Changes in microstates of first-episode untreated nonsuicidal self-injury adolescents exposed to negative emotional stimuli and after receiving rTMS intervention

Lin Zhao, Dongdong Zhou, Jinhui Hu, Xiaoqing He, Xinyu Peng, Lingli Ma, Xinyi Liu, Wanqing Tao, Ran Chen, Zhenghao Jiang, Chen‐Yu Zhang, Jing Liao, Jiao-Jiao Xiang, Zeng Qi, Linxi Dai, Qi Zhang, Su Hong, Wo Wang, Li KuangFrontiers in Psychiatry 2023 · DOI

Abstract: MDD adolescents with NSSI showed abnormal changes in several microstate parameters when receiving negative emotional stimuli, and compared to those not receiving rTMS treatment, MDD adolescents with NSSI treated with rTMS showed more significant improvements in depressive symptoms and NSSI performance, as well as improvements in EEG microstate abnormalities.

Introduction

Non-suicidal self-injury (NSSI) is a critical public health concern, particularly among adolescents, where it serves as a significant predictor for future suicide attempts. While NSSI is frequently associated with Major Depressive Disorder (MDD), the real-time neurobiological mechanisms—specifically how the brain transitions between functional states in milliseconds—remain poorly understood. This study utilizes EEG microstate analysis to identify potential biomarkers for NSSI and evaluates the efficacy of repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (rTMS) in modulating these brain dynamics.

Methodology

The study involved 138 participants aged 12–17, categorized into three groups: MDD with NSSI (n=66), MDD-only (n=52), and healthy controls (n=20). The experimental design included a cross-sectional comparison and a longitudinal treatment phase.

The Negative Emotional Stimuli Task

Participants were exposed to facial images from the Chinese Facial Affective Picture System (CFAPS), comparing neutral and negative emotional triggers while 64-channel EEG data was recorded. The task was designed to trigger the emotional dysregulation often seen in NSSI populations.

rTMS Intervention

The MDD+NSSI group was divided into two treatment arms for eight weeks: a medication-only group (SSRIs) and a combined medication plus rTMS group. The rTMS protocol involved 10Hz stimulation targeting the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC), a region critical for executive control and emotional regulation.

Experimental procedure and rTMS stimulation protocol

Results

NSSI-Specific Microstate Signatures

Microstate analysis revealed that adolescents with NSSI exhibit distinct abnormalities in Microstates (MS) 3, 4, and 6, particularly when processing negative emotions. These participants showed increased duration and coverage of MS 3, suggesting a "stuck" state during specific phases of emotional processing. These abnormalities were significantly more pronounced during exposure to negative stimuli compared to neutral ones, reinforcing the theory that NSSI is a maladaptive response to acute emotional distress.

ERP waveforms across different groups and emotional stimuli conditions

Clinical and Neurophysiological Impact of rTMS

The combination of rTMS and medication led to superior clinical outcomes compared to medication alone. Following the 8-week intervention, scores on the Hamilton Depression Scale (8.38 vs. 12.94) and the Ottawa Self-Injury Scale (0.24 vs. 0.87) were significantly lower in the rTMS group.

Beyond clinical scores, rTMS uniquely modulated the spatiotemporal dynamics of the brain. While both treatments influenced MS 3 and 6, only the rTMS group showed significant changes in MS 1, 2, and 4. Specifically, rTMS decreased MS 1 duration and MS 4 coverage while increasing MS 2 duration and coverage. This suggests that rTMS acts as a "spatiotemporal harmonizer," modulating specific neural circuits related to cognitive executive processes and early attention that medication alone does not reach.

Discussion and Limitations

The findings suggest that microstate analysis can provide objective biomarkers for NSSI and that rTMS is an effective adjunct therapy for rebalancing brain dynamics. However, the study notes limitations, including a relatively small longitudinal sample size due to external disruptions and the need for more precise targeting using fMRI-guided neuronavigation in future research. Furthermore, while microstate changes were evident, the lack of a direct linear correlation with clinical score improvements suggests a complex relationship between brain dynamics and behavioral outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

MDD adolescents with NSSI showed abnormal changes in several microstate parameters when receiving negative emotional stimuli, and compared to those not receiving rTMS treatment, MDD adolescents with NSSI treated with rTMS showed more significant improvements in depressive symptoms and NSSI performance, as well as improvements in EEG microstate abnormalities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2023changes,
  author = {Lin Zhao and Dongdong Zhou and Jinhui Hu and Xiaoqing He and Xinyu Peng and Lingli Ma and Xinyi Liu and Wanqing Tao and Ran Chen and Zhenghao Jiang and Chen‐Yu Zhang and Jing Liao and Jiao-Jiao Xiang and Zeng Qi and Linxi Dai and Qi Zhang and Su Hong and Wo Wang and Li Kuang},
  title = {{Changes in microstates of first-episode untreated nonsuicidal self-injury adolescents exposed to negative emotional stimuli and after receiving rTMS intervention}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychiatry},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyt.2023.1151114},
}
Figure