Challenges and Opportunities to Address Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion within the Professional Construction Industry

Andrés Nieto Leal, Homero Murzi, Abiola Akanmu, Anthony Yusuf, Sheryl Ball, Walid Saad, Andrea Ofori‐Boadu2024 · DOI

TL;DR

While many construction firms have adopted Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) statements, their impact is unevenly felt across the industry. This study reveals a significant "awareness gap" between large and small firms and highlights a critical disconnect: while practitioners associate DEI with workforce representation, they often fail to link it to diversity in top-level management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The U.S. construction industry is facing a dual crisis: a massive labor shortage and an aging workforce. Despite these pressures, the field remains one of the least diverse in the country, historically dominated by White/Caucasian men. While corporate DEI statements have become standard, the authors argue that "saying it" isn't the same as "doing it."

The paper investigates the gap between corporate rhetoric and employee perception. It seeks to understand how professionals actually recognize and define DEI within their specific work environments—whether they are on a massive infrastructure project or in a small design boutique. By identifying where DEI awareness fails, the authors aim to provide a roadmap for both industry leaders and educators to foster a more inclusive professional culture.

Methods

The researchers employed a mixed-methods approach to capture both broad trends and nuanced perspectives:

  • Nationwide Survey: Conducted in Spring 2023, the survey collected quantitative data on DEI awareness, company demographics, and personal definitions of DEI.
  • Focus Groups: The authors held discussions with both industry practitioners and faculty instructors to contextualize the survey findings.
  • Analysis: Quantitative data was processed using descriptive statistics, while qualitative focus group data was analyzed using memoing and coding strategies to identify recurring themes.

This study is part of a larger project called ConPEC (Connecting the Professional and Educational Communities of Practice), which aims to bridge the communication gap between the classroom and the construction site.

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of responses from 249 industry practitioners representing 26 U.S. states.

  • Demographics: Reflecting the industry's current state, the sample was 75% male and 81% White/Caucasian.
  • Company Profiles: The data covers a spectrum of firm sizes (46% large, 30% medium, 24% small) and types (67% building/heavy construction, 17% special trade, 10% design, and 6% transportation).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Size Matters" Awareness Gap: There is a stark divide in DEI socialization based on company size. 85% of employees at large firms (500+ employees) were aware of their company’s DEI statements, compared to a dismal 42% at small firms. This suggests that smaller companies lack the resources or the perceived "need" to formalize inclusive cultures.
  • The Management Blind Spot: Perhaps the most surprising finding was that while ~80% of participants linked DEI to workforce representation, only about 50% associated it with representation at the top management level. This indicates a "glass ceiling" mentality where diversity is seen as a "boots on the ground" initiative rather than a leadership requirement.
  • The "Heavy Duty" Excuse: Focus groups revealed that construction-related firms often excuse a lack of gender diversity by citing the "heavy-duty" nature of the work or long hours, a narrative that continues to marginalize women who aspire to these roles.
  • Design Firms as Leaders: Design-focused firms showed the highest DEI ratings (69% rated their DEI as "high" or "very high"). The authors attribute this to the higher prevalence of advanced degrees (Masters/PhDs) in these firms, which often correlates with earlier and more frequent exposure to DEI concepts in academia.

Key Results

  • Awareness by Industry Type: Design firms led with 85% awareness of DEI statements, while Transportation and Highway construction firms lagged at 53%.
  • Racial Disparities in Awareness: While over 80% of Black and Asian practitioners were aware of their company's DEI statements, only 55% of Hispanic or Latinx practitioners reported the same.
  • DEI Definitions: The most recognized "labels" for DEI were "Proper representation of females in the workforce" (85% for women, 78% for men) and "Proper representation of minoritized populations in the workforce" (84% for women, 78% for men).
  • The Disconnect: Only 48% of participants (both men and women) associated "Proper representation of minoritized populations at top management level" with the definition of DEI.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a significant limitation: because the industry itself lacks diversity, the study’s sample of underrepresented minorities was small (only 15% of the total sample). This makes it difficult to generalize the specific experiences of these groups. Additionally, the data was heavily skewed toward the state of Virginia.

Future Work: The team plans to leverage the ConPEC web platform to facilitate a "diversity exchange" between academia and industry. A major recommendation is to move DEI training in engineering schools away from one-off workshops and instead integrate it directly into the core curriculum, ensuring that the next generation of engineers enters the workforce with a "DEI-first" mindset.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The construction industry has been a predominantly White/Caucasian Men community with a very low representation of women and people from traditionally marginalized backgrounds. Even though companies have been implementing Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) statements for many years, we still believe it is neither a diverse nor equitable field. To better understand how DEI statements declared by companies have been understood and recognized by employees, a survey was deployed nationwide to understand how professionals in the construction industry perceive their organization's DEI statements or policies. A complete data set was built from 249 participants. 75% identified themselves as men and 25% as women, and nobody identified with other gender identities. More than 80% of participants were White/Caucasian, 4% Black or African American, 4% Hispanic or Latinx, and 6% Asian. Participants are currently working in small (24%), medium (30%), and large (46%) construction and design companies located across The United States. Regarding the number of employees, companies are small, less than 99 employees; medium, between 100 and 499 employees; and large, more than 500 employees. Also, companies were grouped into four main types, building construction companies (67%), transportation construction companies (6%), special trade contractor companies (17%), and design companies (10%). For more than 65% of professionals in the construction industry who participated in this study, DEI was mainly related to proper representation of women and minoritized populations in the workforce; Merit-based transparent recruitment and promotion; equality, social justice, and nondiscrimination policy statement; and equitable payment and compensation. Other factors such as proper representation of women and minoritized populations at the top management level and payment structure transparency did not emerge from the results. We also found that 70% of professionals identified DEI statements in their companies and 30% of professionals did not identify or did not know about DEI statements. Looking at the company size, 85% of professionals in large companies identified DEI statements in their companies, but 71% and 42% of professionals in medium and small companies identified DEI statements in their companies, respectively. According to the company type, more than 80% of professionals working in design companies recognized DEI statements in their companies, but around 60% in construction and special trade companies. We can highlight that large companies have established policies and practices that result in better socialization and recognition of their DEI statements than medium and small companies. Also, construction and special trade companies need to strengthen their DEI statements and increase the representation of women and people from traditionally marginalized backgrounds. Results from this research give an idea about the current state of DEI in the construction industry and would contribute to the current effort to increase the diversity of the nation's construction workforce.
BibTeX
@misc{leal2024challenges,
  author = {Andrés Nieto Leal and Homero Murzi and Abiola Akanmu and Anthony Yusuf and Sheryl Ball and Walid Saad and Andrea Ofori‐Boadu},
  title = {{Challenges and Opportunities to Address Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion within the Professional Construction Industry}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.18260/1-2--45436},
}
Figure