Changes in hip Joint Contact Stress During a Gait Cycle based on the Individualized Modeling Framework of"Gait-Musculoskeletal System-Finite Element"

Bing-Lang Xiong, Peng Yang, Tianye Lin, Jinli Xu, Yong Ping Xie, Yongliang Guo, Churong Liu, Qi-Zhao Zhou, Qizhong Lai, Qiushi Wei, Wei He, Qingwen ZhangResearch Square 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Objective: To construct a comprehensive simulation framework of "gait-musculoskeletal system(MS)-finite element(FE)" for analysis of hip joint dynamics characteristics and the changes in the contact stress in the hip throughout a gait cycle. Methods: Two healthy volunteers (male and female) were recruited. The 3D gait trajectories during normal walking and the CT images including the hip and femur of the volunteers were obtained. CT Imaging data in the DICOM were extracted for subjected 3D hip joint reconstruction. The reconstructed 3D model files were used to realize the subject-specific registration of the pelvis and thigh segment of general musculoskeletal model. The captured marker trajectory data were used to drive subject-specific musculoskeletal model to complete inverse dynamic analysis. Results of inverse dynamic analysis were exported and applied as boundary and load settings of the hip joint finite element in ABAQUS. Finally, the finite element analysis(FEA) was performed to analyze contact stress of hip joint during a gait cycle of left foot. Results: In the inverse dynamic analysis, the dynamic changes of the main hip-femoral muscle force with respect to each phase of a single gait cycle were plotted. The hip joint reaction force reached a maximum value of 2.9 BW (Body weight) and appeared at the end of the terminal stance phase. Twin peaks appeared at the initial contact phase and the end of the terminal stance phase respectively. FEA showed the temporal changes in contact stress in the acetabulum. In the visual stress cloud chart, the acetabular contact stress was mainly distributed in the dome of the acetabulum and in the anterolateral area at the top of the femoral head during a single gait cycle. The acetabular contact area was 293.8-998.4 mm² and the maximum contact area appear at the mid-stance phase or the loading response phase of gait. The maximum contact stress of the acetabulum reached 6.91 Mpa (Model 1) / 6.92 Mpa (Model 2) at the terminal stance phase. Conclusions: The "Gait-MS-FE" technology is integrated to construct a comprehensive simulation framework. Based on human gait trajectories and their CT images, individualized simulation modeling can be achieved. Subject-specific gait in combination with an inverse dynamic analysis of the MS provides pre-processing parameters for FE simulation for more accurate biomechanical analysis of hip joint.

Introduction

The hip joint is a critical biomechanical structure, yet it remains a primary site for debilitating conditions such as osteoarthritis and femoral head necrosis. Understanding the precise mechanical environment of the joint—specifically how stress is distributed during movement—is essential for diagnosing and treating these diseases. Historically, biomechanical models have often relied on simplified static "one-foot standing" assumptions or "Frankenstein" models that combine muscle forces from one individual with the bone geometry of another. This study introduces an individualized "Gait-Musculoskeletal System-Finite Element" (Gait-MS-FE) framework designed to track dynamic stress through every phase of a complete gait cycle.

Methods

The researchers developed a multi-stage pipeline to create subject-specific simulations for two healthy volunteers: a 32-year-old male (70 kg) and a 27-year-old female (51 kg).

  1. Data Acquisition: 3D gait trajectories were captured using an optical motion capture system alongside ground reaction forces from force platforms. High-resolution CT images provided the anatomical basis for 3D bone reconstruction.
  2. Musculoskeletal (MS) Modeling: Using the AnyBody Modeling System, the team performed an inverse dynamic analysis to calculate specific muscle forces and joint reaction forces generated during walking.
  3. Finite Element Analysis (FEA): These forces were imported into ABAQUS to analyze 8 distinct phases of the gait cycle. The cartilage was modeled as a constant 1.8mm layer, and bones were treated as homogeneous, isotropic materials.
Table 1: Material properties and mesh details for the finite element models.

