Changes in taxonomic and phylogenetic diversity in the Anthropocene

Daijiang Li, Julian D. Olden, Julie L. Lockwood, Sydne Record, Michael L. McKinney, Benjamin BaiserProceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that while local species richness (SR) is often increasing, global biodiversity is undergoing significant homogenization. Crucially, taxonomic and phylogenetic diversity are not always changing in tandem, highlighting the need for a more nuanced approach to conservation that considers evolutionary history alongside species counts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how biodiversity is changing in response to human activities (the Anthropocene) is a critical challenge. Previous research has often focused on local species richness (SR), yielding conflicting results: some studies show increases, while others report declines, particularly in human-impacted areas. This ambiguity arises from using different methodologies and focusing on only one aspect of diversity. This paper addresses the need for a more comprehensive understanding by examining both taxonomic (species identity) and phylogenetic (evolutionary history) diversity across different spatial scales (local α diversity and regional β diversity) and using multiple data types and taxonomic groups. The core question is: how are these different facets of biodiversity changing globally due to anthropogenic pressures, and are these changes consistent?

Methods

The researchers conducted a large-scale meta-analysis, compiling 162 datasets from around the world covering fish, birds, and plants. They analyzed biodiversity changes using three primary approaches:

  • Land Use Gradients: Comparing diversity in areas with varying degrees of human impact (e.g., urban vs. natural habitats).
  • Species Lists: Analyzing historical and contemporary lists of species within specific regions, including the establishment of non-native species.
  • Resampling Data: Comparing species composition at the same locations across different time periods (at least 20 years apart).

They measured:

  • α diversity (within-site): Species Richness (SR) and Faith's Phylogenetic Diversity (PD, non-independent of SR), and Phylogenetic Species Variability (PSV, independent of SR).
  • β diversity (between-site): Taxonomic turnover (using Sorensen dissimilarity) and Phylogenetic turnover (using phylogenetic Sorensen dissimilarity and Phylogenetic Community Dissimilarity - PCDp, independent of SR).

Statistical analysis involved linear mixed-effects models (LMMs) to account for the hierarchical structure of the data (multiple datasets from the same study) and to estimate effect sizes (log response ratios) for changes in diversity metrics.

Datasets

The study utilized 162 datasets compiled from various sources, including:

  • PREDICTS database: A global database of land-use effects on terrestrial biodiversity (focusing on birds and plants).
  • Global freshwater fish database: A compilation of fish species occurrences in drainage basins.
  • Other published studies and databases: Covering plants, birds, and fishes.

These datasets represent three broad data types: land use data (n=66), species list data (n=78), and resample data (n=18). The data spanned five continents and included over 32,000 plant species, 2,900 bird species, and 13,000 fish species. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing data were synthesized.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decoupling of α and β Diversity: Local diversity (α) and regional diversity (β) are not always changing in lockstep. This means that even if local species counts remain stable or increase, the overall composition of species across different regions can become more similar.
  • Phylogenetic vs. Taxonomic Diversity: Changes in species richness don't necessarily mirror changes in evolutionary diversity. Metrics independent of SR (like PSV) revealed declines in phylogenetic diversity even when SR increased, suggesting that new species might be evolutionarily similar to existing ones.
  • Global Homogenization: A consistent decrease in spatial β diversity across all taxonomic groups and data types provides strong evidence of global biotic homogenization. This means that different ecosystems are becoming more similar to each other in terms of their species composition.
  • Land Use Impacts: Land use change consistently led to declines in SR, Faith's PD, and PSV, underscoring its significant negative impact on biodiversity.
  • Importance of Multiple Metrics: Relying solely on species richness provides an incomplete picture. Incorporating phylogenetic diversity, especially metrics independent of SR, is crucial for a robust understanding of biodiversity change.

Key Results

  • α Diversity:
    • Local species richness (SR) and Faith's PD generally increased across taxonomic groups (e.g., fish SR increased by 10.62%).
  • However, phylogenetic α diversity measured by PSV (independent of SR) decreased for all taxonomic groups (e.g., birds by 2.08%).
  • Land use data consistently showed declines in SR, Faith's PD, and PSV.
  • β Diversity:
    • Spatial taxonomic and phylogenetic β diversity consistently decreased across all taxonomic groups and data types, indicating homogenization. For example, taxonomic β diversity for fishes decreased by 8.89%.
  • The exception was a marginal increase in taxonomic β diversity for land use data under a "landscape approach," likely due to the introduction of new habitat types.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Geographical Bias: The study acknowledges that the datasets are geographically biased, limiting the ability to estimate biodiversity changes in underrepresented regions.
  • Data Type Biases: Different data types (resample, species list, land use) have inherent biases that can affect trend interpretations. For instance, species list data might overestimate SR increases due to difficulties in confirming extinctions.
  • Multiple Drivers: Environmental changes often occur simultaneously and interact, making it challenging to isolate the impact of single drivers.

The authors emphasize the need for future research to:

  • Fill Geographical Gaps: Prioritize collecting biodiversity data from underrepresented regions.
  • Integrate Diverse Metrics: Continue to use a variety of taxonomic and phylogenetic metrics at different spatial scales to gain a comprehensive understanding.
  • Focus on Consequences: Investigate the ecological and evolutionary consequences of biotic homogenization, particularly its impact on ecosystem services.
  • Develop Policy: Inform conservation and environmental policy decisions by considering biodiversity beyond simple species counts.

Summary updated

Abstract

To better understand how ecosystems are changing, a multifaceted approach to measuring biodiversity that considers species richness (SR) and evolutionary history across spatial scales is needed. Here, we compiled 162 datasets for fish, bird and plant assemblages across the globe and measured how taxonomic and phylogenetic diversity changed at different spatial scales (within site <i>α</i> diversity and between sites spatial <i>β</i> diversity). Biodiversity change is measured from these datasets in three ways: across land use gradients, from species lists, and through sampling of the same locations across two time periods. We found that local SR and phylogenetic <i>α</i> diversity (Faith's PD (phylogenetic diversity)) increased for all taxonomic groups. However, when measured with a metric that is independent of SR (phylogenetic species variation, PSV), phylogenetic <i>α</i> diversity declined for all taxonomic groups. Land use datasets showed declines in SR, Faith's PD and PSV. For all taxonomic groups and data types, spatial taxonomic and phylogenetic <i>β</i> diversity decreased when measured with Sorensen dissimilarity and phylogenetic Sorensen dissimilarity, respectively, providing strong evidence of global biotic homogenization. The decoupling of <i>α</i> and <i>β</i> diversity, as well as taxonomic and phylogenetic diversity, highlights the need for a broader perspective on contemporary biodiversity changes. Conservation and environmental policy decisions thus need to consider biodiversity beyond local SR to protect biodiversity and ecosystem services.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2020changes,
  author = {Daijiang Li and Julian D. Olden and Julie L. Lockwood and Sydne Record and Michael L. McKinney and Benjamin Baiser},
  title = {{Changes in taxonomic and phylogenetic diversity in the Anthropocene}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1098/rspb.2020.0777},
}
Figure