Changes in the Response Rate and Response Variability of Area V4 Neurons During the Preparation of Saccadic Eye Movements

Nicholas A. Steinmetz, Tirin MooreJournal of Neurophysiology 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the variability in the firing rate of neurons in visual area V4, not just their average firing rate, provides a crucial signal for preparing eye movements (saccades). This variability decrease reliably predicts how quickly an animal will make a saccade, even when the average firing rate doesn't change, suggesting it captures a distinct aspect of motor preparation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

We know that our brain's visual system and motor control systems are tightly linked. When we prepare to move our eyes (a saccade), our visual perception can be enhanced at the target location. Neuroscientists have observed that neurons in visual areas, like V4, change their activity (modulate their firing rate) when a saccade is being prepared, especially if the target is within their receptive field. However, it's been unclear how this preparation is reflected in neuronal activity. While changes in the average firing rate have been studied, recent work in other brain areas suggests that the variability of neuronal responses across trials might be a more sensitive indicator of motor preparation. This paper aims to investigate whether this across-trial variability in V4 neurons also serves as a signature of saccade preparation and how it relates to the more commonly studied average firing rate.

Methods

The researchers recorded the activity of single neurons in area V4 of two macaque monkeys while they performed a visually guided saccade task. The task involved the monkeys fixating a central spot, then seeing a visual stimulus appear in the neuron's receptive field (RF). After a delay, they were cued to make a saccade to a target, which could be within the RF ("toward" condition) or outside the RF ("up" or "opposite" conditions).

Key analytical techniques included:

  • Mean Firing Rate Calculation: Standard measurement of the average number of spikes per unit time.
  • Fano Factor (FF) Calculation: This is the core measure of response variability. It's calculated by dividing the variance of spike counts across trials by the mean spike count within a specific time window. An FF of 1 suggests a Poisson process, while values significantly above or below 1 indicate over- or under-dispersion of spikes, respectively.
  • "Mean-Matching" Procedure: To isolate the effect of variability changes from changes in mean firing rate, they used a sophisticated statistical method. This involved randomly discarding trials to equalize the distribution of mean spike counts across time, allowing them to analyze FF changes independent of mean firing rate fluctuations.
  • Saccadic Reaction Time (RT) Analysis: Trials were sorted into "short RT" and "long RT" groups, and the neural activity was compared between these groups to see if it predicted reaction time.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The data comes from electrophysiological recordings in macaque monkeys performing a specific behavioral task.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Variability as a Saccade Prep Signal: The most striking finding is that a decrease in the Fano Factor (across-trial variability) in V4 neurons reliably precedes saccades, regardless of whether the saccade is directed towards or away from the neuron's receptive field.
  • Complementary Signatures: Both mean firing rate and response variability change during saccade preparation, but they capture different aspects. Mean firing rate is more sensitive to the direction of the saccade (specifically, enhancement for RF targets), while variability seems to reflect the progress of preparation more generally.
  • Predicting Behavior: The decrease in FF before a saccade was a better predictor of saccadic reaction time than the change in mean firing rate, especially for saccades directed away from the RF. This suggests that variability might be a more fundamental or earlier indicator of motor preparation.
  • Independence from Mean Rate: The study provides strong evidence that the presaccadic decrease in FF is not simply a byproduct of changes in mean firing rate. Even after statistically controlling for mean firing rate changes, the FF still decreased and predicted RT.
  • Microsaccade Control: The researchers ruled out the possibility that the observed FF decrease was due to the natural reduction in microsaccades (small, involuntary eye movements) that occurs before a saccade.

Key Results

  • Mean Firing Rate: Increased for saccades directed towards the neuron's RF, but showed no significant change for saccades away from the RF.
  • Fano Factor (FF): Showed a robust decrease prior to saccades in all tested directions (toward, up, opposite). This decrease was greatest for saccades toward the RF, but a significant decrease was still observed for other directions.
  • Predicting RT:
    • For saccades towards the RF, both mean firing rate and FF predicted RT.
  • For saccades away from the RF, only FF predicted RT; mean firing rate did not.
  • Mean-Matched Analysis: Even after statistically removing the influence of mean firing rate changes, the presaccadic FF decline persisted and still predicted RT.
  • RT Group Differences: Short RT trials were associated with lower FF values around the time of the movement cue compared to long RT trials, suggesting that reduced variability reflects faster preparation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Task Design: The authors acknowledge that the task design, where the "toward" saccade was cued by the absence of a target while other saccades were cued by target appearance, could be a confounding factor. However, they argue that their findings on FF are independent of this cueing difference.
  • Interpretation of Variability: While FF is a measure of across-trial variability, the precise neural mechanisms underlying this decrease are not fully elucidated. The authors speculate about potential links to gamma-frequency oscillations and attention, but these are areas for future investigation.
  • Future Directions: The paper suggests exploring the relationship between FF and other neural measures like gamma-band oscillations. Further work could also investigate how these findings generalize to other motor preparation tasks (e.g., reaching) and other visual areas. The authors also highlight the need for a more integrated view of how visual cortical areas contribute to behavior, leveraging multiple neural signatures like firing rate and variability.

Summary updated

Abstract

The visually driven responses of macaque area V4 neurons are modulated during the preparation of saccadic eye movements, but the relationship between presaccadic modulation in area V4 and saccade preparation is poorly understood. Recent neurophysiological studies suggest that the variability across trials of spiking responses provides a more reliable signature of motor preparation than mean firing rate across trials. We compared the dynamics of the response rate and the variability in the rate across trials for area V4 neurons during the preparation of visually guided saccades. As in previous reports, we found that the mean firing rate of V4 neurons was enhanced when saccades were prepared to stimuli within a neuron's receptive field (RF) in comparison with saccades to a non-RF location. Further, we found robust decreases in response variability prior to saccades and found that these decreases predicted saccadic reaction times for saccades both to RF and non-RF stimuli. Importantly, response variability predicted reaction time whether or not there were any accompanying changes in mean firing rate. In addition to predicting saccade direction, the mean firing rate could also predict reaction time, but only for saccades directed to the RF stimuli. These results demonstrate that response variability of area V4 neurons, like mean response rate, provides a signature of saccade preparation. However, the two signatures reflect complementary aspects of that preparation.
BibTeX
@article{steinmetz2009changes,
  author = {Nicholas A. Steinmetz and Tirin Moore},
  title = {{Changes in the Response Rate and Response Variability of Area V4 Neurons During the Preparation of Saccadic Eye Movements}},
  journal = {Journal of Neurophysiology},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1152/jn.00689.2009},
}
Figure