Caregiver insights on challenges and needs in fecal incontinence products: a mixed methods study

Lanlan Yu, Fengming Hao, Jie Li, Yingjie Hu, Fei Xiong, Ling Chen, Wenzhi CaiFrontiers in Public Health 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Disparities in FI product use stem mainly from economic constraints, training gaps, and limited awareness. Enhancing caregiver training, streamlining product distribution, and broadening insurance support could strengthen FI management and reduce HAIs. Although the findings offer useful guidance for policy and practice, their generalizability is limited by the single geographic setting and reliance on self-reported data. Future studies should examine diverse institutional contexts to validate and extend these results.

Introduction

Fecal incontinence (FI) affects up to 20% of long-term, bed-bound hospital patients. Beyond the loss of dignity, poor FI management is a major clinical risk factor for skin breakdown, specifically incontinence-associated dermatitis (IAD), and the spread of healthcare-associated infections (HAIs).

This mixed-methods study reveals a significant "innovation gap" in FI management. While the medical device industry has developed sophisticated fecal collection systems—ranging from adhesive perianal pouches to indwelling diversion devices—their real-world adoption remains surprisingly low. Most caregivers still rely on traditional absorbent pads and diapers, which often fail to keep skin dry during frequent liquid FI episodes. This research explores the specific barriers faced by three distinct caregiver groups: family members, nursing assistants, and professional nurses.

Methods

The researchers employed an explanatory sequential mixed-methods design, consisting of two phases:

  1. Quantitative Phase: A cross-sectional survey of 318 caregivers (115 family members, 73 nursing assistants, and 130 registered nurses) across three hospitals in Shenzhen, China. Logistic regression identified variables predicting product choice.
  2. Qualitative Phase: Semi-structured, in-depth interviews with 24 participants (9 nurses, 10 assistants, 5 family members) to provide context to the survey data.

The study followed STROBE guidelines for quantitative reporting and the COREQ checklist for qualitative reporting.

Key Results and Insights

The study identified several critical barriers to the adoption of advanced FI products, segmented by caregiver role.

Awareness and Usage Gaps

A primary finding was the low awareness of advanced collection devices. Only 23.4% of family caregivers and 9.6% of nursing assistants were aware that fecal-collection devices beyond pads existed. Consequently, absorbent products remain the "default" due to their low cost and familiarity, despite their known role in aggravating skin damage.

Usage of fecal incontinence collection products by different caregivers.

Predictors of Product Choice

  • Family Caregivers: Household income was the strongest predictor of choosing premium products (OR = 2.380).
  • Nursing Assistants: Formal training was the most significant predictor for using advanced devices (OR = 8.817).
  • Registered Nurses: Specialized training in IAD (OR = 3.344) and working in an ICU environment (OR = 3.304) were primary drivers for using advanced systems.

Clinical Impact and the "Pad Paradox"

A concerning "Pad Paradox" exists: caregivers continue to use absorbent products even when they fail. Data showed that 100% of family caregivers and 84.8% of nursing assistants continued using only absorbent products after a patient developed IAD.

Usage of fecal incontinence collection products after developing IAD.

The "MacGyver" Effect and Future Needs

Due to procurement gaps, nurses often improvised solutions, such as repurposing tracheostomy tubes for fecal drainage. There is a clear demand for "smart" technology—devices that can automatically cleanse skin or alert caregivers to bowel movements to prevent dermatitis.

Discussion and Limitations

The findings highlight a disconnection between clinical needs and product choices driven by economic constraints and educational deficits. However, the study's generalizability is limited by its focus on a single city (Shenzhen) and reliance on self-reported data for infection rates.

Future research should examine diverse institutional contexts, such as nursing homes versus acute care, and focus on developing integrated "smart" FI management systems to reduce the burden on caregivers and improve patient outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Disparities in FI product use stem mainly from economic constraints, training gaps, and limited awareness. Enhancing caregiver training, streamlining product distribution, and broadening insurance support could strengthen FI management and reduce HAIs. Although the findings offer useful guidance for policy and practice, their generalizability is limited by the single geographic setting and reliance on self-reported data. Future studies should examine diverse institutional contexts to validate and extend these results.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yu2025caregiver,
  author = {Lanlan Yu and Fengming Hao and Jie Li and Yingjie Hu and Fei Xiong and Ling Chen and Wenzhi Cai},
  title = {{Caregiver insights on challenges and needs in fecal incontinence products: a mixed methods study}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2025.1453244},
}
Figure