Centralized and decentralized isolation strategies and their impact on the COVID-19 pandemic dynamics

Alexandru Topirceanu, Mihai Udrescu, Radu MarculescuarXiv 2020 · arXiv

Abstract

The COVID-19 pandemic necessitated rapid implementation of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs), primarily social distancing. Traditional compartmental models often overlook the nuances of individual awareness and network structure. This study introduces the SICARS model, which differentiates between contagious and aware infectious states within a network-centric framework. By simulating centralized (government-mandated) and decentralized (individual-led) isolation strategies, the research identifies that a hybrid approach is superior in mitigating outbreaks and neutralizing high-degree "superspreader" nodes.

Introduction

Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, social distancing was the primary tool for slowing viral transmission. However, standard epidemiological models like SEIR treat populations as homogeneous blocks, failing to account for the complex web of social ties or the behavioral shifts that occur when individuals realize they are sick. This paper addresses this gap by examining how the structure of isolation—whether imposed globally by a central authority or adopted locally by aware individuals—affects pandemic dynamics.

Methodology: The SICARS Model

The authors developed the SICARS model (Susceptible - Incubating - Contagious - Aware - Removed | Susceptible) to better capture the realities of infection and behavior. A key innovation is the bifurcation of the infectious period into two distinct states:

  1. Contagious: The individual is infectious but asymptomatic or unaware.
  2. Aware: The individual is infectious and has become aware of their status, enabling behavioral change.
The SICARS model transitions, highlighting the distinction between the Contagious and Aware states within the infectious period.

Unlike compartmental models, SICARS is network-centric, representing social distancing as the removal of edges (social ties) within a graph. This allows for the simulation of targeted isolation strategies rather than simple population reduction.

Isolation Strategies

The study evaluates three primary isolation frameworks:

  • Centralized (C): A top-down, synchronous removal of a fixed percentage of social ties across the entire network, mimicking a government-mandated lockdown.
  • Decentralized (D): Asynchronous isolation driven by individual awareness. This includes Aware-Isolation (DA), where the infected individual cuts ties, and Auto-Isolation (DI), where healthy neighbors proactively avoid known sick individuals.
  • Hybrid (C+D): A combination of both top-down mandates and bottom-up individual awareness.
Comparison of isolation strategies: Centralized isolation (random edge removal), Aware-Isolation (DA), and Isolation of neighbors (DI).

These strategies were tested across various topologies, including synthetic small-world and scale-free networks, as well as real-world datasets like the Enron email network and high-resolution contact data from schools.

Key Insights and Results

The Synergy of Hybrid Strategies

The most significant finding is that the Hybrid (C+D) strategy is more effective than the sum of its parts. While centralized lockdowns lower the overall connectivity of the network, decentralized awareness acts as a precision strike against active clusters. For instance, cutting 75% of ties via centralized isolation reduced outbreak impact by 75%, but the Hybrid approach achieved an 87% reduction.

Neutralizing Superspreaders

"Hub" nodes with many connections are the primary drivers of rapid transmission. The Hybrid strategy proved uniquely efficient at mitigating these superspreaders, reducing the highest node degrees to less than 10% of their initial values.

The Critical "Awareness Lag"

The "Contagious" state—where nodes spread the virus before realizing they are infected—represents the most dangerous period. Because individuals cannot self-isolate during this phase, centralized measures are essential to provide a safety net and slow transmission before individual awareness can take effect.

Impact of Timing and Density

Timing is paramount; delaying isolation measures by just one month can lead to a 76% increase in total infections. Furthermore, in high-density environments like schools, moderate distancing is often ineffective due to the highly "meshed" nature of the network; only extreme isolation (cutting >75% of ties) showed significant impact.

Conclusion

The SICARS model demonstrates that effective pandemic management requires a multi-layered approach. While centralized lockdowns are vital for delaying peaks and buying time for healthcare systems, they are most powerful when paired with decentralized individual awareness. Future research should consider socio-economic barriers to isolation and the impact of "distancing fatigue" on long-term pandemic waves.

Summary updated

Abstract

The infectious diseases are spreading due to human interactions enabled by various social networks. Therefore, when a new pathogen such as SARS-CoV-2 causes an outbreak, the non-pharmaceutical isolation strategies (e.g., social distancing) are the only possible response to disrupt its spreading. To this end, we introduce the new epidemic model (SICARS) and compare the centralized (C), decentralized (D), and combined (C+D) social distancing strategies, and analyze their efficiency to control the dynamics of COVID-19 on heterogeneous complex networks. Our analysis shows that the centralized social distancing is necessary to minimize the pandemic spreading. The decentralized strategy is insufficient when used alone, but offers the best results when combined with the centralized one. Indeed, the (C+D) is the most efficient isolation strategy at mitigating the network superspreaders and reducing the highest node degrees to less than 10% of their initial values. Our results also indicate that stronger social distancing, e.g., cutting 75% of social ties, can reduce the outbreak by 75% for the C isolation, by 33% for the D isolation, and by 87% for the (C+D) isolation strategy. Finally, we study the impact of proactive versus reactive isolation strategies, as well as their delayed enforcement. We find that the reactive response to the pandemic is less efficient, and delaying the adoption of isolation measures by over one month (since the outbreak onset in a region) can have alarming effects; thus, our study contributes to an understanding of the COVID-19 pandemic both in space and time. We believe our investigations have a high social relevance as they provide insights into understanding how different degrees of social distancing can reduce the peak infection ratio substantially; this can make the COVID-19 pandemic easier to understand and control over an extended period of time.
BibTeX
@misc{topirceanu2020centralized,
  author = {Alexandru Topirceanu and Mihai Udrescu and Radu Marculescu},
  title = {{Centralized and decentralized isolation strategies and their impact on the COVID-19 pandemic dynamics}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2004.04222},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2004.04222},
}
Figure