Cell type composition and circuit organization of neocortical radial clones

Cathryn R. Cadwell, Federico Scala, Paul G. Fahey, Dmitry Kobak, Fabian H. Sinz, Per Johnsson, Shuang Li, R. Cotton, Rickard Sandberg, Philipp Berens, Xiaolong Jiang, Andreas S. ToliasbioRxiv 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Excitatory neurons arising from a common progenitor establish radially-oriented clonal units in the neocortex which have been proposed to serve as elementary information processing modules. To characterize the cell types and circuit diagram within these clonal units, we performed single-cell RNA-sequencing and multi-cell patch clamp recordings of neurons derived from Nestin-positive progenitors. We found that radial clones do not appear to be fate-restricted, but instead individual clones are composed of a random sampling of the transcriptomic cell types present in a particular cortical area. The effect of lineage on synaptic connectivity depends on the type of connection tested: pairs of clonally related neurons were more likely to be connected vertically, across cortical layers, but not laterally within the same layer, compared to unrelated pairs. We propose that integration of vertical input from related neurons with lateral input from unrelated neurons may represent a developmentally programmed motif for assembling neocortical circuits.

Introduction

The mammalian neocortex is organized into "ontogenetic columns"—radial clusters of excitatory neurons that descend from a single radial glial cell (RGC). For decades, neuroscientists have debated two major questions about these clones:

  1. Fate Restriction: Does a single progenitor produce the full diversity of excitatory neurons in a column, or are some progenitors "hard-wired" to only produce specific subtypes (e.g., only neurons that project to the opposite hemisphere)?
  2. Connectivity: It is a "dogma" in the field that clonally related neurons are more likely to be synaptically connected. However, does this increased connectivity apply to all directions, or is it specific to the vertical "columnar" architecture?

Understanding these rules is critical for deciphering how the brain’s massive, complex circuits assemble themselves during development.

Methods

The study employed a multi-modal experimental approach to link lineage, transcriptomics, and connectivity.

Lineage Tracing and Reconstruction

Researchers used a tamoxifen-inducible Cre-lox system (Nestin-CreER) to sparsely label progenitors at the onset of neurogenesis. By inducing at different embryonic days (E9.5–E11.5), they could control clone size and density, allowing for the identification of clones spanning layers 2 through 6.

Lineage tracing strategy and 3D reconstruction of a radial clone.

Patch-seq and Multi-cell Patch-clamp

To link function to identity, the team used Patch-seq to record electrophysiological properties and sequence the RNA of individual neurons. Simultaneously, multi-cell patch-clamp recordings (up to eight neurons) were used to map the synaptic connectivity matrix between "sisters" (labeled) and "strangers" (unlabeled neighbors). Transcriptomic data were mapped onto the Tasic et al. (2018) reference atlas for objective cell type classification.

Results

Characterization of Radial Clones

Induction at E10.5 produced clones with a median of 86 neurons, spanning approximately 235 µm in width. Quantitative analysis showed that clone size and width decreased significantly as induction occurred later in development.

Quantitative characterization of clone size, width, and completeness across developmental induction timepoints.

Stochastic Composition

Individual radial clones are not fate-restricted. A single progenitor can give rise to the full spectrum of excitatory transcriptomic types (e.g., L2/3 IT, L4 IT, L5 PT) found in its area. The makeup of a clone effectively represents a random sampling of the local population, with labeled neurons mapping to all broad excitatory classes in proportions nearly identical to unlabeled control neurons.

The Vertical Wiring Rule

Lineage-dependent connectivity is direction-specific. Sister neurons were approximately twice as likely to connect vertically (across layers) compared to unrelated pairs (6.0% vs. 2.7%, $p=0.0056$). Conversely, there was no significant increase in lateral connectivity within the same layer between sister neurons (5.7% for related vs. 8.2% for unrelated, $p=0.25$).

Discussion

The authors propose a new model for cortical assembly: vertical "core" inputs are provided by developmentally related sister cells, while lateral "integrative" inputs are provided by unrelated neurons. This suggests a hardwired blueprint for building the functional modules of the brain.

While the study provides a high-resolution map of local circuits in juvenile mice (P15–P20), future work is needed to determine if these rules hold in the fully adult brain or in higher-order cortical areas like the prefrontal cortex. Additionally, the diversity of long-range projection targets for sister neurons remains an open question for future mapping efforts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Summary Excitatory neurons arising from a common progenitor establish radially-oriented clonal units in the neocortex which have been proposed to serve as elementary information processing modules. To characterize the cell types and circuit diagram within these clonal units, we performed single-cell RNA-sequencing and multi-cell patch clamp recordings of neurons derived from Nestin -positive progenitors. We found that radial clones do not appear to be fate-restricted, but instead individual clones are composed of a random sampling of the transcriptomic cell types present in a particular cortical area. The effect of lineage on synaptic connectivity depends on the type of connection tested: pairs of clonally related neurons were more likely to be connected vertically, across cortical layers, but not laterally within the same layer, compared to unrelated pairs. We propose that integration of vertical input from related neurons with lateral input from unrelated neurons may represent a developmentally programmed motif for assembling neocortical circuits.
BibTeX
@misc{cadwell2019cell,
  author = {Cathryn R. Cadwell and Federico Scala and Paul G. Fahey and Dmitry Kobak and Fabian H. Sinz and Per Johnsson and Shuang Li and R. Cotton and Rickard Sandberg and Philipp Berens and Xiaolong Jiang and Andreas S. Tolias},
  title = {{Cell type composition and circuit organization of neocortical radial clones}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/526681},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure