Challenges in simulating beam dynamics of dielectric laser acceleration

Uwe Niedermayer, Andreas Adelmann, S. Bettoni, Marco Calvi, M. Dehler, Enrico Ferrari, F. Frei, Dominique Hauenstein, Benedikt Hermann, Nicole Hiller, R. Ischebeck, Csaba Lombosi, Eduard Prat, S. Reiche, Leonid Rivkin, R. Aßmann, Ulrich Dorda, Ingmar Hartl, Willi Kuropka, François Lémery, Barbara Marchetti, Frank Mayet, Hongwen Xuan, Jun Zhu, Dylan S. Black, Payton Broaddus, Robert L. Byer, Andrew Ceballos, Huiyang Deng, Shanhui Fan, J. S. Harris, Tomohiko Hirano, Tyler W. Hughes, Yuming Jiang, T. Langenstein, Kenneth J. Leedle, Yu Miao, Alexander Ody, A. Pigott, Neil V. Sapra, Olav Solgaard, Logan Su, Si Tan, Jelena Vučković, Ki Youl Yang, Zhexin Zhao, Oliver Boine‐Frankenheim, Thilo Egenolf, Eric Skär, David Cesar, P. Musumeci, Brian Naranjo, J. B. Rosenzweig, Xinglai Shen, B. Cowan, R. J. England, Zhirong Huang, Hüseyin Çankaya, Moein Fakhari, Arya Fallahi, Franz X. Kärtner, T. Feurer, Peter Hommelhoff, Johannes Illmer, A. Li, Anna Mittelbach, J. McNeur, Norbert Schönenberger, Roy Shiloh, Alexander Tafel, Peyman Yousefi, Martin Kozák, Minghao Qi, Y. J. Lee, Yen-Chieh Huang, Evgenya SimakovInternational Journal of Modern Physics A 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the simulation challenges for Dielectric Laser Acceleration (DLA), a promising technology for compact, high-gradient accelerators. The authors detail their DLAtrack6D code, a simplified yet effective tool for simulating beam dynamics, and discuss the development of laser-based focusing techniques crucial for DLA's scalability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dielectric Laser Acceleration (DLA) offers a revolutionary path to significantly smaller and more powerful particle accelerators by leveraging dielectric materials to achieve much higher accelerating gradients than traditional metallic structures. The "Accelerator on a Chip International Program" (ACHIP) aims to realize this potential by building a silicon-chip-based accelerator capable of boosting electrons from keV to MeV energies with gradients exceeding 100 MeV/m. However, the intense accelerating fields in DLA also lead to strong defocusing forces that cannot be managed by conventional magnetic focusing. This necessitates novel, laser-based focusing schemes. Furthermore, simulating the complex beam dynamics within these structures, especially for optimization and design, is computationally demanding. This paper addresses these challenges by presenting a specialized simulation code and discussing the development and implementation of advanced focusing techniques.

Methods

The core of the paper revolves around the DLAtrack6D code, a simplified symplectic tracking code designed for DLA simulations. It operates on a "one kick per cell" principle, where the interaction of the electron beam with the laser field within each DLA cell is approximated by a single impulse. This impulse is derived from the Fourier coefficients of the synchronous spatial harmonic of the laser field. The code accounts for both longitudinal energy gain and transverse kicks, crucial for understanding beam behavior.

To overcome the limitations of magnet-only focusing, the authors discuss two key laser-based focusing techniques:

  • Spatial Harmonic Focusing: This method utilizes specific spatial harmonics of the laser field to provide focusing forces.
  • Alternating Phase Focusing (APF): This more recent technique manipulates the phase of a single spatial harmonic to create alternating focusing and defocusing gradients, which, when integrated over the structure, result in stable beam confinement. APF is particularly well-suited for sub-relativistic DLAs using high refractive index silicon structures.

The paper also touches upon field computation for single DLA cells using various numerical methods like Finite Difference/Finite Integration Time Domain (FD/FI TD), Finite Difference Frequency Domain (FDFD), and Finite Element Frequency Domain (FEFD) codes. For full-scale simulations, they mention using commercial codes like CST Studio Suite and VSim, particularly for Particle-In-Cell (PIC) simulations when high fidelity is required.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on simulation methodologies and theoretical development rather than experimental data analysis or training on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • DLAtrack6D as a powerful optimization tool: The simplified "one kick per cell" approach in DLAtrack6D offers a computationally efficient way to simulate beam dynamics, making it practical for optimizing DLA structures, a task that would be prohibitively expensive with full PIC simulations.
  • Necessity of laser-based focusing: The paper strongly emphasizes that conventional magnetic focusing is insufficient for DLA due to the small scale and high gradients involved. Laser-based focusing techniques are essential for achieving stable and scalable DLA systems.
  • APF's promise for sub-relativistic DLAs: Alternating Phase Focusing (APF) is highlighted as a particularly promising technique for sub-relativistic electron beams, offering stable confinement and efficient conversion of laser energy into acceleration.
  • Trade-offs in DLA design: The paper implicitly points out the inherent trade-offs in DLA design, such as the balance between material damage threshold, refractive index, and achievable gradient, as well as the complexity of optimizing field flatness and minimizing fringe fields.
  • Wake field effects are a future concern: The authors acknowledge that wake field effects, particularly for short bunches, are an important consideration for longer DLA structures and are being integrated into their simulation efforts.

