Changes in productivity and carbon storage of grasslands in China under future global warming scenarios of 1.5°C and 2°C

Zhaoqi Wang, Jinfeng Chang, Shushi Peng, Shilong Piao, Philippe Ciais, Richard BettsJournal of Plant Ecology 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses a sophisticated ecosystem model to project how Chinese grasslands will respond to 1.5°C and 2°C of global warming. The findings suggest increased productivity and carbon storage under both warming scenarios, with alpine meadows showing a greater temperature increase and temperate grasslands potentially playing a larger role in future carbon sequestration.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global community is striving to limit global warming to 1.5°C or 2°C above pre-industrial levels, as outlined in the Paris Agreement. However, the specific impacts of these warming levels on crucial ecosystems like grasslands, particularly in large regions such as China, remain unclear. Chinese grasslands are vital for supporting millions of people and livestock, and they are highly sensitive to climate change. Understanding how these grasslands will respond in terms of productivity (how much carbon they absorb from the atmosphere) and carbon storage (how much carbon they retain in the soil and biomass) is critical for predicting future climate feedbacks and informing land management strategies. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by quantifying these impacts under the specified warming scenarios.

Methods

The researchers employed the ORCHIDEE (Organizing Carbon and Hydrology in Dynamic Ecosystems) model, a well-established process-based terrestrial ecosystem model. This model was used to simulate the carbon cycle of both alpine meadows and temperate grasslands across China. To drive the model, they utilized high-resolution (0.5° x 0.5°) climate data downscaled from the EC-EARTH3-HR v3.1 model. This climate data was based on global warming scenarios of 1.5°C and 2°C above pre-industrial levels, with sea surface temperature and sea-ice concentration boundary conditions provided by the IPSL-CM5-LR Earth System Model. The model was first run for a historical baseline period (1971-2005) to establish current conditions, and then for the future warming scenarios.

Datasets

  • Climate Data: High-resolution (0.5° x 0.5°) downscaled climate forcing from EC-EARTH3-HR v3.1, based on IPSL-CM5-LR Earth System Model projections for 1.5°C and 2°C global warming scenarios.
  • Observation-based GPP Products:
    • FLUXCOM GPP (gridded, 0.5° x 0.5°) derived from eddy flux towers using machine learning methods (Random Forests, ANN, MARS).
  • MODIS GPP product (MOD17C6, 8-day composite) from eddy flux tower calibrated models.
  • CMIP5 ESMs Data: Gross Primary Productivity (GPP) and Net Biome Productivity (NBP) data from four Coupled Model Inter-comparison Project Phase 5 (CMIP5) Earth System Models (GFDL-ESM2M, HadGEM2-ES, IPSL-CM5A-LR, NorESM1-ME) for historical (1971-2005) and future periods under RCP8.5.
  • Grasslands Map: 1:1,000,000 China vegetation map, reclassified into Alpine Meadows (AM) and Temperate Grasslands (TG).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Grasslands as Carbon Sinks: The study strongly suggests that Chinese grasslands will continue to act as carbon sinks under both 1.5°C and 2°C warming scenarios, absorbing more carbon than they release.
  • Differential Warming Impacts: Alpine meadows are projected to experience higher temperature increases than temperate grasslands, potentially leading to different responses in productivity and carbon storage.
  • Precipitation's Crucial Role: While warming is a key driver, increases in precipitation are identified as a significant factor enhancing GPP and carbon storage, particularly in certain regions.
  • Temperate Grasslands' Future Potential: Under the 2°C warming scenario, temperate grasslands (TG) show a particularly strong potential for increased carbon sequestration, potentially surpassing that of alpine meadows.
  • CO2 Fertilization and Warming Synergy: The combined effects of rising atmospheric CO2 concentrations and increased precipitation are expected to drive higher productivity and carbon storage.