Results

The study revealed that hip joint stress is highly dynamic, characterized by a "twin peak" phenomenon in reaction forces. The first peak occurs during the initial contact phase, while a larger second peak—reaching approximately 2.9 times body weight—occurs at the end of the terminal stance phase.

Table 2: Hip joint reaction forces, peak contact pressure, and contact area across eight phases of the gait cycle.

Key findings include:

  • Peak Stress: The maximum contact stress on the acetabulum reached 6.91 MPa for the male model and 6.92 MPa for the female model during the terminal stance phase.
  • Contact Area: The contact area fluctuated significantly, ranging from 293.8 to 998.4 mm² throughout the cycle.
  • Stress Migration: Contact stress migrated from the anterior column to the posterior column of the acetabulum as the stride progressed. The highest stress concentrations were consistently observed in the acetabular dome and the anterolateral area of the femoral head.

Discussion and Conclusion

The Gait-MS-FE framework demonstrates that using subject-specific gait and anatomy eliminates the "noise" of individual differences, providing a more accurate biomechanical profile. The identification of specific "warning zones" in the acetabulum provides clinicians with targeted areas for monitoring early joint wear or potential collapse. Future work should incorporate varying bone densities and explore how different walking speeds affect stress distribution to further refine this clinical tool.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> <bold>Objective: </bold>To construct a comprehensive simulation framework of "gait-musculoskeletal system(MS)-finite element(FE)" for analysis of hip joint dynamics characteristics and the changes in the contact stress in the hip throughout a gait cycle.<bold>Methods:</bold>Two healthy volunteers (male and female) were recruited. The 3D gait trajectories during normal walking and the CT images including the hip and femur of the volunteers were obtained. CT Imaging data in the DICOM were extracted for subjected 3D hip joint reconstruction. The reconstructed 3D model files were used to realize the subject-specific registration of the pelvis and thigh segment of general musculoskeletal model. The captured marker trajectory data were used to drive subject-specific musculoskeletal model to complete inverse dynamic analysis. Results of inverse dynamic analysis were exported and appliedas boundary and load settings of the hip joint finite element in ABAQUS. Finally, the finite element analysis(FEA) was performed to analyze contact stress of hip joint during a gait cycle of left foot.<bold>Results: </bold>In the inverse dynamic analysis, the dynamic changes of the main hip-femoral muscle force with respect to each phase of a single gait cycle were plotted. The hip joint reaction force reached a maximum value of 2.9%BW(Body weight)and appeared at the end of the terminal stance phase. Twin peaks appeared at the initial contact phase and the end of the terminal stance phase respectively. FEA showed the temporal changes in contact stress in the acetabulum. In the visual stress cloud chart, the acetabular contact stress was mainly distributed in the dome of the acetabulum and in the anterolateral area at the top of the femoral head during a single gait cycle. The acetabular contact area was 293.8-998.4 mm<sup>2</sup> and the maximum contact area appear at the mid-stance phase or the loading response phase of gait. The maximum contact stress of the acetabulum reached 6.91 Mpa (Model 1) / 6.92 Mpa(Model 2) at the terminal stance phase. <bold>Conclusions:</bold>The "Gait-MS-FE" technology is integrated to construct a comprehensive simulation framework. Based on human gait trajectories and their CT images, individualized simulation modeling can be achieved. Subject-specific gait in combination with an inverse dynamic analysis of the MS provides pre-processing parameters for FE simulation for more accurate biomechanical analysis of hip joint.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xiong2021changes,
  author = {Bing-Lang Xiong and Peng Yang and Tianye Lin and Jinli Xu and Yong Ping Xie and Yongliang Guo and Churong Liu and Qi-Zhao Zhou and Qizhong Lai and Qiushi Wei and Wei He and Qingwen Zhang},
  title = {{Changes in hip Joint Contact Stress During a Gait Cycle based on the Individualized Modeling Framework of"Gait-Musculoskeletal System-Finite Element"}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-983381/v1},
}
Figure