Catalytic Performance of Fe-Rich Sludge in Pyrolysis of Waste Oil Scum as Volatiles and Magnetic Char

Jiancong Liu, Manhong Ji, Qin Jiabao, Jia Zhu, Suiyi ZhuWater 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel "waste-to-treat-waste" strategy by catalytically pyrolyzing waste oil scum with Fe-rich sludge. This process efficiently converts the oil scum into valuable combustible gas/oil and a magnetic char, which then demonstrates excellent selective adsorption capabilities for the antibiotic ciprofloxacin from wastewater.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Oil-bearing wastewater treatment plants generate significant amounts of waste oil scum, a challenging byproduct that is often disposed of in landfills or incinerated, leading to environmental pollution and resource waste. While pyrolysis offers a route to recover valuable components, direct pyrolysis of oil scum can result in undesirable aromatic-rich products and inefficient char formation. The paper addresses the need for a more sustainable and efficient method to recycle oil scum, transforming it into useful materials while simultaneously tackling another environmental concern: the removal of persistent pollutants like antibiotics from wastewater.

Methods

The core of this research lies in a catalytic pyrolysis process. Waste oil scum was mixed with Fe-rich sludge (sourced from a pickling wastewater treatment plant) and heated to 700°C under a nitrogen atmosphere. The resulting products – gas, oil, and char – were collected and analyzed. A control experiment without the Fe-rich sludge was also performed for comparison.

Key analytical techniques employed include:

  • Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry (GC-MS): To characterize the composition of the generated gas and oil.
  • X-ray Diffraction (XRD): To analyze the crystalline structure of the char, particularly identifying iron-bearing phases.
  • Vibrating Sample Magnetometry (VSM): To quantify the magnetic properties of the produced char.
  • Adsorption Isotherm and Kinetic Studies: To evaluate the performance of the char in removing ciprofloxacin from aqueous solutions.
  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) analysis: To characterize the surface morphology and specific surface area of the chars.
  • X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) and Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR): To investigate the surface chemistry and functional groups of the char before and after adsorption.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilizes collected waste oil scum and Fe-rich sludge as feedstocks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Catalysis: The Fe-rich sludge acts as a crucial catalyst, not just a filler. The Fe/magnetite cycle facilitates the cleavage of tar into volatiles and simultaneously hinders its polycondensation into char. This is a key mechanism for improving gas/oil yield and quality.
  • "Waste-to-Treat-Waste" Paradigm: The research elegantly demonstrates a dual-purpose solution: recycling problematic oil scum into valuable products (gas/oil, magnetic char) and then utilizing the magnetic char to remediate another pollutant (ciprofloxacin) from wastewater.
  • Magnetic Char for Easy Separation: The incorporation of Fe-rich sludge imbues the resulting char with magnetic properties. This is a significant advantage for post-treatment separation from water using a magnetic field, simplifying the remediation process.
  • Selective Adsorption: The magnetic char exhibits remarkable selectivity for ciprofloxacin over other organic molecules like benzoic and sulfanilamide, suggesting its potential for targeted pollutant removal in complex wastewater matrices.
  • Enhanced Surface Functionality: The Fe-rich sludge not only catalyzes pyrolysis but also activates the char, creating more functional surface groups that enhance its adsorption capacity.

Key Results

  • Improved Volatiles Yield: The addition of Fe-rich sludge increased the conversion efficiency of tar to gas/oil from 30.2% to 57.3%.
  • Shift in Product Composition: Direct pyrolysis yielded gas/oil rich in aromatics. In contrast, the Fe-rich sludge-catalyzed pyrolysis produced gas/oil mainly composed of chain hydrocarbons, indicating a higher quality fuel.
  • Magnetic Char Performance: The magnetic char (char M) achieved a maximum adsorption capacity for ciprofloxacin of 63.5 mg/g, significantly higher than the non-magnetic char (char R) which had a capacity of 50.2 mg/g.
  • Selective Removal: Char M demonstrated a high removal efficiency for ciprofloxacin (98.9%) while showing much lower efficiencies for benzoic (14.2%) and sulfanilamide (16.1%) in a mixed wastewater scenario.
  • Reusability: The magnetic char maintained good performance after five reuse cycles, indicating its durability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Optimization of Pyrolysis Conditions: The authors suggest that further optimization of pyrolysis conditions is needed to maximize the conversion efficiency of tar to volatiles and minimize char yield.
  • Gas Collection: Special equipment is recommended for the efficient collection of combustible gases, separating them from CO2 and nitrogen.
  • Wastewater Treatment Scope: While effective for ciprofloxacin, the magnetic char showed limited efficacy in removing benzoic and sulfanilamide, indicating a need for further development for broader organic wastewater treatment.
  • Interpretation of Catalytic Mechanism: Further research is suggested to fully interpret the catalytic pyrolysis mechanism of waste oil scum with Fe-rich sludge under optimized conditions.
  • Broader Waste Utilization: The study proposes the potential for using other Fe-rich wastes (e.g., red mud, groundwater treatment sludge) and other oil-rich wastes in similar processes, opening avenues for wider resource recovery.

Summary updated

Abstract

Waste oil scum is commonly discharged during the air flotation process at oil-bearing wastewater treatment plants and disposed as an additive in cement kilns and/or furnaces. Herein, it was mixed with a magnetite-rich waste sludge and then completely recycled as value-added gas/oil and magnetic char via a facile catalytic pyrolysis route. Results showed that the oil scum was a blackish gel and contained 36.2% water, 52.5% tar, and 11.3% inorganics. After direct pyrolysis, the conversion efficiencies of tar to gas, oil, and char were 30.2%, 41.2%, and 28.6%, respectively, and the generated gas/oil was rich in aromatics. By adding Fe-rich sludge, the efficiencies varied to 57.3%, 26.9%, and 15.8%, respectively, and the gas/oil mainly comprised a chain hydrocarbon. During oil scum pyrolysis, the redox reaction of tar to Fe-rich sludge enabled a cycle of Fe/magnetite to accelerate the cleavage of tar as volatiles and to steadily retard the polycondensation of tar as char. In addition, the added Fe-rich sludge not only activated the rest of the char and created more surface functional groups for contaminant adsorption but also endowed the char with a good magnetic response. Such magnetic char showed a maximum adsorption capacity of ciprofloxacin of 63.5 mg/g, higher than that without the Fe-sludge catalyst, and had ability to selectively adsorb ciprofloxacin from benzoic/sulfanilamide-bearing wastewater. In summary, a ‘waste to treat waste’ strategy was developed to recycle waste oil scum as combustible gas/oil and magnetic char with the addition of magnetite-rich sludge.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2023catalytic,
  author = {Jiancong Liu and Manhong Ji and Qin Jiabao and Jia Zhu and Suiyi Zhu},
  title = {{Catalytic Performance of Fe-Rich Sludge in Pyrolysis of Waste Oil Scum as Volatiles and Magnetic Char}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/w15142637},
}
Figure