CEBench: A Benchmarking Toolkit for the Cost-Effectiveness of LLM Pipelines

Rihan Hai, Wenbo Sun, Jiaqi Wang, Qiming Guo, Ziyu Li, Wenlu Wang, Rihan Hai 0001arXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

Deploying Large Language Models (LLMs) in production environments requires a delicate balance between performance and operational costs. While high-accuracy models are desirable, sectors such as healthcare and finance often necessitate local deployments to comply with data privacy regulations like GDPR. However, local hosting involves significant hardware investment and complex Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) configurations. CEBench is an open-source benchmarking toolkit designed to address these challenges by evaluating the cost-effectiveness of LLM pipelines, identifying the "Pareto front"—the optimal balance between performance and expenditure.

System Design and Methodology

CEBench addresses two primary gaps in the current ecosystem: the high friction of custom benchmarking and the "economic blind spot" where costs are ignored in favor of accuracy metrics. The toolkit provides a "zero-coding" framework that treats resource consumption as a primary evaluation metric.

CEBench System Architecture

The architecture is modular, consisting of a Host Server for configuration and a Benchmarking Server that executes models and vector databases within Docker containers. Key features include:

  • Automated Execution: Iterates through models, quantization levels, and RAG parameters (chunk size, Top-K) via YAML/JSON configurations.
  • Resource Monitoring: Real-time tracking of memory footprint and processing latency.
  • Plan Recommender: Uses collected metrics to suggest deployment plans. It estimates cloud costs by comparing local GPU TFLOPS against target cloud instances.
  • Multi-Objective Optimization: Visualizes trade-offs to help stakeholders determine if marginal accuracy gains justify increased hosting costs.

Experimental Evaluation

The researchers validated CEBench using two real-world scenarios:

  1. DAIC-WOZ (Clinical Interviews): Focused on local deployment for a mental health assistant where privacy is paramount.
  2. ContractNLI (Legal Documents): Focused on online LLM services to compare RAG against few-shot prompting strategies.

Key Insights and Results

Experimental results highlighted that RAG serves as a significant economic tool. In legal use cases, RAG-based pipelines were cheaper than few-shot prompting because they utilized shorter, more relevant context chunks, reducing the total input token count. Furthermore, the study observed diminishing returns of scale; larger models like Llama-3-70B did not always outperform smaller, optimized models like Mixtral-8x7b, despite significantly higher hardware costs.

Pareto Front Analysis of Cost vs. Performance

Key findings include:

  • Mental Health Assistant: Mixtral-8x7b achieved the highest accuracy, but Llama-3-8b offered the lowest latency. CEBench identified configurations that significantly reduced costs with only minor impacts on accuracy.
  • Legal Contract Review: Claude 3 Haiku with RAG emerged as the optimal choice, maintaining over 90% F1 score at a cost of just $0.0003 per prompt.
  • Online vs. Local: For certain tasks, online services were found to be up to three times cheaper than maintaining equivalent local high-performance hardware.

Conclusion and Future Work

CEBench demonstrates that automated benchmarking is essential for navigating the complex trade-offs of LLM deployment. While the current latency estimation relies on simplified TFLOPS ratios, future work will integrate more sophisticated performance models to account for memory bandwidth and software-level optimizations like FlashAttention, providing even more precise predictions across diverse hardware configurations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Online Large Language Model (LLM) services such as ChatGPT and Claude 3 have transformed business operations and academic research by effortlessly enabling new opportunities. However, due to data-sharing restrictions, sectors such as healthcare and finance prefer to deploy local LLM applications using costly hardware resources. This scenario requires a balance between the effectiveness advantages of LLMs and significant financial burdens. Additionally, the rapid evolution of models increases the frequency and redundancy of benchmarking efforts. Existing benchmarking toolkits, which typically focus on effectiveness, often overlook economic considerations, making their findings less applicable to practical scenarios. To address these challenges, we introduce CEBench, an open-source toolkit specifically designed for multi-objective benchmarking that focuses on the critical trade-offs between expenditure and effectiveness required for LLM deployments. CEBench allows for easy modifications through configuration files, enabling stakeholders to effectively assess and optimize these trade-offs. This strategic capability supports crucial decision-making processes aimed at maximizing effectiveness while minimizing cost impacts. By streamlining the evaluation process and emphasizing cost-effectiveness, CEBench seeks to facilitate the development of economically viable AI solutions across various industries and research fields. The code and demonstration are available in https://github.com/amademicnoboday12/CEBench.
BibTeX
@misc{hai2024cebench,
  author = {Rihan Hai and Wenbo Sun and Jiaqi Wang and Qiming Guo and Ziyu Li and Wenlu Wang and Rihan Hai},
  title = {{CEBench: A Benchmarking Toolkit for the Cost-Effectiveness of LLM Pipelines}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2407.12797},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.12797},
}
Figure