Causal gene regulatory analysis with RNA velocity reveals an interplay between slow and fast transcription factors

Rohit Singh, Alexander P. Wu, Anish Mudide, Bonnie BergerbioRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces Velorama, a novel computational framework that leverages RNA velocity data to infer causal gene regulatory networks (GRNs) from single-cell data. Velorama can handle complex, branching cell differentiation trajectories and, crucially, estimates the speed of transcription factor (TF) interactions, revealing a link between TF speed and their regulatory function in development and disease.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how genes interact to control cellular function is a fundamental goal in biology, often represented by gene regulatory networks (GRNs). While single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) has revolutionized our ability to study these dynamics, inferring causal GRNs from this data remains challenging. Existing methods often rely on ordering cells along a linear "pseudotemporal" axis, which fails to capture the complex, branching nature of cell differentiation. Furthermore, many methods don't fully utilize the rich temporal information encoded in RNA velocity, a powerful technique that predicts future cell states. This gap limits our ability to uncover the precise causal relationships and the temporal dynamics of gene regulation, especially in the context of development and disease.

Methods

Velorama's core innovation lies in its ability to model cell differentiation as a directed acyclic graph (DAG) of cells, rather than a linear sequence. This DAG can be constructed from either pseudotime or, more powerfully, from RNA velocity data. Velorama directly incorporates RNA velocity-based cell-to-cell transition probabilities, allowing it to capture complex trajectories.

The inference of causal GRNs is performed using a generalized Granger causal (GC) inference framework adapted for DAGs. This approach looks for lagged interactions between transcription factors (TFs) and their target genes. A key feature of Velorama is its ability to estimate the speed of these TF-target interactions, based on the lag between a TF's expression change and its target's expression change. This is achieved through a multilayer neural network architecture that learns these relationships.

Datasets

The authors evaluated Velorama on:

  • Four synthetic datasets generated by SERGIO, designed to simulate various differentiation landscapes (linear, bifurcation, trifurcation, and tree-shaped). These datasets provided ground-truth GRNs for benchmarking.
  • Six real single-cell RNA-seq datasets, including:
  • Mouse endocrinogenesis
    • Mouse dentate gyrus neurogenesis
    • Human hematopoiesis
    • Cardiac hypertrophy in cardiomyocytes
    • A549 cells responding to pracinostat
    • Human corticogenesis (using both gene expression and chromatin accessibility data)
  • Two acute myeloid leukemia (AML) datasets for studying disease progression and treatment response.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • DAGs are better than linear models for complex differentiation: Representing cell states as a DAG, rather than forcing them into a linear pseudotime, is crucial for accurately capturing branching trajectories in cell differentiation.
  • RNA velocity unlocks finer-grained causal inference: Incorporating RNA velocity data significantly improves GRN inference accuracy compared to using pseudotime alone, highlighting its power in capturing dynamic cellular processes.
  • TF interaction speed matters: Velorama's ability to estimate TF interaction speeds is not just a technical feat; it reveals biologically meaningful distinctions. Slow TFs are linked to fundamental regulatory processes like chromatin remodeling and are associated with diseases like gliomas, while fast TFs are more involved in specific functions and linked to neuropsychiatric disorders.
  • Cooperative regulation across different speeds: TFs with different interaction speeds often work together. Slow TFs (like chromatin remodelers) may cooperate with faster TFs to drive cell-type-specific functions and differentiation.

Key Results

  • Substantial performance gains: Velorama outperformed existing GRN inference methods by 3.7–4.8x in terms of area under the precision-recall curve (AUPRC) on synthetic datasets.
  • RNA velocity boosts accuracy: Using RNA velocity data improved AUPRC by 1.8–3x compared to pseudotime-based inference.
  • Disease associations:
    • Slow TFs were significantly linked to gliomas and were less cell-type specific.
  • Fast TFs were implicated in neuropsychiatric diseases and were more cell-type specific.
  • Pioneer factors are slow: Slow TFs were significantly enriched for pioneer factors, which are known to initiate chromatin accessibility.
  • Corticogenesis insights: In human corticogenesis, slow TFs were associated with gliomas, while fast TFs were linked to neuropsychiatric disorders.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scalability: While Velorama is efficient, very large datasets (over 100,000 cells) might benefit from data sketching techniques.
  • Integration of modalities: The authors suggest that integrating Velorama with other data modalities, such as chromatin accessibility and TF binding data, could further improve performance.
  • Ensembling approaches: Combining pseudotime and RNA velocity predictions through ensembling could harness the unique strengths of both.
  • Broader application of speed estimation: The ability to measure TF interaction speeds is a promising new direction for understanding the role of temporal control in gene regulation across various tissues and diseases.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Single-cell expression dynamics from differentiation trajectories or RNA velocity have the potential to reveal causal links between transcription factors (TFs) and their target genes in gene regulatory networks (GRNs). However, existing methods either neglect these expression dynamics or require cells to be ordered along a linear pseudotemporal axis, which is incompatible with branching trajectories. We introduce Velorama, an approach to causal GRN inference that represents single-cell differentiation dynamics as a directed acyclic graph (DAG) of cells constructed from pseudotime or RNA velocity measurements. In contrast to previous approaches, Velorama is able to work directly with RNA velocity-based cell-to-cell transition probabilities and enables estimates of TF interaction speeds with their target genes. On a set of synthetic datasets, Velorama substantially outperforms existing approaches, improving area under the precision-recall curve (AUPRC) by 3.7–4.8x over the next best method. Applying Velorama to four RNA velocity datasets, we uncover evidence that the speed of a TF’s interactions is tied to its regulatory function. For human corticogenesis, we find slow TFs to be linked to gliomas and co-regulate preferentially with fast TFs, while fast TFs are associated with neuropsychiatric diseases. We expect Velorama to be a critical part of the RNA velocity toolkit for investigating the causal drivers of differentiation and disease. Software availability https://cb.csail.mit.edu/cb/velorama
BibTeX
@misc{singh2022causal,
  author = {Rohit Singh and Alexander P. Wu and Anish Mudide and Bonnie Berger},
  title = {{Causal gene regulatory analysis with RNA velocity reveals an interplay between slow and fast transcription factors}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.10.18.512766},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure