Changes of PBP5 Gene Expression in Enterococcal Isolates from Renal Transplantation Recipients

Tomasz Jarzembowski, Agnieszka Daca, Jacek M. Witkowski, Leszek Rutkowski, Justyna Gołębiewska, Alicja Dębska‐ŚlizieńBioMed Research International 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how immunosuppression in renal transplant recipients affects the expression of the PBP5 gene in Enterococcus bacteria, a common cause of infections in these patients. Using a novel Flow-FISH technique, researchers found that PBP5 gene expression is significantly higher in Enterococcus strains from transplant patients compared to commensal strains, and that the immunosuppressant cyclosporine appears to further upregulate this gene.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Enterococcus species, often harmless commensals, can cause severe infections in immunocompromised individuals, particularly renal transplant (RTx) recipients. Managing these infections is challenging due to Enterococcus's intrinsic resistance to common antibiotics like β-lactams. This resistance is partly due to a specific penicillin-binding protein (PBP), PBP5, which can compensate for other inhibited PBPs. Bacteria can modulate the expression of resistance genes in response to environmental conditions, making it crucial to understand how factors like immunosuppression influence this. This paper aims to elucidate how immunosuppressive therapy in RTx patients impacts the expression of the PBP5 gene in Enterococcus isolates.

Methods

The researchers employed a Flow-FISH (Fluorescence In Situ Hybridization) technique, a sophisticated method that combines flow cytometry with FISH. This allows for the detection and quantification of specific mRNA molecules (in this case, PBP5 mRNA) within individual bacterial cells. They used a linear locked nucleic acid (LNA) probe designed to bind specifically to PBP5 mRNA, labeled with a fluorescent marker (FITC). This probe offers high affinity for DNA and RNA, enabling sensitive detection.

To analyze gene expression, they measured two parameters:

  1. Mean probe fluorescence (FL1) normalized by DNA fluorescence (FL3): This accounts for variations in cell size and DNA content.
  2. Median fluorescence (MFL1) weighted by the percentage of probe-binding particles: This metric considers both the intensity of the signal and the proportion of cells expressing the gene.

The study also involved:

  • MIC determination: Standard E-test was used to assess penicillin resistance.
  • Biofilm formation: Strains were cultured in vitro to form biofilms.
  • In vitro drug exposure: Bacterial strains were exposed to varying concentrations of cyclosporine and tacrolimus to mimic therapeutic levels.

Datasets

The study utilized two main groups of Enterococcus strains:

  1. Clinical isolates: Forty strains isolated from urine and feces of RTx recipients at the Medical University of Gdańsk.
  2. Reference strains: Seven commensal strains from healthy volunteers and two reference strains (ATCC 51299 and ATCC 29212).

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the focus was on analyzing clinical isolates and comparing them to commensal and reference strains.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Immunosuppression as a driver of resistance gene expression: The study strongly suggests that the immunosuppressive environment in RTx patients directly influences bacterial resistance mechanisms, specifically by upregulating PBP5 gene expression.
  • Biofilm vs. Planktonic differences: While commensal strains showed higher PBP5 expression in planktonic form, RTx isolates exhibited significantly higher expression in biofilms. This suggests that Enterococcus may adapt differently to the RTx environment, potentially enhancing its survival and virulence in biofilm communities.
  • Differential effects of immunosuppressants: Cyclosporine appears to be a more potent inducer of PBP5 expression than tacrolimus, at least in vitro. This has implications for antibiotic treatment strategies in RTx patients.
  • Flow-FISH as a powerful tool: The study highlights the utility of Flow-FISH for single-cell analysis of gene expression, enabling the detection of subtle changes and rare cell populations that might be missed by bulk methods.

Key Results

  • Higher PBP5 expression in RTx isolates: PBP5 gene expression was significantly higher in Enterococcus strains isolated from RTx patients (median FL1/FL3 of 3.43, MFL1FL1(+) of 3.09) compared to commensal strains (median FL1/FL3 of 0.48, MFL1FL1(+) of 0.46).
  • Biofilm advantage in RTx patients: In RTx isolates, PBP5 gene expression was 17.45% higher in biofilms than in planktonic cells. This is in contrast to commensal strains, where planktonic expression was higher.
  • Cyclosporine's potentiation: In vitro studies showed that cyclosporine seemed to induce higher PBP5 expression compared to tacrolimus.
  • Penicillin resistance correlation: While not statistically proven, higher median MIC values for penicillin were observed in patients treated with cyclosporine (265 µg/mL) compared to tacrolimus (132 µg/mL), potentially linking cyclosporine's effect to increased resistance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Correlation vs. Causation: While the study shows a correlation between immunosuppression and PBP5 expression, and in vitro induction by specific drugs, definitively proving causation in vivo requires further investigation.
  • Interpretation of biofilm findings: The authors acknowledge that the role of PBP5 in cell wall biosynthesis is not fully understood, making the interpretation of the biofilm-specific upregulation speculative.
  • Limited scope of immunosuppressants: The study focused on cyclosporine and tacrolimus. Other immunosuppressive agents and their combinations were not investigated.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that further studies are needed to analyze other aspects of cyclosporine's effect on bacterial cells, including its potential to modify biofilm properties. They also propose that antibiotic therapy using β-lactams might be more effective if tacrolimus is chosen over cyclosporine as the immunosuppressant, but this requires further validation. Investigating the specific PBP5 variants and their affinity for penicillin, as well as post-translational modifications, could also provide deeper insights.

Summary updated

Abstract

The aim of the study was to evaluate changes in expression of PBP5 gene associated with immunosuppression. A linear locked nucleic acid (LNA) probe was used to measure resistance gene expression by the Flow-FISH method. Expression of the PBP5 gene measured by Flow-FISH was higher in enterococcal strains isolated from renal transplantation (RTx) recipients than in commensal strains. Additionally, in contrast to commensal strains in isolates from RTx patients, PBP5 gene expression was 17.45% higher in biofilms than in planktonic cells. Detailed comparison also showed that cyclosporine seemed to induce higher expression of PBP5 as compared to tacrolimus.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jarzembowski2013changes,
  author = {Tomasz Jarzembowski and Agnieszka Daca and Jacek M. Witkowski and Leszek Rutkowski and Justyna Gołębiewska and Alicja Dębska‐Ślizień},
  title = {{Changes of PBP5 Gene Expression in Enterococcal Isolates from Renal Transplantation Recipients}},
  booktitle = {BioMed Research International},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1155/2013/687156},
}
Figure