timing STDP, though this effect diminished with distance.
  • Response Center Shift: For positive timing, the suprathreshold stimulus response center shifted significantly towards the paired position (correlated with the initial distance, R = 0.81, p=0.008). Subthreshold response centers also shifted, though less robustly.
  • Model Validation: The computational model successfully reproduced the observed biphasic membrane potential changes and the transfer of plasticity to neighboring locations, particularly when presynaptic temporal jitter was included.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Anesthetized State: The experiments were conducted in anesthetized rats. While this allows for precise control and stable recordings, it may not fully reflect the dynamic plasticity occurring in awake, behaving animals. The authors acknowledge this by referencing studies in awake animals.
  • Focus on Single Spikes: The study focused on the effect of single postsynaptic spikes paired with presynaptic input. While this is a key aspect of STDP, real-world neural activity involves complex patterns of spikes.
  • Subthreshold vs. Suprathreshold: The paper explores both subthreshold and suprathreshold changes. While the conversion from sub- to suprathreshold is a major finding, the precise mechanisms by which small voltage changes translate to spiking are complex and not fully elucidated, especially in vivo.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that this STDP-driven mechanism is fundamental to how neurons join and leave cell assemblies, playing a role in sensory learning and circuit rewiring. Future work could explore how these changes integrate across larger populations of neurons and contribute to more complex cognitive functions. The role of different types of synaptic inputs and their interaction with STDP in vivo also remains an area for further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Action Potential (APs) patterns of sensory cortex neurons encode a variety of stimulus features, but how can a neuron change the feature to which it responds? Here, we show that in vivo a spike-timing-dependent plasticity (STDP) protocol-consisting of pairing a postsynaptic AP with visually driven presynaptic inputs-modifies a neurons' AP-response in a bidirectional way that depends on the relative AP-timing during pairing. Whereas postsynaptic APs repeatedly following presynaptic activation can convert subthreshold into suprathreshold responses, APs repeatedly preceding presynaptic activation reduce AP responses to visual stimulation. These changes were paralleled by restructuring of the neurons response to surround stimulus locations and membrane-potential time-course. Computational simulations could reproduce the observed subthreshold voltage changes only when presynaptic temporal jitter was included. Together this shows that STDP rules can modify output patterns of sensory neurons and the timing of single-APs plays a crucial role in sensory coding and plasticity.DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.00012.001.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pawlak2013changing,
  author = {Verena Pawlak and David S. Greenberg and Henning Sprekeler and Wulfram Gerstner and Jason N. D. Kerr},
  title = {{Changing the responses of cortical neurons from sub- to suprathreshold using single spikes in vivo}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.00012},
}
Figure