Key Results

  • Temperature Increase: Mean annual air temperature over Chinese grasslands is projected to increase by 2.5°C under 1.5°C warming (SWL1.5) and 3.7°C under 2°C warming (SWL2) compared to the 1971-2005 baseline. Alpine meadows experience a greater temperature increase than temperate grasslands.
  • Precipitation Trends: Most Chinese grasslands are projected to see an increase in precipitation under SWL2, with significant increases in the southeastern Qinghai-Tibet Plateau.
  • Gross Primary Productivity (GPP): Mean annual GPP is projected to increase by 19.32% under SWL1.5 and 43.62% under SWL2.
  • Carbon Storage: Total carbon storage is estimated to increase by 0.64 Pg C under SWL1.5 and 1.37 Pg C under SWL2 over a 50-year simulation period.
  • Regional Differences: While overall GPP increases, some areas, particularly in northeastern China (dominated by TG), might experience a decrease in GPP under SWL1.5.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Uncertainties: The authors acknowledge uncertainties inherent in climate model projections and ecosystem model structures. Differences in GPP and NBP simulations between their model and CMIP5 ESMs highlight these uncertainties.
  • Fixed Grassland Area: The study assumes fixed grassland types and areas throughout the simulation. Future work could incorporate vegetation dynamics, land use changes, and grassland management practices, which could significantly influence carbon cycle outcomes.
  • Nitrogen Cycle Ignored: The model does not explicitly account for the coupled carbon-nitrogen cycle, which is known to strongly influence carbon fluxes, especially in nutrient-limited ecosystems. Future research could integrate C-N dynamics.
  • CO2 Fertilization Uncertainty: The exact magnitude of CO2 fertilization effects on vegetation growth remains a subject of uncertainty, and this could lead to overestimation of future carbon sinks, particularly in temperate grasslands under extreme weather conditions.
  • Integrated Assessments: The authors emphasize the need for further synthesized assessments that consider not only productivity but also the impacts of extreme climate events, livestock interactions, and other ecosystem-specific factors for sustainable grassland development.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Aims The impacts of future global warming of 1.5°C and 2°C on the productivity and carbon (C) storage of grasslands in China are not clear yet, although grasslands in China support ~45 million agricultural populations and more than 238 million livestock populations, and are sensitive to global warming. Methods This study used a process-based terrestrial ecosystem model named ORCHIDEE to simulate C cycle of alpine meadows and temperate grasslands in China. This model was driven by high-resolution (0.5° × 0.5°) climate of global specific warming levels (SWL) of 1.5°C and 2°C (warmer than pre-industrial level), which is downscaled by EC-EARTH3-HR v3.1 with sea surface temperature and sea-ice concentration as boundary conditions from IPSL-CM5-LR (low spatial resolution, 2.5° × 1.5°) Earth system model (ESM). Important Findings Compared with baseline (1971–2005), the mean annual air temperature over Chinese grasslands increased by 2.5°C and 3.7°C under SWL1.5 and SWL2, respectively. The increase in temperature in the alpine meadow was higher than that in the temperate grassland under both SWL1.5 and SWL2. Precipitation was also shown an increasing trend under SWL2 over most of the Chinese grasslands. Strong increases in gross primary productivity (GPP) were simulated in the Chinese grasslands, and the mean annual GPP (GPPMA) increased by 19.32% and 43.62% under SWL1.5 and SWL2, respectively. The C storage increased by 0.64 Pg C and 1.37 Pg C under SWL1.5 and SWL2 for 50 years simulations. The GPPMA was 0.670.390.88 (0.82) (model meanminmax (this study)), 0.850.451.24 (0.97) and 0.940.611.30 (1.17) Pg C year−1 under baseline, SWL1.5 and SWL2 modeled by four CMIP5 ESMs (phase 5 of the Coupled Model Inter-comparison Project Earth System Models). In contrast, the mean annual net biome productivity was −18.55−40.374.47 (−3.61),18.65−2.0364.03 (10.29) and 24.158.3838.77 (24.93) Tg C year−1 under baseline, SWL1.5 and SWL2 modeled by the four CMIP5 ESMs. Our results indicated that the Chinese grasslands would have higher productivity than the baseline and can mitigate climate change through increased C sequestration under future global warming of 1.5°C and 2°C with the increase of precipitation and the global increase of atmospheric CO2 concentration.
BibTeX
@article{wang2019changes,
  author = {Zhaoqi Wang and Jinfeng Chang and Shushi Peng and Shilong Piao and Philippe Ciais and Richard Betts},
  title = {{Changes in productivity and carbon storage of grasslands in China under future global warming scenarios of 1.5°C and 2°C}},
  journal = {Journal of Plant Ecology},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1093/jpe/rtz024},
}
Figure