Carpe diem or carpe mañana? Emotion priming affects intertemporal choice among Internet addicts and normal Internet users

Hongxia Li, Wen ShanFrontiers in Psychology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that while positive emotions generally encourage long-term thinking, "current joy" actually makes Internet addicts more impulsive, triggering a "carpe diem" (seize the day) mindset. Conversely, "current regret" can act as a cognitive brake, pushing addicts toward "carpe mañana" (waiting for a better future reward) by prompting reflection on past behavior.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Internet addiction (IA) is often characterized by a failure in intertemporal choice—the ability to choose a larger, delayed reward over a smaller, immediate one. We know addicts are generally more impulsive, but the relationship between their emotional state and their decision-making is complex.

Existing research often treats "positive" and "negative" emotions as monoliths. This paper addresses the gap by distinguishing between emotional valence (general good/bad vibes), current emotions (how you feel right now about a choice), and expected emotions (how you think you’ll feel later). The authors aim to uncover whether specific emotional "primes" can be used as interventions to help addicts focus on long-term goals rather than immediate digital gratification.

Methods

The researchers conducted three distinct experiments using a mix of Internet addicts (recruited from a withdrawal school) and "normal" Internet users.

  • The Metric: In all studies, the dependent variable was Subjective Value (V), derived from a "Delay Discounting Task." Participants chose between receiving a smaller amount of money immediately (e.g., 50 RMB) or 1,000 RMB in six months. A higher V indicates better self-control and long-term focus.
  • Experiment 1 (Valence): Used the Chinese Affective Picture System (CAPS) to prime participants with positive, negative, or neutral images before the task.
  • Experiment 2 (Current Emotion): Used a stock market simulation. Participants "invested" in stocks; the "regret" group was shown a stock crash regardless of their choice, while the "joy" group saw rapid appreciation.
  • Experiment 3 (Expected Emotion): Used a descriptive writing task where participants imagined and wrote about events where they expected to feel intense joy or regret after making a decision.

Datasets

The study relied on primary data collection rather than pre-existing large-scale datasets:

  • Participants: A total of 285 individuals across three studies, including students from North China University of Technology and residents of an Internet addiction withdrawal school in Beijing.
  • Stimuli: The Chinese Affective Picture System (CAPS) was used for emotional priming in Experiment 1, providing a standardized benchmark for emotional intensity and valence in a Chinese cultural context.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Addict Baseline: Across all studies, Internet addicts consistently showed lower subjective values than normal users, confirming that IA is fundamentally linked to higher impulsivity and a "shorter" mental timeline.
  • The "Current Joy" Paradox: This is the "aha" moment of the paper. While general positive vibes (Exp 1) and expected joy (Exp 3) help people wait for bigger rewards, current joy (Exp 2) makes addicts significantly more impulsive. The authors suggest this is due to decision-making inertia: feeling good "in the moment" encourages addicts to keep seeking immediate rewards.
  • Regret as a Tool: For addicts, feeling current regret actually increased their ability to wait for a future reward. The authors theorize that regret triggers a "carpe mañana" mindset, where the pain of a recent bad choice (like a digital binge) makes them more likely to pause and value the future.
  • Hope Theory Framework: The authors use "Hope Theory" to explain why expected joy works. When we imagine a positive future, it clarifies our "pathway thinking" (how to get there) and "agency" (the motivation to do it), making the six-month wait feel worth it.

Key Results

  • Experiment 1: Positive priming led to higher subjective values (~784 for normal users, ~737 for addicts) compared to negative priming (~655 for normal, ~501 for addicts).
  • Experiment 2 (The Twist): When primed with current joy, addicts' subjective value plummeted to 491.67, compared to 746.15 when primed with current regret. For normal users, current joy actually resulted in a slightly higher (though not always significant) value than regret.
  • Experiment 3: Priming expected joy significantly boosted subjective value for both groups (Normal: 854.17; Addicts: 746.15) compared to expected regret (Normal: 702.50; Addicts: 461.11).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mediation Analysis: While the authors use Hope Theory to explain the results, they did not directly measure "hope" as a mediating variable. Future work should quantify whether hope levels actually shift during priming.
  • Reward Type: The study used monetary rewards. Since Internet addiction involves "digital" rewards (likes, levels, dopamine hits), it’s unclear if these emotional effects translate perfectly from cash to screen time.
  • Scale Modernity: The authors acknowledge that the Internet Addiction Test (IAT) used is an older instrument; future studies should use updated diagnostic criteria that reflect modern mobile and social media usage.
  • Practical Application: The findings suggest that interventions for addicts shouldn't just be about "cheering them up." Instead, training them to visualize future joy or reflect on past regret might be more effective than simply inducing a positive mood in the present.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this digitalized era, Internet addiction has been a severe problem that needs imperative solutions derived from the same mechanism that leads to its addiction. To uncover a more nuanced mechanism for Internet addiction in association with decision-making focus and emotions and thus generate effective interventions, we conducted three experiments to investigate how various forms of emotion priming affect intertemporal choice among Internet addicts and normal Internet users. We divided the emotions into three categories, namely emotional valence (negative and positive emotions), expected emotion type (expected regret, expected joy), and current emotion type (current regret, current joy). In experiment one, we examined the effect of two participant types (Internet addicts and normal Internet users) with three emotion valences (positive, negative, and neutral). In experiment two, we examined the effect of two participant types (Internet addicts and normal Internet users) with three current emotion types (current regret, joy, and neutral). In experiment three, we examined the effect of two participant types (Internet addicts and normal Internet users) with two expected emotion types (expected regret and expected joy). We conducted a completely randomized experimental design in each experiment and used subjective value as the dependent variable index of intertemporal choice. The results showed that the subjective value of Internet addicts was significantly lower than that of normal Internet users across three studies. The subjective value of individuals primed with positive emotions was significantly higher than those primed with negative emotions, no matter whether they were normal Internet users or addicts (experiment one). The subjective value of individuals primed with expected joy was significantly higher than those primed with expected regret, no matter whether they were normal Internet users or addicts (experiment three). When primed with current joy, however, the Internet addicts' subjective value was significantly lower than when primed with current regret, but this did not apply to normal Internet users (experiment two). These results suggest positive emotions and expected joy enhanced long-term goals and greater rewards focus on intertemporal decision-making compared to negative emotions and expected regret. However, current joy facilitated short-term goals, and smaller rewards focus on intertemporal decision-making compared to current regret. The theoretical and practical implications for Internet addiction are also discussed in this paper.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022carpe,
  author = {Hongxia Li and Wen Shan},
  title = {{Carpe diem or carpe mañana? Emotion priming affects intertemporal choice among Internet addicts and normal Internet users}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2022.994778},
}
Figure