Cartographic Body of Knowledge – work in progress

Terje Midtbø, Temenoujka Bandrova, Georg Gärtner, Miljenko Lapaine, Liqiu Meng, Jie Shen, Vit Voženílek, Tao WangAbstracts 2023 · DOI

Abstract

The International Cartographic Association (ICA) is currently developing a dynamic, web-based Cartographic Body of Knowledge (CartoBoK). This initiative seeks to modernize the field by moving away from static documentation toward a "Living Textbook" framework. By utilizing a community-driven knowledge graph, the CartoBoK aims to centralize core concepts and evolve alongside rapid technological advancements in mapping and data science.

Introduction

Cartography is undergoing a significant transformation. While the discipline has deep historical roots, the emergence of modern digital tools and data science has expanded its boundaries significantly. Traditional "Bodies of Knowledge" (BoK) are typically published as static documents or books, which often become obsolete shortly after publication due to the fast pace of technological change. To address this, the International Cartographic Association (ICA) is developing the Cartographic Body of Knowledge (CartoBoK)—a dynamic, web-based platform designed to centralize and modernize the field's core concepts.

The Need for a Dynamic Framework

A primary motivation for the CartoBoK is the gap left by existing resources. For instance, while the GIS&T Body of Knowledge is comprehensive for geographic information science, it does not fully capture the specific nuances and breadth of cartography. Furthermore, there is a pressing need to redefine foundational terms—most notably, "What is a map?"—to reflect the digital, interactive, and 3D realities of the 21st century. The CartoBoK aims to provide a "Living Textbook" that can be updated continuously.

Methodology: The Living Textbook

Managed by a dedicated ICA Working Group, the project shifts the BoK from a static book to an interactive platform. The approach involves several key strategies:

  • Collaborative Sourcing: Keywords were solicited from all ICA commissions to ensure representation across the wide spectrum of cartographic activity, from historical cartography to 3D visualization.
  • The "Living Textbook" Framework: Utilizing a web-based framework developed by Universiteit Twente, the project allows for real-time updates rather than versioned editions.
  • Concept Elaboration: Keywords are expanded into full concepts, including definitions, detailed descriptions, examples, usage guidelines, synonyms, and learning outcomes.
  • Knowledge Graph Visualization: Instead of a linear table of contents, the CartoBoK uses a knowledge graph to visualize relationships and dependencies between concepts.

Knowledge Graph and Data Structure

The "data" driving the project consists of a curated keyword repository provided by ICA commissions and ongoing contributions from subject matter experts. A central insight of the project is that the BoK must be a dynamic digital platform to keep pace with innovation. The knowledge graph approach allows for cross-commission synergy, mapping overlapping interests explicitly rather than duplicating them in silos.

Initial knowledge graph showing the interconnectedness of cartographic terms such as Map Projections and Web Mapping.

Current Progress and Results

The initial infrastructure for the CartoBoK is now live at bok.cartography.no. The project has successfully adopted the "Living Textbook" model and presented a visual proof of concept through an initial knowledge graph. This graph illustrates the interconnectedness of terms like Toponym, Exonym, Map Projections, and Web Mapping, with "Map" serving as the central anchor node. The paper marks a successful transition from the planning phase to the active compilation phase, involving a broad international coalition of experts.

Challenges and Future Directions

As a work in progress, the primary challenge is moving from a list of keywords to a fully populated library of concept descriptions. The project relies heavily on voluntary contributions from ICA members, making consistent quality and momentum a logistical challenge. Additionally, finalizing the definition of "a map" remains an ongoing task requiring broad community consensus. Future work will focus on inspiring the global cartographic community to engage in the compilation process to ensure the BoK accurately represents the entire field.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{midtb2023cartographic,
  author = {Terje Midtbø and Temenoujka Bandrova and Georg Gärtner and Miljenko Lapaine and Liqiu Meng and Jie Shen and Vit Voženílek and Tao Wang},
  title = {{Cartographic Body of Knowledge – work in progress}},
  booktitle = {Abstracts},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.5194/ica-abs-6-166-2023},
}
Figure