Centralized Radio Resource Management for 5G small cells as LSA enabler

Oscar Carrasco, Federico Miatton, Salvador Díaz, Uwe Herzog, Valerio Frascolla, Michael Fitch, Keith Briggs, Benoit Miscopein, Antonio De Domenico, Andreas GeorgakopoulosarXiv 2017 · arXiv

Abstract

This paper proposes a centralized Radio Resource Management (cRRM) architecture situated in the "Edge Cloud" to enable dynamic spectrum sharing for 5G small cells. By moving the network's control logic to the edge, the authors demonstrate how Licensed Shared Access (LSA) can be transformed from a static regulatory framework into a real-time, high-performance tool for managing dense, multi-operator environments. The proposed SPEED-5G framework addresses the "spectrum crunch" by enabling ultra-densification through efficient, low-latency coordination of shared spectrum resources.

Introduction: The Spectrum Crunch and LSA

The primary hurdle for 5G deployment is the "spectrum crunch." To meet the massive demand for bandwidth and low latency, networks are moving toward ultra-densification—deploying a high volume of small cells. However, this approach faces two major challenges: spectrum scarcity and management complexity. Traditional Licensed Shared Access (LSA) is often static, with spectrum shared over long periods and large geographic areas. In a dense 5G environment, spectrum availability changes rapidly, making interference management and Quality of Service (QoS) across multiple operators a significant coordination challenge that distributed architectures struggle to solve.

The Licensed Shared Access (LSA) framework architecture showing the interaction between incumbents, regulators, and mobile terminals.

The SPEED-5G Architecture and Methods

The authors present the vision of the SPEED-5G project, which introduces a three-dimensional model called extended Dynamic Spectrum Allocation (eDSA). This model jointly manages spectrum bands, cells, and technologies. The core innovation is the Centralized Radio Resource Management (cRRM) entity, which is deployed within an Edge Cloud rather than a distant central office. This proximity allows for decision-making at the Transmission Time Interval (TTI) level—the smallest unit of time in cellular scheduling.

The SPEED-5G Edge Cloud Architecture featuring the centralized RRM (cRRM) and its connection to 5G Small Cells and Core Networks.

Key technical features of this architecture include:

  • Multi-Operator Core Network (MOCN): A RAN sharing scheme where multiple operators share the same physical small cell hardware to reduce costs.
  • Layer-2 Cell Control Interface: Utilizing efficient ASN.1 coding for ultra-low latency signaling, replacing slower XML-based interfaces like TR-069.
  • Functional Split: The architecture separates the control plane (handled by the cRRM) from the user plane, allowing radio resources to be treated as a virtualized pool, similar to Cloud-RAN operations.

The framework builds upon the Finnish LSA Field Trials as a real-world baseline and utilizes SPEED-5G project deliverables (such as D5.1) to justify architectural choices through technical specifications and simulations.

Key Insights

  • "Use it or Share it": The paper advocates for a shift from the traditional "use it or lose it" regulatory mindset to a "use it or share it" model. This allows incumbents (e.g., military or satellite providers) to safely permit mobile operators to use idle spectrum.
  • The Space Dimension: Centralized RRM can integrate geographic location into spectrum decisions. For instance, 2.6GHz bands used by maritime radar can be automatically unlocked for inland small cells by the cRRM.
  • TTI-Level Coordination: Centralizing the RRM at the edge enables interference coordination and resource allocation every millisecond, a feat impossible in fully distributed systems where cells cannot communicate fast enough.
  • Neutral Host Management: The cRRM can act as a "Neutral Host," ensuring that different operators sharing infrastructure receive their fair share of LSA spectrum based on agreed-upon Service Level Agreements (SLAs).

Results and Validation

The SPEED-5G architecture provides several qualitative benefits:

  • Latency Reduction: Moving the cRRM to the edge gateway allows the system to respond dynamically to rapid environmental changes.
  • Predictable QoS: The architecture bridges the gap between the LSA Repository (which tracks spectrum availability) and the Small Cells, ensuring "exclusive-like" access for licensees.
  • Spectral Efficiency: Techniques like Cooperative Multi-Point (CoMP) and virtual multi-cell MIMO, enabled by the cRRM, maximize the capacity extracted from available bands.

Limitations and Future Work

Despite its potential, several hurdles remain. Current management interfaces like TR-069 are too slow for 5G, necessitating new standardized, low-latency interfaces. Additionally, while "Spectrum Sensing Networks" are mentioned, the specific algorithms required to detect incumbent users in real-time without interference remain a complex research area. Finally, global LSA implementation requires National Regulator Authorities to adopt these dynamic sharing models, representing a significant political and regulatory challenge. Future research will focus on advanced LSA coordination procedures and refined sensing strategies to integrate LSA into the 5G standardization path.

Summary updated

Abstract

The stringent requirements defined for 5G systems drive the need to promote new paradigms to the existing cellular networks. Dense and ultra-dense networks based on small cells, together with new spectrum sharing schemes seem to be key enabling technologies for emerging 5G mobile networks. This article explores the vision of the SPEED-5G project, analyzing the ability of a Centralized Radio Resource Management entity to support the Licensed Shared Access spectrum sharing framework in a deployment based on Network Slicing and Network Sharing paradigms.
BibTeX
@misc{carrasco2017centralized,
  author = {Oscar Carrasco and Federico Miatton and Salvador Díaz and Uwe Herzog and Valerio Frascolla and Michael Fitch and Keith Briggs and Benoit Miscopein and Antonio De Domenico and Andreas Georgakopoulos},
  title = {{Centralized Radio Resource Management for 5G small cells as LSA enabler}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1706.08057},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1706.08057},
}
Figure