Key Results

  • The paper presents the theoretical framework and implementation of the DLAtrack6D code for simulating beam dynamics in DLA structures.
  • It details the development and theoretical basis of Alternating Phase Focusing (APF) as a viable laser-based focusing scheme for DLA.
  • The authors discuss the use of spatial harmonic focusing as another approach to manage beam dynamics.
  • They outline the computational approaches for field computation in single DLA cells and the use of full-scale PIC simulations for higher fidelity.
  • The paper references ongoing and recently completed experiments demonstrating acceleration with various DLA structures, including dual pillar and Bragg reflectors, and the first focusing experiments utilizing intrinsic phase-dependent properties.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations of DLAtrack6D: While efficient, DLAtrack6D is a simplified model. It does not include fringe fields, and its accuracy relies on the assumption of strict periodicity, though small deviations are tolerated. The treatment of wake field effects is outlined but still under development.
  • Computational demands for full-scale simulations: Full 3D PIC simulations for larger DLA chips require significant cluster computing resources, which can be a bottleneck for design and optimization.
  • Future Work:
    • Integrating linear and nonlinear wake kicks into DLAtrack6D to predict beam loading effects and instabilities in longer structures.
  • Conducting high-performance PIC simulations to assess fringe fields, imperfect field flatness, wake fields, and radiation emission.
  • Performing experiments to test APF structures and explore their capabilities for bunching and acceleration.
  • Investigating the use of moving window codes for more efficient large-scale PIC simulations.
  • Exploring high-energy DLA experiments at facilities like SwissFEL and SINBAD.

Summary updated

Abstract

Dielectric Laser Acceleration (DLA) achieves the highest gradients among structure-based electron accelerators. The use of dielectrics increases the breakdown field limit, and thus the achievable gradient, by a factor of at least 10 in comparison to metals. Experimental demonstrations of DLA in 2013 led to the Accelerator on a Chip International Program (ACHIP), funded by the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation. In ACHIP, our main goal is to build an accelerator on a silicon chip, which can accelerate electrons from below 100 keV to above 1 MeV with a gradient of at least 100 MeV/m. For stable acceleration on the chip, magnet-only focusing techniques are insufficient to compensate the strong acceleration defocusing. Thus, spatial harmonic and Alternating Phase Focusing (APF) laser-based focusing techniques have been developed. We have also developed the simplified symplectic tracking code DLAtrack6D, which makes use of the periodicity and applies only one kick per DLA cell, which is calculated by the Fourier coefficient of the synchronous spatial harmonic. Due to coupling, the Fourier coefficients of neighboring cells are not entirely independent and a field flatness optimization (similarly as in multi-cell cavities) needs to be performed. The simulation of the entire accelerator on a chip by a Particle In Cell (PIC) code is possible, but impractical for optimization purposes. Finally, we have also outlined the treatment of wake field effects in attosecond bunches in the grating within DLAtrack6D, where the wake function is computed by an external solver.
BibTeX
@article{niedermayer2019challenges,
  author = {Uwe Niedermayer and Andreas Adelmann and S. Bettoni and Marco Calvi and M. Dehler and Enrico Ferrari and F. Frei and Dominique Hauenstein and Benedikt Hermann and Nicole Hiller and R. Ischebeck and Csaba Lombosi and Eduard Prat and S. Reiche and Leonid Rivkin and R. Aßmann and Ulrich Dorda and Ingmar Hartl and Willi Kuropka and François Lémery and Barbara Marchetti and Frank Mayet and Hongwen Xuan and Jun Zhu and Dylan S. Black and Payton Broaddus and Robert L. Byer and Andrew Ceballos and Huiyang Deng and Shanhui Fan and J. S. Harris and Tomohiko Hirano and Tyler W. Hughes and Yuming Jiang and T. Langenstein and Kenneth J. Leedle and Yu Miao and Alexander Ody and A. Pigott and Neil V. Sapra and Olav Solgaard and Logan Su and Si Tan and Jelena Vučković and Ki Youl Yang and Zhexin Zhao and Oliver Boine‐Frankenheim and Thilo Egenolf and Eric Skär and David Cesar and P. Musumeci and Brian Naranjo and J. B. Rosenzweig and Xinglai Shen and B. Cowan and R. J. England and Zhirong Huang and Hüseyin Çankaya and Moein Fakhari and Arya Fallahi and Franz X. Kärtner and T. Feurer and Peter Hommelhoff and Johannes Illmer and A. Li and Anna Mittelbach and J. McNeur and Norbert Schönenberger and Roy Shiloh and Alexander Tafel and Peyman Yousefi and Martin Kozák and Minghao Qi and Y. J. Lee and Yen-Chieh Huang and Evgenya Simakov},
  title = {{Challenges in simulating beam dynamics of dielectric laser acceleration}},
  journal = {International Journal of Modern Physics A},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1142/s0217751x19420314},
}
Figure