Cellular logics bringing the symmetry breaking in spiral nucleation revealed by trans-scale imaging

Taishi Kakizuka, Yusuke Hara, Yusaku Ohta, Asuka Mukai, Aya Ichiraku, Yoshiyuki Arai, Taro Ichimura, Takeharu Nagai, Kazuki HorikawabioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses a novel "trans-scale" imaging technique to observe the spontaneous formation of spiral waves in social amoeba (Dictyostelium discoideum). They discovered that the key to this complex pattern formation lies in the heterogeneous "excitability" of the cells, driven by a small group of "leader" cells and amplified by "follower" cells, rather than a uniform response.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Spiral waves are fascinating spatio-temporal patterns observed in various systems, from chemical reactions to biological processes like heart arrhythmias. While their properties are well-studied, how they spontaneously arise in living systems has remained a mystery. Specifically, in the context of Dictyostelium discoideum, a social amoeba that forms complex patterns during its development, understanding the cellular-level mechanisms that lead to the breaking of symmetry and the initiation of these spiral waves has been elusive. The challenge lies in observing the intricate interplay of communication signals (like cAMP) across a vast number of cells with high spatial and temporal resolution.

Methods

The core innovation here is a "trans-scale" imaging system. This system allows researchers to simultaneously observe the behavior of approximately 130,000 individual cells. It combines a large field of view (covering a significant area of the cell culture) with single-cell resolution. This is achieved using a high-resolution CMOS sensor and a specialized objective lens.

Beyond the imaging hardware, the researchers also employed:

  • Fluorescent reporters: A fusion protein (Red-FL2) was used to visualize cAMP dynamics within the cells.
  • Quantitative analysis: Ratiometric imaging helped correct for motion artifacts, and sophisticated image processing pipelines were used to analyze the vast amount of data.
  • Cellular automata (CA) modeling: To complement the experimental observations, the researchers developed a computational model that simulates the behavior of individual cells and their interactions, allowing them to test hypotheses about the underlying mechanisms.

Datasets

The study utilized a large-scale observation of approximately 130,000 cells of the social amoeba, Dictyostelium discoideum (Ax2 strain). This dataset was generated through live-cell imaging over extended periods. No specific benchmark datasets were mentioned; the study generated its own primary data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Heterogeneity is Key: The most striking finding is that the spontaneous formation of spiral waves isn't due to a uniform response of all cells. Instead, it's driven by heterogeneous excitability – some cells are more responsive or prone to initiating signals than others.
  • "Law of the Few" in Action: A small subset of cells, termed "pacemaker" (PM) cells or "leaders," are crucial for initiating the process. This aligns with the "law of the few" concept, where a small number of elements can have a disproportionately large impact.
  • Followers Amplify: These leader cells don't act alone. "Follower" cells play a critical role in amplifying the signals and controlling the timing of key transitions, effectively scaling up the initial signals.
  • Critical Transition: The study identified a "critical transition" (CT) in the local dynamics of cell populations, where a sudden leap in activity occurs. This transition is essential for the development of localized "hot spots" of high excitability.
  • Asymmetry Drives Symmetry Breaking: The off-center positioning of these pacemaker cells within a high-excitability territory is the direct cause of the symmetry breaking that leads to spiral wave formation.

Key Results

  • The trans-scale imaging system successfully captured cAMP dynamics at the single-cell level across ~130,000 cells.
  • The study identified that wave fragmentation, a precursor to spiral wave formation, occurs at the boundaries of heterogeneously excitable regions.
  • Analysis revealed that pacemaker cells are essential but not sufficient for the development of "hot spots" of high activity; follower cells are also critical for amplification and timing.
  • The CA model, when incorporating distributed initial excitability and a small number of fixed pacemakers, successfully reproduced the observed spontaneous wave fragmentation and spiral wave formation.
  • The density of pacemaker cells was estimated to be about 1 in 770 cells.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Direct Measurement of Excitability: The paper notes that a direct molecular marker for local excitability has not yet been found, and they relied on indirect measures like cumulative pulse counts.
  • Model Simplifications: While the CA model was effective, it involves simplifications of biological processes. The authors mention that the pattern of initial excitability distribution wasn't critical for wave fragmentation, but the non-homogeneous nature was.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that their trans-scale imaging approach and findings could be applicable to other growing excitable media, such as the segmentation clock in embryos and neuronal circuits. Further research could explore the precise molecular mechanisms that establish and maintain this cellular heterogeneity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Summary The spiral wave is a commonly observed spatio-temporal order in diverse signal relaying systems. Although properties of generated spirals have been well studied, the mechanisms for their spontaneous generation in living systems remain elusive. By the newly developed imaging system for trans-scale observation of the intercellular communication among ∼130,000 cells of social amoeba, we investigated the onset dynamics of cAMP signaling and identified mechanisms for the self-organization of the spiral wave at three distinct scalings: At the population-level, the structured heterogeneity of excitability fragments traveling waves at its high/low boundary, that becomes the generic source of the spiral wave. At the cell-level, both the pacemaking leaders and pulse-amplifying followers regulate the heterogeneous growth of the excitability. At the intermediate-scale, the essence of the spontaneous wave fragmentation is the asymmetric positioning of the pacemakers in the high-excitability territories, whose critical controls are operated by a small number of cells, pulse counts, and pulse amounts.
BibTeX
@misc{kakizuka2020cellular,
  author = {Taishi Kakizuka and Yusuke Hara and Yusaku Ohta and Asuka Mukai and Aya Ichiraku and Yoshiyuki Arai and Taro Ichimura and Takeharu Nagai and Kazuki Horikawa},
  title = {{Cellular logics bringing the symmetry breaking in spiral nucleation revealed by trans-scale imaging}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.06.29.176891},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure