Case control study comparing the HPV genome in patients with oral cavity squamous cell carcinoma to normal patients using metagenomic shotgun sequencing

Ian Ganly, Zhiheng Pei, Yuhan Hao, Yingfei Ma, Matthew Rosenthal, Zheng-lin Wu, Jocelyn Migliacci, Bin Huang, Nora Katabi, Wenzhi Tseng, Stuart M. Brown, Yi‐Wei Tang, Liying YangScientific 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated the role of Human Papillomavirus (HPV) in oral cavity squamous cell carcinoma (OC-SCC) by comparing HPV genomes in mouthwash samples from OC-SCC patients and healthy controls using metagenomic shotgun sequencing. The findings suggest that HPV, particularly high-risk genotypes, plays a minimal role in the etiology of OC-SCC, with only one case showing a significant HPV presence.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditionally, oral cancer has been strongly linked to smoking and heavy alcohol consumption. However, recent epidemiological shifts show an increasing incidence of oral cancer in individuals who do not exhibit these risk factors, suggesting other contributing factors. Human Papillomavirus (HPV), especially high-risk genotypes like HPV 16, 18, and 33, is a known cause of oropharyngeal cancers. While some studies have explored HPV's role in oral cancer, results have been variable, and traditional detection methods often miss a wide range of HPV genotypes. This paper addresses the gap in understanding the prevalence and potential role of the full spectrum of HPV genotypes (beyond the commonly tested ones) in oral cavity squamous cell carcinoma, particularly in non-traditional risk groups.

Methods

The researchers employed a case-control study design, recruiting 50 patients diagnosed with OC-SCC and 50 age-, gender-, race-, smoking-, and alcohol-matched healthy controls. DNA was extracted from oral wash samples collected from all participants. The core of their methodology was metagenomic shotgun sequencing (MSS), a comprehensive approach that sequences all DNA present in a sample, allowing for the identification of a broad range of microbial genomes, including all known HPV genotypes.

The workflow involved:

  1. DNA Extraction: From oral wash samples.
  2. Whole Genome Shotgun Sequencing: To generate raw sequence data.
  3. Data Cleaning and Alignment: Raw reads were quality-controlled, adapters removed, and then aligned to the human genome (GRCH38) to identify and remove human DNA.
  4. Nonhuman Read Identification: Reads not aligning to the human genome were flagged for further analysis.
  5. HPV Genotyping: A specialized software tool called HPViewer was used to identify and genotype HPV sequences within the nonhuman reads. HPViewer was developed to improve accuracy by masking homologous sequences and repeats that can lead to misidentification.

For comparison and validation, tumor tissue from OC-SCC patients was also analyzed for high-risk HPV using PCR and p16 immunohistochemistry.

Datasets

The study utilized mouthwash samples from 100 human subjects: 50 diagnosed with oral cavity squamous cell carcinoma (OC-SCC) and 50 healthy controls. The raw sequencing data for HPV reads is publicly available via the NCBI BioProject ID PRJNA692713. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing human genome reference data (GRCH38) was used for read alignment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • HPV's Limited Role in OC-SCC: The most striking finding is the low prevalence of HPV in OC-SCC patients. This challenges the assumption that HPV might be a significant driver of oral cancers, especially in the context of changing epidemiological trends.
  • Metagenomic Shotgun Sequencing as a Comprehensive Tool: The study highlights the power of MSS in detecting a wide range of HPV genotypes, far beyond what traditional PCR-based methods can achieve. This approach is crucial for exploring less common or novel HPV types.
  • HPViewer's Utility: The development and application of HPViewer demonstrate a step forward in accurately identifying and genotyping HPV from complex metagenomic data, addressing challenges like homologous sequences and bacterial contamination.
  • Distinguishing High vs. Low HPV Reads: The study emphasizes the importance of not just detecting HPV, but also quantifying its presence. Only one case showed a high number of HPV reads, suggesting a potential etiological role, while others had only a few reads, indicating incidental presence or low-level infection.
  • Control Group Findings: The detection of HPV in some control individuals, albeit at very low levels, suggests that HPV carriage in the oral cavity is not exclusive to cancer patients and can occur in healthy individuals.

Key Results

  • Patient Demographics: No statistically significant differences were found between OC-SCC cases and controls in terms of gender, age, race/ethnicity, alcohol drinking, or cigarette smoking.
  • HPV Detection in OC-SCC: HPV was detected in 5 out of 50 (10%) OC-SCC cases.
  • Only one case (genotype 16) showed a high number of HPV reads, suggesting a potential role in the etiology of OC-SCC for that specific patient.
  • The other four cases had very low HPV reads (1-2 per human genome) and were associated with genotypes 10, 16 (two cases), and 98.
  • HPV Detection in Controls: HPV was detected in 4 out of 50 (8%) control patients, with genotypes 16, 22, 76, and 200. These detections were also at very low levels (1-2 HPV reads per human genome).
  • Nonhuman DNA Reads: There was no statistically significant difference in the number of nonhuman DNA reads between cancer and control samples.
  • Tumor Characteristics: Most OC-SCC tumors were negative for p16 immunohistochemistry (a surrogate marker for HPV infection), and only one case was positive for high-risk HPV by PCR.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: The study's sample size of 50 cases and 50 controls is relatively small, which may limit the statistical power to detect subtle associations.
  • Population Homogeneity: The study population was largely homogenous (88% white ethnicity) and from the USA. The authors acknowledge that geographic and ethnic differences might influence the role of HPV in oral cancer, necessitating further research in diverse populations.
  • Focus on HPV: While the study focused on HPV, the authors suggest that other infectious agents, such as bacteria or viruses, might play a role in OC-SCC pathogenesis. They propose analyzing the metagenomic sequences for other nonhuman reads (viruses, bacteria, fungi) to explore these possibilities.
  • Further Research: The authors emphasize the need for more extensive research to explore other infectious agents and to conduct comprehensive bioinformatics analyses and validation studies. They also note that the role of HPV in oral cancer might be more complex and potentially linked to specific geographic or ethnic groups.

Summary updated

Abstract

The aim of this study was to carry out a case control study comparing the HPV genome in patients with oral cavity squamous cell carcinoma (OC-SCC) to normal patients using metagenomic shotgun sequencing. We recruited 50 OC-SCC cases which were then matched with a control patient by age, gender, race, smoking status and alcohol status. DNA was extracted from oral wash samples from all patients and whole genome shotgun sequencing performed. The raw sequence data was cleaned, reads aligned with the human genome (GRCH38), nonhuman reads identified and then HPV genotypes identified using HPViewer. In the 50 patients with OC-SCC, the most common subsite was tongue in 26 (52%). All patients were treated with primary resection and neck dissection. All but 2 tumors were negative on p16 immunohistochemistry. There were no statistically significant differences between the cases and controls in terms of gender, age, race/ethnicity, alcohol drinking, and cigarette smoking. There was no statistically significant difference between the cancer samples and control samples in the nonhuman DNA reads (medians 4,228,072 vs. 5,719,715, P value = 0.324). HPV was detected in 5 cases (10%) of OC-SCC (genotypes 10, 16, 98) but only 1 tumor sample (genotype 16) yielded a high number of reads to suggest a role in the etiology of OC-SCC. HPV was detected in 4 control patients (genotypes 16, 22, 76, 200) but all had only 1-2 HPV reads per human genome. Genotypes of HPV are rarely found in patients with oral cancer.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ganly2021case,
  author = {Ian Ganly and Zhiheng Pei and Yuhan Hao and Yingfei Ma and Matthew Rosenthal and Zheng-lin Wu and Jocelyn Migliacci and Bin Huang and Nora Katabi and Wenzhi Tseng and Stuart M. Brown and Yi‐Wei Tang and Liying Yang},
  title = {{Case control study comparing the HPV genome in patients with oral cavity squamous cell carcinoma to normal patients using metagenomic shotgun sequencing}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-021-83197-x},
}
Figure