Case Study of Spectrum Sharing between Mobile and RAS Stations in Upper 6 GHz

Sana Salous, Jiming Chen2025 · DOI

TL;DR

As mobile operators eye the "spectrum gold mine" of the upper 6 GHz band for high-capacity 5G and 6G, they face a major hurdle: interference with ultra-sensitive radio astronomy stations. This paper demonstrates that by moving away from "one-size-fits-all" empirical models and using site-specific ray-tracing simulations, we can reduce required protection distances from a generic 60 km to as little as 25.4 km, opening the door for more efficient spectrum sharing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The upper 6 GHz band (6425–7125 MHz) is currently a high-stakes battleground in telecommunications. Mobile operators desperately need this bandwidth to meet the demand for low-latency, high-capacity applications. However, this same frequency range is vital for the Radio Astronomy Service (RAS), specifically for observing the methanol spectral line—a key marker used by scientists to study star formation.

The challenge is that RAS stations are incredibly sensitive. The interference threshold defined by the ITU (International Telecommunication Union) is a staggering -218.1 dBW/50 kHz. To put that in perspective, a typical mobile base station could easily drown out these cosmic signals from dozens of kilometers away. Standard empirical propagation models often suggest a blanket 60 km "exclusion zone" around RAS sites to prevent interference. This paper asks: Can we use more sophisticated modeling to find a more precise, less restrictive way for these two services to coexist?

Methods

The authors developed a simulation framework that moves beyond the standard empirical formulas (like those found in 3GPP TR38.901) which often oversimplify the environment. Instead, they employed ray-tracing propagation models.

While empirical models use statistical averages to predict signal loss, ray tracing simulates the actual physical paths of radio waves as they bounce off buildings, wrap around hills, and penetrate obstacles. By using 3GPP-compliant base station parameters combined with high-resolution terrain and obstacle data, the researchers could calculate the exact received power at an RAS station from potential mobile transmitters in the surrounding area.

Datasets

The paper focuses on a specific case study: Jodrell Bank Central in the UK, one of the world's most famous radio astronomy observatories.

  • Environmental Data: The simulation utilized local terrain and obstacle (building) data for the Jodrell Bank area.
  • Standards: The study adhered to the interference thresholds set by Recommendation ITU-R RA.769 and the channel models described in 3GPP TR 38.901.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Topography is a Shield: The most significant "aha moment" is that the 60 km standard exclusion zone is often either too conservative or not conservative enough. Because ray tracing accounts for the "shadowing" effect of hills and buildings, it reveals that some areas very close to the station might be safe for mobile use, while others further away (with a direct line of sight) might not be.
  • Site-Specific vs. Statistical: The paper argues that spectrum sharing shouldn't be governed by broad rules of thumb. Instead, "digital twins" of the environment (via ray tracing) allow for "surgical" spectrum management, where protection zones are shaped by the actual landscape.
  • Reconciling Science and Industry: The work provides a framework to balance the "irreplaceable scientific value" of radio astronomy with the economic and social necessity of wireless connectivity.

Key Results

The simulation at Jodrell Bank yielded a wide variance in required protection distances, proving that a single "60 km" rule is inefficient:

  • Best-Case Scenario: In areas where the terrain or buildings provided significant shielding, the protection distance could be reduced to just 25.4 km.
  • Worst-Case Scenario: In areas with clear lines of sight or unfavorable terrain, the required protection distance exceeded 90 km.
  • Conclusion on Accuracy: The results demonstrate that ray-tracing models provide a much more nuanced and accurate prediction of interference than traditional models, potentially reclaiming vast areas for mobile deployment that were previously thought to be "off-limits."

Limitations and Future Work

The current study provides a "snapshot" based on static terrain and base station parameters. The authors acknowledge that real-world conditions are dynamic.

Future Work: * AI-Driven Models: The authors plan to explore AI-driven predictive models to handle long-term coexistence, likely accounting for changing network traffic patterns and atmospheric conditions. * Dynamic Sharing: Moving from static exclusion zones to dynamic spectrum access, where mobile networks might adjust their power or beam direction in real-time based on RAS observation schedules.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{salous2025case,
  author = {Sana Salous and Jiming Chen},
  title = {{Case Study of Spectrum Sharing between Mobile and RAS Stations in Upper 6 GHz}},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.46620/ursiaprasc25/kgei1986},
}
Figure