Cell-in-Cell Phenomenon and Its Relationship With Tumor Microenvironment and Tumor Progression: A Review

Xinlong Wang, Yilong Li, Jiating Li, Le Li, Hong‐Jian Zhu, Hua Chen, Rui Kong, Gang Wang, Yongwei Wang, Jisheng Hu, Bei SunFrontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology 2019 · DOI

Abstract

The term cell-in-cell, morphologically, refers to the presence of one cell within another. This phenomenon can occur in tumors but also among non-tumor cells. The cell-in-cell phenomenon was first observed 100 years ago, and it has since been found in a variety of tumor types. Recently, increasing attention has been paid to this phenomenon and the underlying mechanism has gradually been elucidated. There are three main related process: cannibalism, emperipolesis, and entosis. These processes are affected by many factors, including the tumor microenvironment, mitosis, and genetic factors. There is considerable evidence to suggest that the cell-in-cell phenomenon is associated with the prognosis of cancers, and it promotes tumor progression in most situations. Notably, in pancreatic cancer, the cell-in-cell phenomenon is associated with reduced metastasis, which is the opposite of what happens in other tumor types. Thus, it can also inhibit tumor progression. Studies show that cell-in-cell structure formation is affected by the tumor microenvironment, and that it may lead to changes in cellular characteristics. In this review, we summarize the different cell-in-cell processes and discuss their role in tumor progression and how they are regulated by different mechanisms.

Introduction

For over a century, pathologists have observed "bird’s eye" or "signet ring" cells within tumor tissues. This "cell-in-cell" (CIC) phenomenon—where one viable cell resides inside another—has long been a morphological curiosity. However, recent research has begun to uncover the molecular drivers and clinical significance of these structures. This review synthesizes findings to categorize CIC into three distinct biological processes: cannibalism, emperipolesis, and entosis. While typically a hallmark of tumor progression and genetic instability, the phenomenon presents a fascinating paradox, potentially inhibiting metastasis in specific contexts like pancreatic cancer.

Mechanisms of Cell-in-Cell Formation

The CIC phenomenon is not a single event but a collection of distinct molecular and behavioral pathways triggered by the tumor microenvironment (TME), characterized by acidity, nutrient deprivation, and inflammation.

Schematic representation of the three main cell-in-cell processes: cannibalism, emperipolesis, and entosis.

Cannibalism

Cannibalism involves the active engulfment of cells (either homotypic or heterotypic) by a host cell. This is primarily a metabolic strategy for nutrient acquisition in harsh, starved environments. Key molecular players include TM9SF4 and Caveolin-1.

Emperipolesis

Emperipolesis is a "wandering" process where one cell penetrates another and remains intact. The internal cell may eventually escape or undergo a specialized form of death known as "emperitosis." This process is mediated by Ezrin, LFA-1, and ICAM-1.

Entosis

Entosis is a cell-in-cell invasion triggered by the loss of attachment to the extracellular matrix (anoikis resistance). Driven by imbalances in actomyosin contraction, it involves E/P-cadherin and the Rho-ROCK signaling pathway.

Impact on Tumor Progression and Clinical Significance

The CIC phenomenon plays a dual role in oncology, acting primarily as a driver of malignancy while occasionally serving as a tumor suppressor.

Nutrient Scavenging and Survival

In the starved, acidic TME, "winner" tumor cells utilize cannibalism and entosis to survive by consuming "loser" sibling cells or infiltrating immune cells. Extracellular acidosis (low pH) has been confirmed as a primary trigger that activates cannibalistic enzymes like cathepsins.

Induction of Chromosomal Instability (CIN)

A critical insight is that CIC structures physically interfere with the host cell's mitosis. By blocking cytokinesis, these structures lead to multinucleation and aneuploidy, accelerating the genomic instability that drives cancer progression. Clinical data shows that neutrophil-tumor cell cannibalism correlates with higher-grade malignancy, observed in approximately 1.4% of oral squamous cell carcinoma cases.

The Pancreatic Paradox

While CIC usually signals a poor prognosis, pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC) presents an exception. Homotypic cannibalism in PDAC is associated with reduced metastasis and better outcomes. Patients with osteoclast-like giant cells (exhibiting high CIC activity) showed a 59.1% 5-year survival rate, significantly higher than standard PDAC prognoses.

Conclusion and Future Directions

Despite significant progress, several gaps remain in our understanding of the CIC phenomenon. The boundaries between cannibalism, entosis, and emperipolesis are still blurred, suggesting they might exist on a spectrum rather than as entirely distinct paths. Furthermore, while inducing entosis could theoretically kill tumor cells, it risks increasing chromosomal instability and drug resistance. Future research must transition from in vitro cultures to in vivo models to fully understand how the complex architecture of a living tumor regulates these "cell-eating-cell" behaviors.

Summary updated

Abstract

The term cell-in-cell, morphologically, refers to the presence of one cell within another. This phenomenon can occur in tumors but also among non-tumor cells. The cell-in-cell phenomenon was first observed 100 years ago, and it has since been found in a variety of tumor types. Recently, increasing attention has been paid to this phenomenon and the underlying mechanism has gradually been elucidated. There are three main related process: cannibalism, emperipolesis, and entosis. These processes are affected by many factors, including the tumor microenvironment, mitosis, and genetic factors. There is considerable evidence to suggest that the cell-in-cell phenomenon is associated with the prognosis of cancers, and it promotes tumor progression in most situations. Notably, in pancreatic cancer, the cell-in-cell phenomenon is associated with reduced metastasis, which is the opposite of what happens in other tumor types. Thus, it can also inhibit tumor progression. Studies show that cell-in-cell structure formation is affected by the tumor microenvironment, and that it may lead to changes in cellular characteristics. In this review, we summarize the different cell-in-cell processes and discuss their role in tumor progression and how they are regulated by different mechanisms.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2019cell,
  author = {Xinlong Wang and Yilong Li and Jiating Li and Le Li and Hong‐Jian Zhu and Hua Chen and Rui Kong and Gang Wang and Yongwei Wang and Jisheng Hu and Bei Sun},
  title = {{Cell-in-Cell Phenomenon and Its Relationship With Tumor Microenvironment and Tumor Progression: A Review}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fcell.2019.00311},
}
Figure