Cenozoic Pulsed Rise and Growth of the Chinese South Tianshan Revealed by Zircon and Apatite Provenance Analyses: Implications for Stepwise Aridification in the Tarim Basin

Dunfeng Xiang, Zhiyong Zhang, David Chew, Marc Jolivet, Marco G. Malusà, Thomas Zack, Lin Wu, Chao Guo, Nan Wang, Wenjiao XiaoTectonics 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the South Tianshan mountain range experienced pulsed uplift in the Cenozoic, with key growth phases around 41-37 Ma and 24 Ma, and a significant blocking event by 10 Ma. These uplift events directly correlate with two distinct stages of aridification in the Tarim Basin, fundamentally shaping Central Asian climate.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The aridification of Central Asia, particularly the Tarim Basin, is a significant geological and climatic phenomenon. While the uplift of major mountain ranges like the Himalayas and Pamirs has been implicated, the specific role of the Tianshan range, especially its southern portion, has been less clear. When and how the Tianshan deformed and grew during the Cenozoic is a subject of debate, making it difficult to pinpoint its influence on regional climate. This paper aims to resolve this ambiguity by precisely dating the uplift phases of the South Tianshan and linking them directly to the stepwise aridification of the Tarim Basin.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Detrital Zircon U-Pb Dating: This technique analyzes the age of zircon crystals found in sedimentary rocks. By dating these grains, scientists can identify the source rocks from which they were eroded, providing insights into the provenance (origin) of the sediments and thus the uplift history of the source mountains.
  • Detrital Apatite U-Pb Dating: Similar to zircon dating, this method uses apatite crystals to determine source rock ages. Apatite can offer complementary information to zircon, especially regarding different geological processes.
  • Apatite Fission Track (AFT) Analysis: This method dates the time it took for apatite crystals to cool below a certain temperature threshold. By analyzing detrital AFT ages in sedimentary layers, researchers can reconstruct the cooling and exhumation history of the source mountains, essentially dating when rocks were brought closer to the surface.
  • Magnetostratigraphy: This technique uses the Earth's magnetic field reversals recorded in sedimentary rocks to establish a precise chronological framework for the depositional ages of the samples.
  • Paleocurrent Measurements: Analyzing the direction of ancient river flows (indicated by sedimentary structures like cross-bedding and imbricated pebbles) helps determine the direction from which sediments were transported, further constraining the source regions.
  • Multidimensional Scaling (MDS) Plot: This statistical tool helps visualize the relationships between different detrital zircon age spectra and potential source regions, aiding in provenance discrimination.

Datasets

The study utilized newly collected detrital zircon and apatite samples from Cenozoic sedimentary successions in the Baicheng-Kuqa Depression on the northern margin of the Tarim Basin. These were integrated with previously published detrital zircon U-Pb data from adjacent regions, including samples from the Kelasu, Awate, and Kuqa River sections. The ages of magmatic rocks from the Tianshan and northern Tarim Craton were also compiled for comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Two-Stage Aridification: The most significant insight is the direct link between two distinct pulses of South Tianshan uplift and two corresponding stages of aridification in the Tarim Basin. This challenges simpler models of continuous uplift.
  • South Tianshan as a Primary Driver: The study strongly suggests that the South Tianshan, rather than just the Pamir-Tianshan corridor, played a dominant role in blocking moisture-laden westerlies and driving aridification.
  • Timing is Crucial: Precisely dating the uplift events (around 41-37 Ma and 24 Ma, with a significant blocking event by 10 Ma) is key to understanding the causal relationship with climate change.
  • Provenance Shifts: The detrital zircon data reveal clear shifts in sediment sources, indicating major changes in drainage patterns and mountain erosion over time, directly tied to the Tianshan's growth.
  • India-Asia Collision as the Ultimate Driver: The study posits that the far-field compressive stress from the India-Asia collision initiated and propagated the uplift and deformation in the Tianshan.

Key Results

  • Initial Uplift (41-37 Ma): Deformation and uplift in the Baicheng-Kuqa Depression and the South Tianshan began around 41-37 Ma, initiating the blocking of sediment flow from the north.
  • Second Uplift Pulse (24 Ma): A subsequent topographic growth phase of the South Tianshan occurred around 24 Ma, further enhancing its role as a barrier.
  • Complete Blockage (10 Ma): By approximately 10 Ma, the continued uplift of the South Tianshan completely blocked fluvial transport from the Central Tianshan-Yili Block, as evidenced by a significant decrease in 380-310 Ma detrital zircons and apatites.
  • Two-Step Aridification: The Tarim Basin experienced aridification in two stages, correlating with the ~24 Ma and ~10 Ma uplift events of the South Tianshan.
  • Eocene Stress Propagation: Northward-directed compressive stress from the India-Asia collision began propagating into the South Tianshan and its foreland during the Late Eocene (~41-37 Ma) and continued to do so at ~24 Ma and 10 Ma.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Geothermal Gradient Assumptions: The AFT analysis relies on assumed geothermal gradients, which can introduce some uncertainty in temperature reconstructions.
  • Recycling of Sediments: While acknowledged, the precise impact of Mesozoic and Cenozoic sediment recycling on the detrital age spectra requires further detailed investigation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further research could focus on integrating more detailed paleoclimate data with the tectonic evolution to refine our understanding of the complex interactions between mountain building and climate change in Central Asia. Investigating other regions within the Tianshan range could also provide a more comprehensive picture of its overall deformation history.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Cenozoic uplift in the Tianshan played an important role in driving Proto‐Paratethys Sea retreat and Asian aridification. However, most paleoclimate studies have focused on the Pamir‐Tianshan corridor, and frequently overlook the role of the entire Tianshan range in modifying the Central Asian climate during Cenozoic uplift. When and how Cenozoic deformation of Tianshan was initiated and propagated are intensively debated which makes its role in contributing to climate change in Central Asia more ambiguous. To address this issue, this study presents new detrital zircon U‐Pb and detrital apatite U‐Pb and fission track age data from Cenozoic sedimentary successions (54–0 Ma) in the northern margin of the Tarim Basin and integrates these data with published provenance data from adjacent regions. Our results show that deformation/uplift of the Baicheng‐Kuqa Depression and the South Tianshan occurred at ∼41–37 Ma and ∼24 Ma, when topographic growth of South Tianshan began to block the flow of sediment from the north. Continued uplift of the South Tianshan completely blocked fluvial transport from the Central Tianshan‐Yili Block by ∼10 Ma, as shown by the paucity of 380–310 Ma detrital zircons/apatites. Far‐field, north‐directed compressive stress resulting from the India‐Asia collision began to propagate toward the South Tianshan and its foreland during the Late Eocene, and continued to propagate into the South Tianshan and northward at the ∼24 Ma and 10 Ma. Finally, we suggest a two‐stage of aridification in the Tarim Basin which can be linked to two stages (∼24 and 10 Ma) of growth of the Tianshan.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xiang2024cenozoic,
  author = {Dunfeng Xiang and Zhiyong Zhang and David Chew and Marc Jolivet and Marco G. Malusà and Thomas Zack and Lin Wu and Chao Guo and Nan Wang and Wenjiao Xiao},
  title = {{Cenozoic Pulsed Rise and Growth of the Chinese South Tianshan Revealed by Zircon and Apatite Provenance Analyses: Implications for Stepwise Aridification in the Tarim Basin}},
  booktitle = {Tectonics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1029/2023tc008211},
}
Figure