Case report: Complete response of an anaplastic thyroid carcinoma patient with NRAS Q61R/BRAF D594N mutations to the triplet of dabrafenib, trametinib and PD-1 antibody

Lin Gui, Yiming Zhu, Xiaomo Li, Xiaohui He, Tonghui Ma, Yi Cai, Shaoyan LiuFrontiers in Immunology 2023 · DOI

This case report, published in Frontiers in Immunology, details a clinical breakthrough in treating one of the most aggressive forms of cancer: Anaplastic Thyroid Carcinoma (ATC). By leveraging a specific molecular "workaround" for a rare mutation profile, researchers achieved a complete pathological response in a patient who had failed standard immunotherapy.

TL;DR

Researchers successfully treated a metastatic Anaplastic Thyroid Carcinoma (ATC) patient carrying concurrent NRAS Q61R and non-V600 BRAF D594N mutations using a "triplet" therapy of dabrafenib, trametinib, and the PD-1 antibody sintilimab. This is the first reported case of a complete pathological response for this specific genetic profile, which is typically resistant to standard targeted therapies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Anaplastic Thyroid Carcinoma (ATC) is essentially a clinical emergency, with a mortality rate near 100%. While the medical community has made strides in treating ATC patients with the common BRAF V600E mutation using targeted inhibitors, patients with NRAS mutations or non-V600 BRAF mutations have few effective options.

Immunotherapy (PD-1/PD-L1 inhibitors) has shown some promise, but resistance often develops quickly. The challenge addressed here is how to treat a patient whose tumor is driven by a complex "Class 3" BRAF mutation and an NRAS mutation—a combination that usually renders standard BRAF inhibitors ineffective and drives resistance to initial immunotherapy.

Methods

As a case report, the "methods" describe the diagnostic and clinical decision-making process for a 61-year-old female patient:

  • Diagnostics: The team used contrast-enhanced CT, PET-CT, and immunohistochemical (IHC) staining (confirming a high PD-L1 expression of 60%).
  • Genomic Profiling: Next-generation sequencing (NGS) via the Onco Panscan™ panel identified a high-risk genetic signature: NRAS Q61R, BRAF D594N, and a TERT promoter mutation.
  • Treatment Evolution: After the patient progressed on a doublet of sintilimab (PD-1 inhibitor) and anlotinib (angiogenesis inhibitor), the team pivoted to a salvage "triplet" regimen:
  • Dabrafenib: A BRAF inhibitor.
  • Trametinib: A MEK inhibitor.
  • Sintilimab: Continued PD-1 blockade.

Datasets

This is a single-patient case study. The primary data source is the patient’s clinical record, including longitudinal imaging (CT/PET-CT) and the results of a multi-gene NGS panel (Genetron Health).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Class 3 BRAF "Aha!" Moment: Unlike the common V600E mutation (Class 1), the D594N mutation (Class 3) actually has impaired kinase activity. However, it drives cancer by "macro-dimerizing" with CRAF to amplify the MAPK signaling pathway.
  • Molecular Logic: The researchers hypothesized that while dabrafenib is designed for V600E, it can also inhibit CRAF in this specific context. Combined with trametinib (which hits MEK downstream), they could effectively shut down the MAPK pathway that was likely driving the initial resistance to immunotherapy.
  • Synergy Overcomes Resistance: The triplet therapy didn't just slow the tumor; it sensitized the tumor to the immune system. The activation of the MAPK pathway is known to reduce T-cell infiltration; shutting it down allowed the PD-1 antibody to finally do its job.

Key Results

  • Rapid Symptomatic Relief: Within just nine days of starting the triplet therapy, the patient’s bilateral neck metastases regressed, and her breathing and swallowing returned to normal.
  • Complete Pathological Response (pCR): After two cycles (six weeks), the patient underwent surgery. Postoperative pathology showed zero viable tumor cells—a rare "complete response" in ATC.
  • Durable Remission: As of the last follow-up in March 2023 (over a year after the initial recurrence), the patient remained in remission with an excellent quality of life.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation is the N=1 sample size. While the molecular rationale is sound, case reports cannot establish a new standard of care on their own.

The authors suggest that further investigation is needed to:

  1. Decipher the exact mechanism by which the BRAFi/MEKi combination overcomes PD-1 resistance in NRAS-mutated tumors.
  2. Determine the optimal sequencing of these drugs (e.g., should immunotherapy always come first, or is the triplet better as a first-line treatment?).
  3. Conduct larger clinical trials for ATC patients with non-V600 BRAF and NRAS mutations to validate this triplet approach.

Summary updated

Abstract

Anaplastic thyroid carcinoma, <i>BRAF</i> non-V600, <i>NRAS</i>, combination immunotherapy and targeted therapy, case report. Anaplastic thyroid carcinoma (ATC) is a rare type of thyroid cancer with a mortality rate near 100%. <i>BRAF</i> V600 and <i>NRAS</i> mutations are the most common drivers of ATC. While patients with <i>BRAF</i> V600-mutated ATC can be treated with BRAF-targeted therapy, there is no effective treatment for ATC driven by <i>NRAS</i> or non-V600 <i>BRAF</i> mutations. For patients with untargetable driver mutations, immunotherapy provides an alternative treatment option. Here, we present a metastatic ATC patient with PD-L1 positive (tumor proportion score of 60%) tumor and <i>NRAS</i> Q61R/<i>BRAF</i> D594N mutations, who progressed on PD-1 antibody sintilimab plus angiogenesis inhibitor anlotinib. The class 3 BRAF mutant D594N is sensitive to the inhibition of MEK inhibitor trametinib, and its oncogenic activity also depends on CRAF, which can be inhibited by BRAF inhibitor dabrafenib. For these reasons, the patient received a salvage treatment regime of dabrafenib, trametinib, and sintilimab, which resulted in a complete pathological response. To our best knowledge, this is the first report of successful treatment of ATC patients with concurrent <i>NRAS</i>/<i>BRAF</i> non-V600 mutations with the combination of immunotherapy and targeted therapy. Further investigation is required to decipher the mechanism by which the combination of dabrafenib/trametinib with PD-1 antibody overcomes initial immunotherapy resistance likely mediated by concurrent <i>BRAF</i> and <i>NRAS</i> mutations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gui2023case,
  author = {Lin Gui and Yiming Zhu and Xiaomo Li and Xiaohui He and Tonghui Ma and Yi Cai and Shaoyan Liu},
  title = {{Case report: Complete response of an anaplastic thyroid carcinoma patient with NRAS Q61R/BRAF D594N mutations to the triplet of dabrafenib, trametinib and PD-1 antibody}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Immunology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fimmu.2023.1178682},
}

Loading related content...

Figure